SECURITY DILEMMA AND FOREIGN POLICY OF EASTERN EUROPEAN COUNTRIES IN THE CONTEXT OF THE UKRAINIAN CRISIS

  • Milovan Trbojević Akademija za nacionalnu bezbednost; Fakultet za studije bezbednosti
  • Branislav Svirčević Fakultet za studije bezbednosti
Keywords: security dilemma, foreign policy, conflict, Ukraine, The Russian Federation, Eastern Europe.

Abstract


 The stability of the course of internal and foreign policy directly depends on internal, regional and even global security. Establishing a clear foreign policy direction requires long-term/strategic partnerships, certain and positive security-political opportunities in the environment, which is especially difficult in the dynamic geopolitical environment such as Eastern Europe. Frequent changes in the foreign policy directions of Eastern European countries are the result of conflicts between mutually exclusive geostrategic interests and pretensions in different historical-political contexts, which often led to crisis and even conflict moments. Unfavorable security conditions in Eastern Europe caused by the current conflict in Ukraine fueled a security dilemma, the effects of which were soon felt in all social spheres. Bearing that in mind, the subject of this paper is the research and critical analysis of the security dilemma as a factor of foreign policy action in the context of the Ukrainian conflict, which includes both long-term (strategic) and short-term directions, as well as regional and global political goals of the countries of Eastern Europe. The countries of Eastern Europe that are direct participants in the Ukrainian conflict were excluded: the Russian Federation and Ukraine, and the focus was on the evaluation of the foreign policy directions of action of the countries of the mentioned region.

All analyzed energetic, geographical, demographic, economic and political-security features of Eastern Europe are a suitable basis and, directly or indirectly, affect the realization of certain security-threatening phenomena, among which are certainly the most dangerous military threats, which have the potential to spread and intensify. The reactivation of the security and defense dilemma, which was actualized after the military intervention of the Russian Federation in Ukraine, put the countries of Eastern Europe under the microscope and put their external political direction to the test. However, it is clear that the countries of this region do not have absolutely mutually compatible foreign policy goals and interests in those areas where it is necessary to protect their national values. While the majority inconsistent countries decide to prioritize their own national security, the majority consistent countries, by helping Ukraine, actively participate in maintaining and strengthening the regional security dilemma.

References

About Hungary 2024. Bóka: Hungary calls for clear EU stance on Russia-Ukraine conflict. https://abouthungary.hu/news-in-brief/boka-hungary-calls-for-clear-eu-stance-on-russia-ukraine-conflict. 4. 3. 2024,
About Hungary 2024. FM: Reality and ideology are "far apart" in politics today. https://abouthungary.hu/news- in-brief/fm-reality-and-ideology-are-far-apart-in-politics-today. 4. 3. 2024,
Ahmatović 2024: Šejla Ahmatović. Slovak PM says EU, NATO members weighing sending troops to Ukraine. https://www.politico.eu/article/slovak-pm-fico-says-eu-and-nato-states-consider-sending-troops-to- ukraine/. 4. 3. 2024,
Aligica 2024: Paul Dragos Aligica. Frictions aside, Romania remains steady in support of Ukraine. https://www.gisreportsonline.com/r/romana-ukraine-relations/. 16. 3. 2024,
AP News 2023: https://apnews.com/article/russia-belarus-nuclear-weapons-shipments-lukashenko-poland- a035933e0c4baa0015e2ef2c1f5d9b1a. 21. 3. 2024,
AP News 2023. Bulgaria agrees to send heavy military equipment to Ukraine for the first time since the invasion. https://apnews.com/article/bulgaria-ukraine-armored-carriers-military-aid- 7f256492a063c154ca614c18ab95aced. 9. 3. 2024,
Astapenia 2023: Ryhor Astapenia. Chatham house. https://www.chathamhouse.org/2023/12/russias-war- ukraine-has-strengthened-lukashenka-undermined-belarus. 21. 3. 2024,
Brookes 2023: Peter Brookes. Russia’s strategy in sending tactical nuclear weapons to Belarus. https://www.gisreportsonline.com/r/russia-belarus-nuclear/. 20. 2. 2024,
Воскресенье 2014. https://www.belta.by/president/view/lukashenko-podtverdil-chto-s-territorii-belarusi-byli- zapuscheny-rakety-po-pozitsijam-v-ukraine-no-eto-487330-2022/. 21. 3. 2024,
Euronews 2024. Central European countries show deep rifts on Ukraine war at V4 meeting. https://www.euronews.com/2024/02/27/central-european-countries-show-deep-rifts-on-ukraine-war-at-v4- meeting. 28. 2. 2024,
Genctruk 2023: Ahmet Genctruk. Poland places orders for $23.8B in weapons purchases. https://www.aa.com.tr/en/europe/poland-places-orders-for-238b-in-weapons-purchases/2984964. 20. 2. 2024,
Gencturk 2023: Ahmet Gencturk. War in Ukraine forced Bulgaria to improve defense capabilities: Defense minister. https://www.aa.com.tr/en/europe/war-in-ukraine-forced-bulgaria-to-improve-defense- capabilities-defense-minister/2983275. 10. 3. 2024,
Gencturk-Eruygur 2023: Ahmet Gencturk-Eruygur. Romania, Ukraine agree to elevate relations to strategic partnership. https://www.aa.com.tr/en/europe/romania-ukraine-agree-to-elevate-relations-to-strategic- partnership/3014633. 11. 3. 2024,
Government of The Czech Republic 2023. Czechia sends hundreds of heavy military systems worth tens of billions to Ukraine during the first year of Russian invasion. https://vlada.gov.cz/en/media- centrum/tiskove-zpravy/czechia-sends-hundreds-of-heavy-military-systems-worth-tens-of-billions-to- ukraine-during-the-first-year-of-russian-invasion-203252/. 1. 3. 2024,
Goslin 2023: Tim Goslin. Attacks on Ukraininas in Chechia are on the rise. https://balkaninsight.com/2023/10/12/attacks-on-ukrainians-in-czechia-are-on-the-rise/. 26. 2. 2024
George-Weyeman 2023: Mathew George-Pieter Weyeman. Tensions on the Belarus border: A look at military spending and arms import patterns. https://www.sipri.org/commentary/topical- backgrounder/2023/tensions-belarus-border-look-military-spending-and-arms-import-patterns. 20. 2. 2024,
Herz 1950: John H. Herz. Idealist Internationalism and the Securitiy Dilemma. World Politics. Vol. 2, No. 2, 1950, pp. 157-180,
Ilie 2023: Luiza Ilie. Romania bolsters defences to stop Ukraine war crossing NATO threshold. https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/romania-bolsters-defences-stop-ukraine-war-crossing-nato- threshold-2023-09-29/. 13. 3. 2024,
Istepanov 2024: Aslan Istepanov. Slovakia’s Stance on the Ukrainian War. https://www.ankasam.org/slovakias- stance-on-the-ukrainian-war/?lang=en. 3. 3. 2024,
Janicek 2024: Karel Janicek. Deep divisions on Russia’s war in Ukraine were evident at a meeting of 4 Central European countries. https://apnews.com/article/czech-republic-poland-ukraine-war-russia- cb30efe44a452b8e4871aa1d1182ddda. 2. 3. 2024,
Kirichenko 2023: David Kirichenko. To protect Europe, the West should send arms to Moldova. https://www.euronews.com/2023/08/22/to-protect-europe-the-west-should-send-arms-to-moldova. 18. 3. 2024,
Kumar Sen 2023: Ashish Kumar Sen. Romania Worries About Fallout from Ukraine War. https://cepa.org/article/romania-worries-about-fallout-from-ukraine-war/. 13. 3. 2024),
Laster-Michael 2023: Maya Lester KC-Michael O’Kane. Belarus – sanctions regime. https://globalsanctions.co.uk/region/belarus/. 20. 2. 2024,
Lukiv 2024: Jaroslav Lukiv. Trump will not give a penny to Ukraine - Hungary PM Orban. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-68533351. 6. 3. 2024,
Mackinder 2004: Halford J. Mackinder. „The Geographical Pivot of History“. The Geographical Journal. год. 2004. Vol. 170, No. 4, 298-321,
McGrath-Ghirda 2023: Stephen McGrath-Vadim Ghirda. ‘No risk’ that NATO member Romania will be dragged into war, senior alliance official says. https://apnews.com/article/romania-ukraine-nato-russia-war-drones- 8a80bf6604bbd5506d1eef1358ddc9c2. 15. 3. 2024),
McGrath-Obreja 2024: Stephen McGrath-Aurel Obreja. Moldova faces multiple threats from Russia as it turns toward EU membership, foreign minister says. https://apnews.com/article/moldova-russia-war-ukraine- transnistria-eu-6c14d96e8cdc0bc699f0315eecaab4f6. 16. 3. 2024,
Мијалковић 2018. Саша Мијалковић. Национална безбедност – четврто, измењено и допуњено издање. Београд: Криминалистичко-полицијска академија,
Necsutu 2023: Madalin Necsutu. Romanians Hosting Ukrainian Refugees Complain of Delay in Payments. https://balkaninsight.com/2023/03/23/romanians-hosting-ukrainian-refugees-complain-of-delay-in- payments/. 12. 3. 2024,
Nikolov 2023: Krassen Nikolov. Bulgarian president accuses Ukraine of not wanting to stop Russian war. https://www.euractiv.com/section/politics/news/bulgarian-president-accuses-ukraine-of-not-wanting-to- stop-russian-war/. 7. 3. 2024,
Novakova 2024: Veronica Novakova. Russian invasion of Ukraine: How does it affect the Czech Republic?. https://www.humanrightscentre.org/blog/russian-invasion-ukraine-how-does-it-affect-czech-republic. 1. 3. 2024,
Ozturk 2024: Mustafa Ozturk. Hungary's position on war in Ukraine remains unchanged: Orban. https://www.aa.com.tr/en/europe/hungarys-position-on-war-in-ukraine-remains-unchanged-orban/3125375. 5. 3. 2024,
Pasha-Lutsevych 2024: Valeriu Pasha-Orysia Lutsevych. Is Moldova a new battleground in Russia’s war?. https://www.chathamhouse.org/2024/03/moldova-new-battleground-russias-war. 18. 3. 2024,
Pollet 2024: Mathieu Pollet. Slovak PM: Ukraine must give up territory to end Russian invasion. https://www.politico.eu/article/slovakia-prime-minister-robert-fico-ukraine-cede-territory-russia-moscow- invasion-nato-entry/. 3. 3. 2024,
Potter 2024: Benjamin Potter. Unrecognized Republic, Recognizable Consequences. https://www.usmcu.edu/Outreach/Marine-Corps-University-Press/MCU-Journal/Journal-of-Advanced- Military-Studies-SI-2022/Unrecognized-Republic-Recognizable-Consequences-Russian-Troops-in-Frozen- Transnistria/. 16. 3. 2024,
Seltzer 2019: Nicholas Seltzer. Liberalism and the Security Dilemma: Are International Institutions Effective?. Reno: University of Nevada,
Shiping 2009: Tang Shiping. The Security Dilemma: A Conceptual Analysis. Security Studies. DOI: 10.1080/09636410903133050, 587–623,
Shtreber: 2013. Источна Европа. https://shtreber.com/istocna-evropa. [11. 1. 2024.],
Szczerbiak 2022: Aleks Szczerbiak. How will the Russia-Ukraine war affect Poland’s rule of law dispute with the EU? https://www.pubaffairsbruxelles.eu/opinion-analysis/how-will-the-russia-ukraine-war-affect- polands-rule-of-law-dispute-with-the-eu/. 28. 2. 2024,
Suetomi 2022. Junko Suetomi. Japan introduces further sanctions against Russia and Belarus. https://sanctionsnews.bakermckenzie.com/japan-introduces-further-sanctions-against-russia-and-belarus-3/. 20. 2. 2024,
Thorpe 2023: Nick Thorpe. What has Hungary's Orban got against Ukraine?. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-67725570. 5. 3. 2024,
Трапара 2014: Трапара Владимир. „Савремени значај макиндеровог концепта Источне Европе: случај украјинске кризе“, Институт за међународну политику и привреду. год. 2014. год. LXV, бр. 1155– 1156, 26–43,
United Nations. Department of Economic and Social Affairs: Standard country or area codes for statistical use . https://unstats.un.org/unsd/methodology/m49/#geo-regions. 15. 1. 2024,
Вилијамс 2012: Пол Вилијамс: Увод устудије безбедности. Београд: Факултет безбедности – Универзитет у Београду,
Zankina 2023: Emilia Zankina. Pro-Russia or anti-Russia: Political dilemmas and dynamics in Bulgaria in the context of the war in Ukraine. https://www.populismstudies.org/pro-russia-or-anti-russia-political- dilemmas-and-dynamics-in-bulgaria-in-the-context-of-the-war-in-ukraine/. 8. 3. 2024,
Wivel 2011: Anders Wivel. Security Dilemma. International Encyclopedia of Political Science. 2011, 2389- 2391.
Published
2024/09/10
Section
Članci