State Capture, Hybrid Regimes, and Security Sector Reform
Abstract
In this introduction into the special issue on state capture and security sector governance, we argue that state capture is a relevant concept that helps us understand the current autocratisation and the rise of hybrid regimes. We argue that the extraction of public resources via party patronage, privatization of public administration, judiciary, security institutions, and media are vital for influencing political competition. In the second part of the article, we argue that the concept of state capture brings added value to the understanding of security governance and transformations. We show why the parts or whole of security and justice institutions are the inevitable targets of state capture and what it means to understand the success of security sector reform (SSR). Finally, we examine a range of possible positions of the security sector within the captors and what it means for both the literature on state capture and civil-military relations.
References
Abrahamsen, Rita. 2016. “Exporting Decentered Security Governance: The Tensions of Security Sector Reform.” Global Crime, 17 (3): 281–295.
Åslund, Anders. 2013. How Capitalism Was Built: The Transformation of Central and Eastern Europe, Russia, the Caucasus, and Central Asia. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. (2nd Edition)
Baez-Camargo, Claudia and Alena Ledeneva. 2017. “Where Does Informality Stop and Corruption Begin? Informal Governance and the Public/Private Crossover in Mexico, Russia and Tanzania.” The Slavonic and East European Review. 95 (1): 49–75.
Bartlett, William. 2021. “The Yugoslav Successor States: From Self-Management Socialism to Political Capitalism.” In Comparative Economic Studies in Europe. A Thirty Year Review, edited by Wladimir Andreff, 279–296. Cham: Palgrave, Macmillan.
Bearfield, Domonic. A. 2009. “What Is Patronage? A Critical Reexamination.” Public Administration Review 69 (1): 64–76.
Bertuzzi, Luca. 2021. “Facial Recognition Technologies Already Used in 11 EU Countries and Counting, Report Says”. Euractiv. October 26. Accessed 18 April 2021. https://www.euractiv.com/section/data-protection/news/facial-recognition-technologies-already-used-in-11-eu-countries-and-counting-report-says/
Bigo, Digo and Emma McCluskey. 2018. “What is a Paris Approach to (In)Securitization? Political Antropological Research for International Sociology”. In The Oxford Handbook of International Security edited by Alexandra Gheciu and William C. Wolgforth. Oxford Handbooks. Accessed 20 April 2020. DOI: 10.1093/oxfordhb/9780198777854.013.9
Bhorat, Haroon, Mbongiseni Buthelezi, Ivor Chipkin, Sikhulekile Duma, Lumkile Mondi, Camaren Peter, Mzukisi Qobo, Mark Swilling, and Hannah Friedenstein. 2017. Betrayal of the Promise: How South Africa is Being Stolen. Stellenbosch, Centre for Complex Systems in Transition.
Bjørgo, Tore and Miroslav Mareš. 2019. Vigilantism Against Migrants and Minorities. New York: Routledge.
Briscoe, Ivan, Catalina Perdomo and Catalina Uribe Bucher, eds. 2014. Ilicit Networks and Politics in Latin America. Stockholm: International IDEAS and The Hague: NIMD and Clingendael.
Brooks, Graham, Chris Lewis, David Walsh and Hakkyong Kim. 2013. Preventing Corruption: Investigation, Enforcement and Governance. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Bogaards, M. 2009. “How to classify hybrid regimes? Defective democracy and electoral authoritarianism.” Democratization, 16 (2): 399–423.
Buzan, Buzan, Ole, Wæver and Jaap de Wilde. 1998. Security: A New Framework for Analysis. Boulder: Lynne Reiner.
Caneppele, Stefano and Sara Martocchia. 2014. “Italian Mafias, Public Procurement and Public Works in Southern Italy.” In Organized Crime, Corruption and Crime Prevention, edited by Stefano Caneppele and Calderoni Francesco, 293–299. Heidelberg: Springer International Publishing.
Canonico Paolo, Consiglio Stefano, De Nito Ernesto, and Mangia Gianluigi. 2021 “Criminal Infiltration of the Public Sector”. In Contemporary Organized Crime. Studies of Organized Crime, edited by Hans Nelen and Dina Siegel, vol 18. Springer International Publishing.
a. s. e. collective. 2006. “Critical Approaches to Security in Europe: A Networked Manifesto”. Security Dialogue 37 (4): 443–87.
Capussela, Andrea. L. 2021. “‘State Capture’ and ‘Social Order’, Events and Structures.” Journal of Regional Security, 16 (2). DOI: 10.5937/jrs0-34271.
Cawthra, Gavin. 2019. “The Death of Security Sector Reform? The South African Exemplar Revisited. Conflict, Security & Development, 19 (2): 223–235.
Chappuis, Fairlie and Joseph Siegle. 2015. “Security Sector Reform in Times of Democratic Reversal”. Sicherheit und Frieden (S+ F)/Security and Peace, 33 (1): 1–6.
CSD. 2008. Crime Without Corruption – Countering Corruption and Organized Crime in Bulgaria. Sofia: Center for Study of Democracy.
Chipkin, Ivor. 2020. “Defining ‘State Capture’ in South Africa: Democracy, Bureaucratic Autonomy and Elite Populism”. GAPP Working Paper 1 (1): 1–19.
Chipkin, Ivor and Mark Swilling. 2018. Shadow State: The Politics of State Capture. Johannesburg: Wits University Press.
Chipkin, Ivor and Jelena Vidojević. 2021. Making Sense of State Capture in South Africa. Submission to the State Capture Commission. Gauteng: Government and Public Policy Think-tank. (Manuscript)
Curato, Nicole and Diego Fossati. 2020. “Authoritarian Innovations: Crafting Support for a Less Democratic Southeast Asia.” Democratization 27 (6): 1006–1020.
CSD. 2008. Crime Without Corruption – Countering Corruption and Organized Crime in Bulgaria. Sofia: Center for Study of Democracy.
Dávid-Barrett, Elisabeth and Mihaly Fazekas. 2020. “Grand Corruption and Government Change: An Analysis of Partisan Favoritism in Public Procurement.” European Journal on Criminal Policy and Research 26: 411–430.
Diamond, Larry. 2002. “Elections Without Democracy: Thinking About Hybrid Regimes.” Journal of Democracy 13 (2): 21–35.
Džankić, Jelena. 2018. “Capturing Contested States: Structural Mechanisms of Power Reproduction in Bosnia and Herzegovina, Macedonia and Montenegro.” Southeastern Europe 42 (1): 83–106.
Ejdus, Filip. 2017. “‘Not a Heap of Stones’: Material Environments and Ontological Security in International Relations.” Cambridge Review of International Affairs 30 (1): 23–43.
Elisha, A., Meijer, D. O’Toole, S., Roylance, T. 2021. The Antidemocratic Turn. Nations in Transit Report 2021. New York: Freedom House.
European Commission. 2018. A Credible Enlargement Perspective for and Enhanced EU Engagement with the Western Balkans. COM(2018) 65 final. February 6. Strasbourg.
Glasius, Marlies. 2018. “What Authoritarianism is ... and is not: A Practice Perspective.” International Affairs 94 (3): 515–533.
Fiskalni savet. 2021. “Ocena predloga zakona o završnom računu budžeta Republike Srbije za 2020. godinu.” [The Evaluation of the draft on the final account of the 2020 Republic of Serbia’s budget.] Beograd: Fiskalni savet.
Fridman, Orli and Krisztina Rácz. 2016. “Memories and Narratives of the 1999 NATO Bombing in Serbia.” Südosteuropa 64 (4): 433–437.
Greene, Kenneth. 2007. Why Dominant Parties Lose. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Greene, Kenneth. 2010. “The Political Economy of Authoritarian Single-Party Dominance.” Comparative Political Studies 43(7): 807–834.
Grzymała-Busse, Anna. 2007. Rebuilding Leviathan: Party Competition and State Exploitation in Post-Communist Democracies. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Grzymala-Busse, Anna. 2008. “Beyond Clientelism: Incumbent State Capture and State Formation.” Comparative Political Studies 41 (4–5): 638–73.
Grzymala-Busse, Anna. 2010. “The Best Laid Plans: The Impact of Informal Rules on Formal Institutions in Transitional Regimes.” Studies in Comparative International Development 45: 311–333.
Hellman, Joel, Geraint Jones, and Daniel Kaufmann. 2000. “Seize the State, Seize the Day.” State Capture, Corruption, and Influence in Transition. Policy Research Working Paper 2444. Washington DC: World Bank.
Hertel-Fernandez, A. 2019. State Capture: How Conservative Activists, Big Businesses, and Wealthy Donors Reshaped the American States-and the Nation. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Hicken, Allen. 2011. “Clientelism.” Annual Review of Political Science 14: 289–310.
Hulsey, John. 2018. “Institutions and the Reversal of State Capture.” Southeastern Europe 42 (1): 15–32.
Innes, Abby. 2014. “The Political Economy of State Capture in Central Europe.” JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies 52 (1): 88–104.
Innes, Abby. 2021. “Corporate State Capture: The Degree to Which the British State is Porous to Business Interests is Exceptional Among Established Democracies.” LSE Blog. April 16. Accessed 18 April 2021. https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/politicsandpolicy/corporate-state-capture/.
Institute for Security Studies and Corruption Watch. 2019. “State Capture and the Political Manipulation of Criminal Justice Agencies”. A joint submission to the Judicial Commission of Inquiry into Allegations of State Capture. April. Pretoria: ISS.
Ignjatijević, Marija. 2020. “Capturing the Overseers of Security Sector: The National Assembly.” In Security Sector Capture in Serbia – An Early Study, edited by Predrag Petrović and Jelena Pejić Nikić, 81–86. Belgrade: Belgrade Centre for Security Policy.
Jackson, Paul. 2018. “Introduction: Second-Generation Security Sector Reform.” Journal of Intervention and Statebuilding 12 (1): 1–10.
Jackson, Paul and Shivit Bakrania. 2018. “Is the Future of SSR non-linear?”. Journal of Intervention and Statebuilding 12 (1): 11–30.
Jackson, Christopher. 2021. “Local Security Capture After Conflict in the Western Balkans: New Security Entrants and Stability.” Journal of Regional Security, 16:2. DOI: 10.5937/jrs0-31813
No author. 2017. “JAROSŁAW KACZYŃSKI, The Backbench Driver.” Politico Class of 2017. Accessed 13 May 13 2021. https://www.politico.eu/list/politico-28-class-of-2017-ranking/jaroslaw-kaczynski/
Kinyakin, Andrey. 2013. “The Oligarchs in Contemporary Russia: From State ‘Capture’ to Subjection to State ‘Predation’.” Revue Internationale de Politique Comparée, 20 (3): 115–131.
Klíma, Michal. 2019. Informal Politics in Post-Communist Europe: Political Parties, Clientelism and State Capture (1st ed.). New York: Routledge.
Kopecký, Petr & Spirova, Maria. 2011. “‘Jobs for the Boys’? Patterns of Party Patronage in Post-Communist Europe.” West European Politics, 34 (5): 897–921.
Krasteva, Anna, and Nebojša Vladisavljević. 2017. “Securitisation versus Citizenship in the Balkan States: Populist and Authoritarian Misuses of Security Threats and Civic Responses”. Global Campus Human Rights Journal 1 (2): 373–392.
Lindsey, Brink, and Steven M. Teles. 2017. Captured Economy. How the Powerful Enrich Themselves, Slow Down Growth, and Increase Inequality. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Ledeneva, Alena. 2006. How Russia Really Works: The Informal Practices that Shaped Post-Soviet Politics and Business. Ithica: Cornell University Press.
Le Clercq Ortega, Juan Antonio and Gerardo Rodríguez Sánchez Lara. 2020. “Impunity Levels in the World. Global Impunity Index 2020.” Puebla: Fundación Universidad de las Américas.
Léonard, Sarah. 2010. “EU Border Security and Migration Into the European Union: FRONTEX and Securitization Through Practices”. European Security, 19 (2): 231–54.
Levitsky, Steven and Lucan A. Way. 2002. “The Rise of Competitive Authoritarianism”. Journal of Democracy, 13 (2): 51–66.
Lopes de Silva, Diego. 2020. “Autocracy is on the Rise: Should we Expect Military Spending to Follow.” Backgrounder. SIPRI.
Lührmann, Anna and Staffan I. Lindberg. 2019. “A Third Wave of Autocratization is Here: What is New About It?”. Democratization, 26 (7): 1095–1113.
Magyar, Balint. 2016. Post-Communist Mafia State. Budapest: Central European University Press.
Magyar, Balint and Balint Madlovics. 2020. The Anatomy of Post-communist Regimes. Budapest: CEU Press.
Marjanović-Rudan, Ana. 2021. “Whitewashing State Capture: Discursive Practices in the Western Balkans.” Journal of Regional Security 16:2. DOI: 10.5937/jrs15-24102
Megaloni, Beatriz. 2006. Voting for Autocracy: Hegemonic Party Survival and its Demise in Mexico. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Mesquita, Michael. 2018. “Kompromat.” In The Global Encyclopedia of Informality: Understanding Social and Cultural Complexity, edited by Alena Ledeneva, 435–441. London: UCL Press.
Mihályi, Péter, and Ivan Szelényi. 2019. “The Place of Rent-Seeking and Corruption in Varieties of Capitalism Models.” In Market Liberalism and Economic Patriotism in the Capitalist World-System, edited by Tamás Gerőcs and Miklós Szanyi, 67–97. Cham: Palgrave, Macmillan.
Mihályi, Péter and Ivan Szelényi. 2020. Varieties of Post-communist Capitalism. A Comparative Analysis of Russia, Eastern Europe and China. Leiden and Boston, Brill.
Niskanen, William, A. 1971. Bureaucracy and Representative Government. London and New York: Routledge.
Morgenbesser, Lee. 2020. “The Menu of Autocratic Innovation”. Democratization 27(6): 1053–1072.
OCCRP. 2020. “Balkan Cocaine Wars”. Organized Crime and Corruption Reporting Project, 5 May. Accessed 3 September 2020. https://www.occrp.org/en/balkan-cocaine-wars/
O’Dwyer, Conor. 2006. Runaway State Building: Patronage Politics and Democratic Development. Baltimore, MD: John Hopkins University Press.
Orenstein, Mitchell, A. 2019. The Lands In Between. Russia vs. the West and the New Politics of Hybrid War. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Pap, András. 2017. “Constitutional Identity? The Hungarian Model of Illiberal Democracy.” In A Quarter Century of Post-Communism Assessed, edited by Steven M. Fish, Graeme Gill and Milenko Petrović, 161–186. Palgrave Macmillan.
Pavlović, Dušan. 2016. “Extractive Institutions in the Western Balkans.” In Urušavanje ili slom demokratije [The Decline or the Breakdown of Democracy], edited by Ilija Vujačić and Bojan Vranić, 127–140. Beograd: FPN, Čigoja štampa.
Pavlović, Dušan 2020. “The Political Economy Behind the Gradual Demise of Democratic Institutions in Serbia.” Southeast European and Black Sea Studies 20 (1): 19–39.
Pavlović, Dušan. 2021a. The Moneywasting Machine. Five Months Inside Serbia’s Ministry of Economy. Budapest, CEU Press. (Forthcoming)
Pavlović Dušan. 2021b. “How Political Parties in Hybrid Regimes Help the Incumbent Maintain a Democratic Façade.” East European Politics and Societies 35(3): 593–612.
Pavlović, Dušan. 2021c. “State Capture in the Post-Communist Southeast Europe. A New Variant?” Academia Letters. DOI: 10.20935/AL3032
Peake, Gordon, Scheye, Eric and Alice Hills, eds. 2013. Managing Insecurity: Field Experiences of Security Sector Reform. London: Routledge
Pejić, Jelena and Sonja Stojanović Gajić. 2018. “Why Do We Need the Pribe Report As Well: How To Reverse the Trend of State Capture in the Western Balkans.” prEUgovor Practical Policy Proposal. Belgrade: Belgrade Centre for Security Policy. Accessed 18 April 2021. https://www.preugovor.org/Policy-Papers/1482/Why-Do-We-Need-the-Priebe-Report-As-Well.shtml
Pepinsky, Thomas. 2020. “Authoritarian Innovations: Theoretical Foundations and Practical Implications”. Democratization 27 (6): 1092–1101.
Pešić, Vesna. 2007. State Capture and Widespread Corruption in Serbia. Brussels: CEPS.
Pešić, Jelena and Marko Milošević. 2021. “Political Clientelism and Private Security Sector in Serbia.” In Political Clientelism in the Western Balkans, edited by Jovan Bliznakovski, 109–133. Skopje: Institute for Sociological, Political and Judicial Research.
Petrović, Predrag and Jelena Pejić Nikić, eds. 2020. Security Sector Capture in Serbia – An Early Study. Belgrade: Belgrade Centre for Security Policy.
Petrović, Predrag. 2021. “State Capture and Security Intelligence Agencies in Serbia.” Journal of Regional Security 16:2. 10.5937/jrs0-29333
Prelec, Tena. 2020. “The Vicious Circle of Corrosive Capital, Authoritarian Tendencies and State Capture in the Western Balkans.” Journal of Regional Security 15 (2):167–198.
Prezelj, Iztok and Nina Otorepec Vogrinčič. 2020. “Criminal and Networked State Capture in the Western Balkans: The Case of the Zemun Clan.” Southeast European and Black Sea Studies 20 (4): 547–570.
Ries, Nancy. 2020. “Thugocracy: Bandit Regimes and State Capture.” Safundi 21(4): 473–485.
Roberts, Margaret. 2018. Censored: Distraction and Diversion Inside China’s Great Firewall. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Schroeder, C. Ursula and Fairlie Chappuis. 2014. “New Perspectives on Security Sector Reform: The Role of Local Agency and Domestic Politics.“ International Peacekeeping 21(2): 133–148.
Sedra, Mark. 2018. “Adapting Security Sector Reform to Ground-level Realities: The Transition to a Second-generation Model”. Journal of Intervention and Statebuilding 12 (1): 48–63.
Seeberg, Marete, Bech. 2014. “State Capacity and the Paradox of Authoritarian Elections.” Democratization 21 (7): 1265–1285.
Seeberg, Marete, Bech. 2018. “Electoral Authoritarianism and Economic Control.” International Political Science Review 39 (1): 33–48.
Seeberg, Marete, Bech. 2021. “How State Capacity Helps Autocrats win Elections.” British Journal of Political Science 51 (2): 541–558.
Schedler, Andreas. 2002. “The Menu of Manipulation.” Journal of Democracy 13 (2): 36–50.
Schedler, Andreas. (ed.) 2006. Electoral Authoritarianism: The Dynamics of Unfree Competition. Lynne Rienner Publisher.
Schedler, Andreas. 2015. The Politics of Uncertainty: Sustaining and Subverting Electoral Authoritarianism. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Stigler, G. J. 1971. “The Theory of Economic Regulation.” Bell Journal of Economics and Management Science, 1971: 3–21.
Stojanović, Milica and Ivana Jeremić. 2021. “’Don’t Ask Me’: Serbia Trades Away Transparency in COVID-19 Spending”. BalkanInsight. July 27. Accessed 18 August 2021. https://balkaninsight.com/2021/07/27/dont-ask-me-serbia-trades-away-transparency-in-covid-19-spending/
Stoyanov, Alexander, Alexander Gerganov and Todor Yalamov. 2019. State Capture Assessment Diagnostics. Sofia: Center for the Study of Democracy.
Suhartono, Muktita and Austin Ramzy. 2019. “Thailand Election Results.” New York Times. Accessed 13 May 2021. https://www.nytimes.com/2019/05/09/world/asia/thailand-election-results.html
Trejo, Guillermo, and Sandra Ley. 2021. “High-Profile Criminal Violence: Why Drug Cartels Murder Government Officials and Party Candidates in Mexico.” British Journal of Political Science 51 (1): 203–29.
Viktorov, Ilja. 2019. “Russia’s Network State and Reiderstvo Practices: The Roots to Weak Property Rights Protection after the Post-Communist Transition.” In Stubborn Structures: Reconceptualizing Post-Communist Regimes, edited by Bálint Magyar, 437–59. Budapest–New York: Central European University Press.
Volkov, Vadim. 2002. Violent Entrepreneurs: The Use of Force in the Making of Russian Capitalism. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
Vuori, Juha A. 2008. “Illocutionary Logic and Strands of Securitization: Applying the Theory of Securitization to the Study of Non-Democratic Political Orders.” European Journal of International Relations, 14 (1): 65–99.
Yakovlev, Andrei. 2006. “The Evolution of Business: State Interaction in Russia: From State Capture to Business Capture?” Europe-Asia Studies 58 (7): 1033–1056.
Yilmaz, Ihsan and Erdoan Shipoli. 2021. “Use of Past Collective Traumas, Fear and Conspiracy Theories for Securitization of the Opposition and Authoritarianisation: The Turkish Case.” Democratization, DOI: 10.1080/13510347.2021.1953992
Waever, Ole. 1995. “Securitization and Desecuritization.” In On Security edited by Ronnie D. Lipschutz, 46–86. New York: Columbia University Press.
Weiss, Sandra. 2021. “Dozens Fall Victim to Mexico’s Brutal Election Campaign.” Deutsche Welle English. May 25. Accessed 14 July 2021. https://p.dw.com/p/3u4wR
Wojczewski, Thorsten. 2020. “’Enemies of the People’: Populism and the Politics of (in)Security.” European Journal of International Security 5 (1): 5–24.
World Bank. 2002. Transition. The First Ten Years. Analysis and Lessons for Eastern Europe and the Former Soviet Union. Washington DC: World Bank.
Authors retain copyright of the published papers and grant to the publisher the non-exclusive right to publish the article, to be cited as its original publisher in case of reuse, and to distribute it in all forms and media.
The published articles will be distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY). It is allowed to copy and redistribute the material in any medium or format, and remix, transform, and build upon it for any purpose, even commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given to the original author(s), a link to the license is provided and it is indicated if changes were made. / The published articles will be distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution ShareAlike 4.0 International license (CC BY-SA). It is allowed to copy and redistribute the material in any medium or format, and remix, transform, and build upon it for any purpose, even commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given to the original author(s), a link to the license is provided, it is indicated if changes were made and the new work is distributed under the same license as the original.
Users are required to provide full bibliographic description of the original publication (authors, article title, journal title, volume, issue, pages), as well as its DOI code. In electronic publishing, users are also required to link the content with both the original article published in Journal of Regional Security and the licence used.
Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.
Authors are permitted to deposit author’s pre-print / author’s post-print (accepted version) / publisher's version (PDF) of their work in an institutional repository, subject-based repository, author's personal website (including social networking sites, such as ResearchGate, Academia.edu, etc.), and/or departmental website prior or during the submission process / at any time after the acceptance of the manuscript / at any time after publication.
Full bibliographic information (authors, article title, journal title, volume, issue, pages) about the original publication must be provided and links must be made to the article's DOI and the license.