Fluctuating Geographical Position Within a Geopolitical and Historical Context. Case study: Romania
Abstract
The geographical position of a territory is a statically element strictly determined by mathematical landmarks and by those of the natural background. For all that, different historical and geopolitical events that happened in the course of time, can make the geographical position fluctuate by including a territory / state into territorial aggregates established on less arbitrary criteria. Thus, many interwar authors placed Romania, by geographical criteria, in Central Europe; after 1945 they would include it in Eastern Europe, or in short, in the East, a political-ideological homogeneous territory, but heterogeneous geographically, historically and cultural. With the downfall of political-ideological barriers and the deep-going mutations in the geopolitics of Central and Eastern Europe, Romania’s geographical position should be reconsidered based on objective criteria: geographical, mathematical and last but not least, cultural and economic. This study is also important because some recent works place Romania erroneously in South-Eastern Europe, either in eastern or in Balkan Europe. The work concludes that Romania in a state situated in the south-eastern part of Central Europe. The arguments brought in favour of it have in view to push forward the current stage of knowledge on Romania’s geopolitics.
References
Academy of the Romanian People’s Republic, Institute of Geology and Geography & USSR Academy of Sciences, Institute of Geography. 1960. Monografia geografică a Republicii Populare Romîne (Geographic Monograph of the Romanian People’s Republic), I, Bucharest: Publishing House of the Academy of the Romanian People’s Republic.
Alexandrescu, V., Deică, P. 2002. Romania’s Fluctuating Position on Europe’s Political Map, Romanian Review on Political Geography, IV (1-2), 5-12.
Ancel, J. 1930. Peuples et nations des Balkans (Peoples and Nations in the Balkans), Paris: Armand Colin.
Ancel, J. 1936. Manuel géographique de politique européenne, tome I, L’Europe Centrale (Geographic handbook of European policy), I, Central Europe, Paris.
Arldt, Th. 1917. Die Völker Mitteleuropas und ihre Staatenbildungen Umschlagzeichnung von Oswald Weise (Peoples and States of Central Europe. Sketch by Oswald Weise), Leipzig.
Baroiu, Dr., Mărculeţ, I., Mărculeţ, C. 2005. The dynamics of the main religious confesions in Transylvania (1930-2002), Romanian Review on Political Geography, VII (2), 69-75.
Boulineau, E. 2001. Un géographe traceur de frontières: Emmanuel de Martonne et la Roumanie (A geographer who drew borders: Emmanuel de Martonne and Romania), L’Espace Géographique, 4, 358-369.
Bowd, G., Clayton, D. 2015. Emmanuel de Martonne and the wartime defence of Greater Romania: Circle, set square and spire, Journal of Historical Geography, 47, 50-63.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhg.2014.10.001
Brunet, R., Rey, V. 1996. Geographie Universelle. Europes Orientales, Russie, Asie Centrale (Universal Geography. Eastern Europe, Russia, Central Asia), Paris: Belin / Reclus.
Castellan, G. 1991. Histoire des Balkans (History of Balkans), Paris: Fayard.
Cazacu, M. 1999. Le Danube dans le discours géostratégique et économique roumain (The Danube in the Romanian geostrategic and economic discourse), in Géopolitique du Danube (ed. Michel Fourcher), Paris: Ellipses.
Cândea, M., Bran, F. 2001. Spaţiul geografic românesc. Organizare, amenajare, dezvoltare (The Romanian geographical space. Organization, amenagement, development), Bucharest: Economica Publishing House.
Center for International Studies and Research & “Hérodote” Review 1993. L’état du Monde. Annuaire économique et géopolitique mondial (States of the World. World Economic and Geopolitic Yearbook), Paris: Éditions La Découverte.
Cheers, G. (ed.) 1999. Geografica. Enciclopedia & Atlasul lumii (Geographica. Encyclopaedia & World Atlas), Random House Australia Pty Ltd. (Romanian Ed.: h.f.ullmann & Tandem Verlag Gmbh, 2008).
Conea, I. 1941. Transilvania, inima pământului şi statului românesc (Transylvania, the heart of the Romanian land and state), Geopolitica şi Geoistoria, I, 18-34.
Conea, I. 1942. Carpaţii, hotar natural ? (Carpathians, natural border ?), Geopolitica şi Geoistoria, II, 62-68.
Conea, I. 1944. O poziţie geopolitică (A Geopolitical Position), Geopolitica şi Geoistoria, III, 64-100.
Conea, I. 1967. Cu privire la “teritoriul nucleu’’ de formare a poporului român (Regarding the “core territory’’ of the formation of the Romanian people), Studii şi Cercetări de Geologie, Geofizică şi Geografie, Geografie, XIV (1), 3-14.
Creţan, R. 2006-a. Etnie, confesiune şi comportament electoral în Banat. Stucturi teritoriale, tradiţie, actualitate (Ethnicity, confession and electoral option in Banat. Territorial structures, tradition, actuality), Timişoara: West University Publishing House.
Creţan, R. 2006-b. The evolution and economic activities in the DKMT Euroregion, Review of Historical Geography and Toponomastics,1 (1), 61-78.
Creţan, R., Vesalon, L. 2017. The political economy of hydropower in the communist space: Iron Gates revisited, Tijdschrift voor economische en sociale geografie, 108 (5), 688-701.
https//doi:10.111/tesg.12427
Cvijić, J. 1918. La Péninsule Balcanique (The Balkan Peninsula), Paris: Armand Colin.
Dawson, A.H., Fawn, R. 2002. The Changing Geopolitics of Eastern Europe, London: Routledge.
https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315040080
De Martonne, Emm. 1934. Europe Centrale (Central Europe), in Géographie universelle, IV (1), Paris.
Dingsdale, A. 1999. Redefining “Eastern Europe”: A New Regional Geography of Post-Socialist Europe ?, Geography, 84 (3), 204-221.
Dughin, Al. 1997. Bazele geopoliticii şi viitorul geopolitic al Rusiei (The bases of geopolitics and the geopolitical future of Russia), Moscow: Arktogheea (Romanian Ed. Bucharest: Eurasiatica.ro Publishing House, 2011).
Enciclopedia Universală Britanică (The British Universal Encyclopedia) 2010. Bucharest: Litera Publishing House, 13, Bucharest.
Erdeli, G., Cucu, V. 2005. România. Populaţie, aşezări umane, economie (Romania. Population, Human settlements, Economy), Bucharest: Transversal Publishing House.
Ethnogeographical Map of Central Europe 1942. 1 : 1 000 000, Budapest.
Fourcher, M. (edt.) 1993. Fragments d’Europe (Fragments of Europe), Paris: Fayard.
Fourcher, M. 2000. La République Européenne (European Republic), Paris: Belin.
Generalkarte von Mitteleuropa (General Map of Mitteleuropa) 1937. 1 : 200 000, Vienna: Wiener Militärgeografischen Institut.
Ghinea, D. 1996. Enciclopedia geografică a României (Geographic Encyclopaedia of Romania), I, Bucharest: Encyclopedic Publishing House.
Giurescu, C-C. 1967. Transilvania în istoria poporului român (Transylvania in the history of Romanian people), Bucharest: Minerva Publishing House.
Gottman, J. 1952. La politique des Etats et leur géographie (States policy and their geography), Paris: Armand Colin.
Gusti, D. (coord) 1938. Enciclopedia României (The Encyclopaedia of Romania), I, Bucharest: The Scientific Association for the Encyclopaedia of Romania.
Halecki, O. 1950, The Limits and Divisions of European History, London & New York: Sheet & Ward.
Hardi, T. 2016. Various mental images about the geographical extension of Central, Southeast and Eastern Europe, Bulletin of Geography. Socio-Economic Series, 31, 129-143.
Hassinger, H. 1917. Das geographische Wesen Mitteleuropas, nebst einingen grundsätzlichen Bemerkungen über die geographischen Naturgebiete Europas und ihre Begrenzung (The geographical essence of Central Europe, together with some fundamental observations about the geographical areas of Europe and their limitations), Mitteilungen der Geographischen Gesellschaft, 60, 437-493.
Hassinger, H. 1923. Mitteleuropa (Central Europe), Lexikon der Geographie, 2, Braunschweig, 124-127.
Heiderich, F. 1926. Mitteleuropa (Central Europe), Geographie des Welthandels, 1 (4), Vienna: Aufl.
Höpker, W. 1936. Rumänien diesseits und jenseits der Karpathen (Romania on both sides of the Carpathians), München.
Huntington, S 1997. Ciocnirea civilizaţiilor şi refacerea ordinii mondiale (The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of World Order), Simon & Schuster, New York (Romanian Ed. Oradea: Antet Publishing House, 1998).
Iordan, I. 2006. România. Geografie umană şi economică (Romania. Human and Economic Geography), Bucharest: “România de Mâine” Foundation Publishing House.
Jelavich, B. 1983. History of the Balkans, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Jordan, P. 2005. Großgliederung Europas nach kulturäumlichen Kriterien (Broad classification of Europe according to cultural criteria), Europa Regional, 13 (4), 162-173.
Josan, N. 2002. Destinul geografic al poporului român (The geographical destiny of the Romanian people), Oradea: The University of Oradea Publishing House.
Kinross, L. 1977. The Ottoman Centuries. The Rise and Fall of the Turkish Empire, New York: Morrow Quill Publishers.
Kolosov, V., O’Loughlin, J. 1998. New borders for the new world orders: Territorialities at the fin-de-siecle, Geojournal, 44 (3), 259-273. https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1006846322508
Lacoste, Y. (edt.) 1995. Dictionnaire de Géopolitique (Dictionary of Geopolitics), Paris: Flammarion
Machatschek, F. 1925. Länderkunde von Mitteleuropa (Regional Studies of Mitteleuropa), Enzyklopädie der Erdkunde, Leipzig & Vienna.
Machatschek, F. 1929. Europa als Ganzes (Europe as a whole), Enzyklopädie der Erdkunde, Vienna.
Marcu, S. 2009. The Geopolitics of the Eastern Border of the European Union: The Case of Romania – Moldova – Ukraine, Geopolitics, 14 (3), 409-432. https://doi.org/10.1080/14650040802693796
Mauriel, M-C., Ditter, J-C., Holz, J-M., Lepesant, G., Sanguin, A-L, Schulz, J. 1997. Recomposition de l’Europe Médiane. Dossiers des Images Economiques du Monde (Recomposition of Middle Europe. Folders of the world’s economic images), Paris: CDU-SEDES.
Mishkova, D., Trencsényi, B. (eds) 2017. European Regions and Boundaries: a Conceptual History, New York: Berghahn Books.
Mitteleuropa. Austrian School Atlas by Slanar 1928. 1 : 200 000, Vienna.
Mureşan, C. 1996. Câteva consideraţii asupra formării naţiunilor (Some considerations on the formation of nations) in Central Europe, Etnicity, Nation, Confession, Oradea: Oradea Publishing House.
Mutton, A-F. 1961. Central Europe: A Regional and Human Geography, New York: John Wiley & Sons.
Neguţ, S., Cucu, V., Vlad, L-B. 2004. Geopolitica României (Geopolitics of Romania), Târgovişte: Transversal Publishing House.
Nimigeanu, V. 2001. România. Populaţie, aşezări, economie (Romania. Population, settlements, economy), Iaşi: “Al. I. Cuza” University Publishing House.
Palsky, G. 2002. Emmanuel de Martonne and the ethnographical cartography of Central Europe (1917-1920), Imago Mundi. The International Journal for the History of Geography, 54 (1): 111-119. https://doi.org/10.1080/03085690208592961
Panaite, V. 1997. Pace, război şi comerţ în Islam. Ţările Române şi dreptul otoman al popoarelor, secolele XV-XVII (Peace, war and trade in Islam. Romanian countries and the Ottoman right of the people, 15th-17th centuries), Bucharest: All Publishing House.
Partsch, J-F., Black, C., Mackinder, H-J. 1903. Central Europe, New York: D. Appleton & Co.
Pascu, Şt. 1972. Voievodatul Transilvaniei (Transylvania Voivodeship), I, Cluj-Napoca: Dacia Publishing House.
Pomian, K. 1991. Les particularités historiques de l’Europe centrale et orientale (The historical pecularities of Central and Eastern Europe), Le Débat, 63.
Posea, Gr. (edt.) 1982. Enciclopedia geografică a României (Geographic Encyclopaedia of Romania), Bucharest: Scientific and Encyclopedic Publishing House.
Penck, A. 1915. Politisch-geographische Lehren des Krieges (The politico-geographical teachings of the war), Meereskunde, 9 (10).
Pop, I-A. 1994. Observaţii privitoare la structura etnică şi confesională a Ungariei şi Transilvaniei medievale, sec. IX-XVI (Observations regarding the ethnic and confessional structure of medieval Hungary and Transylvania, 9th-16th centuries), Istoria României. Pagini Transilvane (edt. Dan Berindei), Cluj-Napoca, 9-44.
Pop, I-A. 1996. Românii şi maghiarii în secolele IX-XIV. Geneza statului medieval Transilvania (Romanians and Hungarians in the 9th-14th centuries. The genesis of the Mediaeval state of Transylvania), Cluj-Napoca: Fundaţia Culturală Română.
Popa, N. 2006. Frontiere, regiuni transfrontaliere şi dezvoltare regională în Europa Mediană (Borders, Cross-border regions and Regional development in Middle Europe), Timişoara: West University Publishing House, Timişoara.
Popescu, G. 2008. The conflicting logics of cross-border reterritorialization: Geopolitics of Euroregions in Eastern Europe, Political Geography, 27 (4), 418-438. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.polgeo.2008.03.002
Posea, Gr., Badea, L. 1984. România, Unităţile de relief - Regionarea geomorfologică) (Romania. Relief units - Geomorphological regionalisation), Bucharest: Scietific & Encyclopedic Publishing House.
Prescott, J-R. 1987. Political Frontiers and Boundaries, Boston: Allen & Unwin.
Prevelakis, G. 1994. Balcanii. Cultură şi geopolitică (Balkans. Culture and geopolitics), Paris: Nathan (Romanian Ed. Bucharest: Corint Publishing House, 2001).
Rădulescu, N-Al. 1938. Poziţia geopolitică a României (The geopolitical position of Romania), Revista Geografică Română, I (1), Cluj: Cartea Românească Publishing House, 13-44.
Rey, V. (coord.), 1998. Les territoires centre-européens. Dilemmes et défis. L’Europe médiane en question (Central European territories. Dilemmas and challenges. The “Middle Europe” in trouble), Paris: La Découverte – Lectio Géographie.
Rey, V., Groza, O., Ianoş, I., Pătroescu, M. 2000. Atlasul României (The Atlas of Romania), Paris: CNRS, GDR Libergéo-La Documentation Française (Romanian Ed. Bucharest: Rao Publishing House, 2006).
Romanian Academy, Institute of Geography 2016, Romania. Space, Society, Environment, The Publishing House of the Romanian Academy, Bucharest.
Romanian Academy, Institute of Geography 2016. România. Natură şi Societate (Romania. Nature and Society), Bucharest: The Publishing House of the Romanian Academy.
Romanian Academy, South-East European Studies Institute 2014. Românii de peste hotare. Memoriu elaborat în anul 1945 de consilierul de legaţie Emil Oprişanu (Romanians from abroad. Memorandum drawn up in 1945 by the Councilor of Legation Emil Oprişanu), Publishing House of the Romanian Academy.
Săgeată, R. 2002. Romania. A Central-European Country, Romanian Review on Political Geography, IV (1-2), 5-14.
Sǎgeatǎ, R. 2009. Romania. A Geopolitical Outline, Potsdamer Geographische Forschungen, 28, 45-58.
Săgeată, R. 2011. Cross-Border Co-operation Euro-regions at the European Union Eastern Border within the Context of Romania’s Accession to the Schengen Area, Geographica Pannonica, 15 (4), 127-135.
Schmidt, E. 1932. Die verfassungsrechtliche und politische Struktur des rumänischen Staates in ihrer historischen Entwicklung (The constitutional and political structure of the Romanian state in its historical development), München.
Schüssler, M. 1939. Mitteleuropa als Wirklichkeit und Schicksal (Mitteleuropa as reality and destine), 2, Köln: Aufl.
Sievers, W. 1916. Die geographischen Grenzen Mitteleuropas (The geographical boundaries of Mitteleuropa), Giessen.
Simileanu, V. 2016. România în „ochiul uraganului” (Romania in the “eye of the hurricane”), Bucharest: Top Form Publishing House.
Simileanu, V., Săgeată, R. 2009. Geopolitica României (Geopolitics of Romania), Bucharest: Top Form Publishing House.
Sinnhuber, K-A. 1954. Central Europe-Mitteleuropa-Europe Centrale. An Analysis of a Geographical Term, Transactions and Papers, Institute of British Geographers, 20, 15-39.
The European Council 1992. Bulletin of the European Communities, Lisbon, 6. aei.pitt.edu/1420/1/Lisbon_june_1992.pdf (Acc. Dec. 2018).
Turner, F-J. 1920. The Frontier in American History, New York: Henry Holt (First Ed.).
Turnock, D. 1972. Romania, Encyclopaedia Britannica, Chicago.
Turnock, D. 2001, Romania: Contemporary geopolitical perspectives, Geopolitics, 6 (1), 119-140.
https://doi.org/10.1080/14650040108407710
Ubersichkarte von Mitteleuropa (Study Map of Mitteleuropa) 1937. 1 : 750 000, Prague.
United Nations Statistics Division 2017. Composition of Macro Geographical (Continental) Regions, Geographical Sub-regions, and Selected Economic and Other Groupings.
https://unstats.un.org/unsd/methodology/m49 (Acc. Ian. 2019).
University of Bucharest, Institute of Geography 1983. Geografia României (The Geography of Romania), I, Bucharest: Publishing House of the Academy of the Romanian Socialist Republic.
Unstead, J-F. 1927. Europe of today, London.
Văran, C., Creţan, R. 2018. Place and the spatial politics of intergenerational remembrance of the Iron Gates displacements, 1966-1972, Area, 50 (4), 509-519. https://doi.org/10.111/area.12387.
Vogel, W. 1922. Politische Geographie (Political Geography), Lepzig & Berlin.
Wirsing, G. 1932. Zwischeneuropa und die Deutsche Zukunft (Between Europe and German future), Leipzig.
