Towards a Comprehensive Framework of Mediation Success: EU Mediation in the Belgrade–Pristina Dialogue
The European Union has gained increasing importance in international mediation over the last decade. Driven by the powerful role assigned to the High Representative and the European External Action Service by the Lisbon treaty, the EU has been facilitating high-level talks between Belgrade and Pristina over their relationship since 2011. Although the signing of the Brussels Agreement in 2013 was a breakthrough, developments in north Kosovo suggest that the process might have significant shortcomings. This paper’s guiding research question of how to assess mediation success addresses the existing gap between external and internal perspectives. It introduces a comprehensive analytical framework to assess mediation success that combines several previously suggested ideas into a single framework. The question of how to measure successful mediation contributes not only to theory development but targets the interface between science and policymaking. The framework, as applied to the EU mediation ef- forts in the Belgrade–Pristina dialogue, has unveiled the in conclusive character of the process. Whilst being a success for the European Union, this paper argues a deficit in local legitimacy exists. Increasing levels of internal violence in Kosovo hint that it failed to fully address the root causes of the dispute.
Amadio Viceré, Maria Giulia. 2016. “The roles of the President of the European Council and the High Representative in leading EU foreign policy on Kosovo.” Journal of European Integration 38 (5): 557–570.
Assembly of the Republic of Kosovo. 2011. “Resolution-For dialogue between Republic of Kosovo and Republic of Serbia”.
Balkan Insight. 2012. “EU: Serbia Does Not Have to Recognize Kosovo”. Accessed January 12, 2017. http://www.balkaninsight.com/en/article/eu-does-not-request- serbia-to-recognize-kosovo.
Balkan Investigative Reporting Network, Internews Kosova, and Centre for Research Transparency and Accountability. 2014. “Big Deal - Civic Oversight of the Kosovo- Serbia Agreement Implementation”.
BBC. 2011. “Kosovo tense after deadly clash on Serbian border”. Accessed January 12, 2017. http://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-14303165.
BBC. 2018. “Top Kosovo Serb politician Oliver Ivanovic shot dead”. Accessed March 27, 2018. http://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-42701712.
Beardsley, Kyle. 2006. “Mediation Style and Crisis Outcomes.” Journal of Conflict Resolution 50 (1): 58–86.
Beardsley, Kyle. 2011. The Mediation Dilemma. Ithaca: Cornell University Press. Beha, Adem. 2015. “Disputes over the 15-point agreement on normalization of relations between Kosovo and Serbia.” Nationalities Papers 43(1): 102–121.
Bercovitch, Jacob, Theodore Anagnoson, and Donnette Wille. 1991. “Some Conceptual Issues and Empirical Trends in the Study of Successful Mediation in International Relations.” Journal of Peace Research 28 (1): 7–17.
Bercovitch, Jacob, and Gerald Schneider. 2000. “Who Mediates? The Political Economy of International Conflict Management.” Journal of Peace Research 37 (2): 145–165.
Bercovitch, Jacob. 2006. “Mediation success or failure: The search for the elusive criteria.” Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution 7 (2): 289–302.
Bercovitch, Jacob, and Karl DeRouen. 2004. “Mediation in Internationalized Ethnic Conflicts: Assessing the Determinants of a Successful Process.” Armed Forces & Society 30 (2): 147–170.
Bercovitch, Jacob, and Paul F. Diehl. 1997. “Conflict management of enduring rivalries: The frequency, timing, and short-term impact of mediation.” International Interactions 22 (4): 299–320.
Bercovitch, Jacob, and Judith Fretter. 2004. Regional guide to international conflict and management from 1945 to 2003. Washington, D.C: CQ Press.
Bercovitch, Jacob, and Richard Jackson. 2009. Conflict resolution in the twenty-first century: principles, methods, and approaches. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
Bercovitch, Jacob, and Scott Sigmund Gartner. 2006. “Is There Method in the Madness of Mediation? Some Lessons for Mediators from Quantitative Studies of Mediation.” International Interactions 32 (4): 329–354.
Bergmann, Julian, and Arne Niemann. 2015. “Mediating International Conflicts: The European Union as an Effective Peacemaker?: The EU as mediator in international conflicts.” JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies 53 (5): 957–975.
Bickerton, Christopher J., Dermot Hodson, and Uwe Puetter. 2015. „The New Intergovernmentalism: European Integration in the Post-Maastricht Era: The new intergovernmentalism.” JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies 53(4): 703–722.
Bieber, Florian. 2015. “The Serbia-Kosovo Agreements: An EU Success Story?” Review of Central and East European Law 40(3–4): 285–319.
Böhmelt, Tobias. 2011. “Disaggregating Mediations: The Impact of Multiparty Mediation.” British Journal of Political Science 41 (04): 859–881.
Brandenburg, Natalie C. 2017. “EU Mediation as an Assemblage of Practices: Introducing a New Approach to the Study of EU Conflict Resolution: Assembling EU mediation.” JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies 55 (5): 993–1008.
B92. 2008. “ICJ move direct challenge to EU”. Accessed January 12, 2017. http://www. b92.net/eng/news/politics.php?yyyy=2008&mm=08&dd=03&nav_id=52409.
B92. 2011. “Kosovo recognition ‘not condition for integrations”. Accessed January 12, 2017. http://www.b92.net/eng/news/politics.php?yyyy=2011&mm=05&dd=20&nav_ id=74433.
Capussela, Andrea Lorenzo. 2016. “Kosovo: Political Evolution and the Negotiations with Serbia.”IEMed. Mediterranean Yearbook 2016: 182–185.
CNN. 2008. “Kosovo celebrates amid Serb protests”. CNN, 2008. Accessed January 12, 2017. http://edition.cnn.com/2008/WORLD/europe/02/17/kosovo. independence/.
Council of the European Union. 2013. “Council and Commission Decision of 22 July on the conclusion of the Stabilisation and Association Agreement between the European Communities and their Member States of the one part, and the Republic of Serbia, of the other part.” Official Journal of the European Union, L278/14.
Council of the European Union. 2012. 3210th Council meeting “General Affairs”. Press Release. Brussels.
Council of the European Union. 2014a. “First Accession Conference with Serbia.”
Council of the European Union. 2014b. “Main aspects and basic choices of the CFSP” (Part II, point E, paragraph 25 of the Interinstitutional Agreement of 2 December 2013) – 2013 – Annual report from the High Representative of the European Union for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy to the European Parliament.
Davis, Laura. 2014. EU foreign policy, transitional justice and mediation: principle, policy and practice. London, New York: Routledge.
Demjaha, Agon. 2017. “Inter-Ethnic Relations in Kosovo.”SEEU Review 12 (1): 181–196. Diehl, Paul F., and Gary Goertz. 2000. War and peace in international rivalry. Ann Arbor: University Of Michigan Press.
DW. 2007. “Serbia Rejects UN Plan for Kosovo”. Accessed January 12, 2017. http:// www.dw.com/en/serbia-rejects-un-plan-for-kosovo/a-2351650.
Economides, Spyros, and James Ker-Lindsay. 2015. “‘Pre-Accession Europeanization’: The Case of Serbia and Kosovo: Pre-Accession Europeanization.” JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies 53 (5): 1027–1044.
Edmead, Frank. 1971. Analysis and prediction in international mediation. New York: United Nations Institute for training and Research.
EEAS. 2013. “Serbia and Kosovo reach landmark deal”.
Ejdus, Filip. 2014. The Brussels Agreement and Serbia ‘s National Interests: A Positive Balance Sheet? Belgrade: Konrad Adenauer Stiftung.
Ejdus, Filip, and Ana E. Juncos. 2018. “Reclaiming the local in EU peacebuilding: Effectiveness, ownership, and resistance.” Contemporary Security Policy 39 (1): 4–27.
Ernst, Andreas. 2014. “The April Agreement - A Step towards Normalization between Belgrade and Pristina?” Contemporary Southeastern Europe 1(1): 122–124.
EURACTIV 2018. “Tensions as Kosovo police arrest senior Serbian official”. Accessed March 28, 2018. https://www.euractiv.com/section/enlargement/news/tensions-as- kosovo-police-arrest-senior-serbian-official.
European Commission. 2011a. “Commission Opinion on Serbia’s application for membership of the European Union”.
---. 2011b. “Enlargement Strategy and Main Challenges 2011–2012”.
---. 2016. “Towards an EU strategy for international cultural relations”.
Frazier, Derrick V., and William J. Dixon. 2006. “Third-Party Intermediaries and Negotiated Settlements, 1946–2000.” International Interactions 32(4): 385–408.
Frei, Daniel. 1976. “Conditions affecting the effectiveness of mediation.” Peace Science Society (International) Papers (26): 67–84.
Gartner, Scott Sigmund. 2014. “The Influence of Directive Strategies on Settlement Duration.” International Negotiation 19(2): 201–220.
Gashi, Krenar, Vjosa Musliu, and Jan Orbie. 2017. “Mediation Through Recontextualization: The European Union and The Dialogue Between Kosovo and Serbia.” European Foreign Affairs Review 22 (4): 33–50.
Girke, Natalie C. 2015. “A matter of balance: the European Union as a mediator in Yemen.” European Security 24 (4): 509–524.
Hamilton, Aubrey. 2012. From Technical Agreements to Political Haggling: The Kosovo-Serbia Dialogue and the North of Kosovo. Pristina: Group for Legal and Political Studies.
Heidelberg Institute for International Conflict Research (HIIK). 1999. Conflict Barometer 1999 - 2015. Conflict Barometer. Heidelberg: University of Heidelberg.
Hill, Christopher, and Karen Elizabeth Smith. 2000. European foreign policy: key documents. London, New York: Routledge.
International Court of Justice. 2010. “Accordance with international law of the unilateral declaration of independence in respect of Kosovo - Advisory Opinion.” The Hague: International Court of Justice.
Jarstad, Anna, and Timothy D. Sisk, eds. 2008. From war to democracy: dilemmas of peacebuilding. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Katz Jameson, Jessica. 1999. “Toward A Comprehensive Model For The Assessment Of Intraorganizational Conflict: Developing The Framework.” International Journal of Conflict Management 10 (3): 268–294.
Kleiboer, Marieke. 1996. “Understanding Success and Failure of International Mediation.” Journal of Conflict Resolution 40 (2): 360–389.
Kosovar Center for Security Studies. 2015. “Public Perceptions on Kosovo’s Foreign Policy and Political Dialogue with Serbia – Kosovo Security Barometer.” Pristina: Kosovar Center for Security Studies.
---. 2017. “Kosovo Security Barometer: Trends of Perception towards Kosovo’s Foreign Policy and Dialogue with Serbia - Covering period from 2013 – 2016.” Pristina: Kosovar Center for Security Studies.
Kosovo Police. 2015. “Annual Report 2015.” Policia e Kosovës / Drejtoria për Planifikim Strategjik dhe Çështje Ligjore.
Kriesberg, Louis, and Stuart J. Thorson, eds. 1991. Timing the de-escalation of international conflicts. Got ed. Syracuse studies on peace and conflict resolution. Syracuse, N.Y: Syracuse University Press.
Maundi, Mohammed Omar, ed. 2006. Getting in: mediators’ entry into the settlement of African conflicts. Washington, D.C: United States Institute of Peace Press.
Michael Greig, J., and Patrick M. Regan. 2008. “When Do They Say Yes? An Analysis of the Willingness to Offer and Accept Mediation in Civil Wars.” International Studies Quarterly 52 (4): 759–781.
Ministry for Dialogue. 2016. “Brussels Agreements - Implementation State of Play - 16 June - 25 November 2016.” Pristina: Republic of Kosovo.
Ministry of European Integration. 2017. “Public Opinion Poll: European Orientation of Serbian Citizens” (June 2017). Belgrade.
Nathan, Laurie. 1999. “‘When Push Comes to Shove’: The Failure of International Mediation in African Civil Wars.” Track Two: Constructive Approaches to Community and Political Conflict 8 (2).
Nilsson, Desirée. 2012. “Anchoring the Peace: Civil Society Actors in Peace Accords and Durable Peace.”International Interactions 38(2): 243–266.
Office for Kosovo and Metohija and Office for the Coordination of Affairs in the Process of Negotiation with the Provisional Institutions of Self-Government in Pristina. 2017. “Progress Report on the Dialogue between Belgrade and Pristina (October 2016 - April 2017).” Belgrade: Government of the Republic of Serbia.
Peen Rodt, Annemarie. 2012. “EU Performance in Military Conflict Management.” In the European Union as a Global Conflict Manager, edited by R.G. Whitman and S. Wolff, 169–188. London: Routledge.
Pehar, Drazen. 2001. “Use of ambiguities in peace agreements.” In Language and Diplomacy, edited by J. Kurbalija and H. Slavik, 163–200. Malta: DiploProjects.
Phillips, David L. 2012. Liberating Kosovo: coercive diplomacy and U.S. intervention. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Plänitz, Erik, and Sonja Stojanovic Gajic. 2017. “Report on impact of EU engagement on mediation and local level dialogue initiatives in Western Balkans.” Deliverable 5.2. EU - CIVCAP.
Popović, Miloš. 2017. “Public Opinion on the Security of Serbia and Dialogue with Pristina.” Belgrade: Centre for Security Policy.
Pushkina, Darya. 2006. “A recipe for success? Ingredients of a successful peacekeeping mission.” International Peacekeeping 13 (2): 133–149.
Radio Free Europe. 2011. “Kosovo Leader Hashim Thaci: NATO Intervention ‘Was the Only Righteous and Humane Solution’”. Accessed January 12, 2017. http:// www.rferl.org/a/kosovo_leader_thaci_intervention_was_the_only_righteous_and_ humane_solution/3538318.html.
Randazzo, Elisa. 2017. Beyond liberal peacebuilding: a critical exploration of the local turn. Abingdon, Oxon, New York: Routledge.
Regan, Patrick M., and Aysegul Aydin. 2006. “Diplomacy and Other Forms of Intervention in Civil Wars.” Journal of Conflict Resolution 50(5): 736–756.
Regan, Patrick M., and Allan C. Stam. 2000. “In the Nick of Time: Conflict Management, Mediation Timing, and the Duration of Interstate Disputes.” International Studies Quarterly 44(2): 239–260.
Reuters. 2011. “Ethnic Serbs fire at NATO troops in Kosovo”. Accessed January 12, 2017. http://www.reuters.com/article/kosovo-nato-idUSBYT76945420110727.
Savun, Burcu. 2008. “Information, Bias, and Mediation Success.” International Studies Quarterly 52 (1): 25–47.
Secretary General. 2005. Letter dated 7 October 2005 from the Secretary-General addressed to the President of the Security Council.
Sheppard, Blair. 1984. “Third party conflict intervention: A procedural framework.” Research in Organizational Behavior 6: 141–190.
Smith, William P. 1985. “Effectiveness of the Biased Mediator.” Negotiation Journal 1 (4): 363–372.
Spörl, Gerhard. 2007. “The Kosovo Failure - Mission Impossible in the Balkans”. Spiegel Online. Accessed January 12, 2017. http://www.spiegel.de/international/ europe/the-kosovo-failure-mission-impossible-in-the-balkans-a-522406.html
Subotić, Jelena. 2011. “Europe is a State of Mind: Identity and Europeanization in the Balkans.” International Studies Quarterly 55 (2): 309–330.
Tamminen, Tanja. 2016. “Challenges: EU Civilian Crisis Management and the Objective of Impact Assessment—Kosovo as an Example of Complexity.” In Complexity thinking for peacebuilding practice and evaluation, edited by Emery Brusset, Cedric De Coning, and Bryn W Hughes, 111–139. UK: Palgrave.
Touval, Saadia. 2003. “Mediation and Foreign Policy.” International Studies Review 5 (4): 91–95.
Touval, Saadia, and I. William Zartman, eds. 1985. International mediation in theory and practice. SAIS papers in international affairs No. 6. Boulder: Washington, D.C: Westview Press, Foreign Policy Institute, School of Advanced International Studies, Johns Hopkins University.
UN ICTY. 2007. “Prosecutor’s statement on Serbia’s cooperation with her office.” The Hague: International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia.
UN Security Council. “Security Council resolution 1244 [on the deployment of international civil and security presences in Kosovo]” S/RES/1244 (1999).
Visoka, Gëzim. 2017. “Peace as Normalisation.” In Shaping Peace in Kosovo: The Politics of Peacebuilding and Statehood, edited by Gëzim Visoka, 183–219. Cham: Springer International Publishing.
Vuković, Siniša. 2014. “International mediation as a distinct form of conflict management.” International Journal of Conflict Management 25 (1): 61–80.
Wall, James A., Rhetta L. Standifer, and John B. Stark. 2001. “Mediation: A Current Review and Theory Development.” The Journal of Conflict Resolution 45 (3): 370–391.
Wallensteen, Peter, and Isak Svensson. 2014. “Talking peace: International mediation in armed conflicts.” Journal of Peace Research 51 (2): 315–327.
Wilkenfeld, Jonathan; Kathleen Young; Victor Asal, and David Quinn. 2003. “Mediating International Crises: Cross-National and Experimental Perspectives.” Journal of Conflict Resolution 47 (3): 279–301.
Yin, Robert K. 1984. Case study research: design and methods. Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications.
Zartman, I William. 2001. “The timing of peace initiatives: Hurting stalemates and ripe moments.” Global Review of Ethnopolitics 1 (1): 8–18.
Zenelaj, Reina, Nimet Beriker, and Emre Hatipoglu. 2015. Determinants of mediation success in post-conflict Bosnia: a focused comparison.” Australian Journal of International Affairs 69 (4): 414–437.
Authors retain copyright of the published papers and grant to the publisher the non-exclusive right to publish the article, to be cited as its original publisher in case of reuse, and to distribute it in all forms and media.
The published articles will be distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY). It is allowed to copy and redistribute the material in any medium or format, and remix, transform, and build upon it for any purpose, even commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given to the original author(s), a link to the license is provided and it is indicated if changes were made. / The published articles will be distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution ShareAlike 4.0 International license (CC BY-SA). It is allowed to copy and redistribute the material in any medium or format, and remix, transform, and build upon it for any purpose, even commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given to the original author(s), a link to the license is provided, it is indicated if changes were made and the new work is distributed under the same license as the original.
Users are required to provide full bibliographic description of the original publication (authors, article title, journal title, volume, issue, pages), as well as its DOI code. In electronic publishing, users are also required to link the content with both the original article published in Journal of Regional Security and the licence used.
Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.
Authors are permitted to deposit author’s pre-print / author’s post-print (accepted version) / publisher's version (PDF) of their work in an institutional repository, subject-based repository, author's personal website (including social networking sites, such as ResearchGate, Academia.edu, etc.), and/or departmental website prior or during the submission process / at any time after the acceptance of the manuscript / at any time after publication.
Full bibliographic information (authors, article title, journal title, volume, issue, pages) about the original publication must be provided and links must be made to the article's DOI and the license.