LEASING IN THE WESTERN BALKANS AND THE FALL OF THE AUSTRIAN HYPO-ALPE-ADRIA BANK
Sažetak
The hybrid contract known in Continental Europe as leasing has arrived to the Balkans and other post-socialist countries of Europe from the United States yet with the intermediation of various Western European jurisdictions that have reshaped the contours of the newcomer transaction to fit the context. Western European banks expanding to the region then brought with them their home country perceptions. This resulted in significantly differing leasing laws in the region. Although the process began already before the 1980s, one could speak of real expansion only from the 1990s on. By now leasing has become an important part of most jurisdictions of the region.
Notwithstanding the organic growth, the article posits, leasing is still not properly understood, the regulations suffer from gaps and are inappropriate to boost the local leasing industries. This is readily proved by most recent reports of some international organizations. Especially small and mid-scale enterprises suffer as equipment leasing remains underdeveloped, what is a major systemic defect as bank credit is (as well) unavailable to them.
The article aims to identify and comment those common deficiencies of the leasing laws of this niche of Europe that have so far been neglected yet the tackling of which is inevitable to boost the local industries. This is done, first, by sketching the experiences with and the judicial responses to a few unreported first generation leasing cases from Vojvodina (Serbia) from the end of the 1980s to determine what main problems the lessor faced in implementing their leasing transactions. It is claimed that some of the key problems have not been eliminated from the legal system ever since, in particular the problems with repossession upon default. Secondly, comparative law is as well resorted to yet contrary to European approaches with more insight into the solutions of the United States as the jurisdiction wherefrom leasing originates.
The final part then comments those key problems and dilemmas that still hinder the proper development of the local leasing industries yet which have been largely bypassed. These are the 1/ problems caused by uncritically taken over solutions and definitions, 2/ the lack of legal tools for prompt repossession of the object of leasing, 3/ the conceptual confusion related to what in common law is known as the ‘election of remedies doctrine’, as well as 4/ the incomprehension of the importance of the policy choices justifying the recognition and judicial support for the so-called hell-or-high-water clauses.
The article additionally posits that the very same reasons might have generated the problematic leasing portfolios of the Austrian Hypo-Alpe-Adria Bank and therefore might have also contributed to the eventual fall of the Bank. In the lack of empirical evidences and other firm evidences, however, this position should not be taken to be more than a question to be answered in the future, if for nothing else, then for having some satisfactory answers for the fall of the Bank and for the sake of better understanding leasing.
Key words: leasing (operating, financial), equipment leasing, bank bailout, self-help repossession, legal engineering, small and mid-scale enterprise (SME) financing, law reforms.
Reference
Allcock, B. J., 2000, Explaining Yugoslavia, London, Hurst & Co.
Altman, I. E., Hotchkiss, E., 2006, Corporate Financial Distress and Bankruptcy: Predicts and Avoid Bankruptcy, Analyze and Invest in Distressed Debt, 3rd ed., Wiley & Sons.
von Bar, C., Clive, E. (eds.), 2010, Principles, Definitions and Model Rules of European Private Law – Draft Common Frame of Reference (DCFR), Oxford University Press.
Bork, R., Security Rights and Insolvency Law in the Germanic Legal Systems, in: McCormack, G. & Bork, R., (eds.) 2017, Security Rights and the European Insolvency Regulation, Cambridge-Antwerp-Portland, Intersentia.
Carballo Fidalgo, M., Carballo Piῆeiro, L., Mangano, R., Security Rights and Insolvency Law in the Roman Legal Systems, in: McCormack, G. & Bork, R., (eds.) 2017, Security Rights and the European Insolvency Regulation, Cambridge, Intersentia.
Dalhuisen, H. J., 2016, Dalhuisen on Transnational Comparative, Commercial, Financial and Trade Law, vol. III, 6th ed., Hart.
Duggan, A. & Brown, D., 2012, Australian Personal Property Securities Law, Australia, LexisNexis Butterworths.
Dobbs, B. D. and Caprice, L. R., 2017, Law of Remedies: Damages-Equity-Restitution, 3rd ed., West.
Doklestić, S., Víg, Z., Enforcement of Contracts in Serbia, in: Messmann, S., Tajti, T., 2009, The Case Law of Central and Eastern Europe – Enforcement of Contracts, Germany, Bochum, European University Press.
Flere, P., Leasing in Slovenia – the Fastest Growing Financial Service Industry notwithstanding the Discrepancy between Theory and Practice, in: Messmann, S., Tajti, T., 2007, The Case Law of Central and Eastern Europe – Leasing, Piercing the Corporate Veil […], Germany, Bochum, European University Press.
Harmathy, A., The EBRD Model Law and the Hungarian Law, in: Norton, J., J. Andenas, Mads, 1998, Emerging Financial Markets and Secured Transactions, UK, London, Kluwer.
Hete, N., Leasing in Hungary – A Burgeoning Business amidst of a Non-Regulated Legal Environment, in: Messmann, S., Tajti, T., 2007, Case Law of Central and Eastern Europe – Leasing, Piercing the Corporate Veil […] (Germany, Bochum, European University Press.
Hoening, C., Hammerl, C., 2014, Insolvency and Restructuring in Central & Eastern Europe, Vienna, Linde.
Iheme, C. W., 2016, Towards Reforming the Legal Framework for Secured Transactions in Nigeria, Springer.
Garner, B.A., (editor in chief), 1999, Black’s Law Dictionary (DeLuxe, 7th ed.,).
Goode, R.M., ZIEGEL, S.J., 1965, Hire-Purchase and Conditional Sale – A Comparative Survey of Commonwealth and American law, UK, London, British Institute of Int’l and Comparative Law.
Gilmore, G., 1965, Security Interests in Personal Property, Boston-Toronto, Little, Brown and Co.
Gullifer, L., Payne, J., 2011, Corporate Finance Law – Principles and Policy, 1st ed., Oxford and Portland, Hard Publishing.
Hoyle, M. S. W., 2006, Freezing and Search Orders, 4th ed., London, Informa.
King, B. D., Kuenzel, C., Stone, B., KNIGHT, Jr., W.H., 1997, Commercial Transactions under the Uniform Commercial Code and other Laws,Matthew Bender.
Lansferd, T., 2014, Political Handbook of the World 2014, Sage & CQPress.
Leaseeurope and Andersen, A., 1992, Leasing in Europe, London, McGraw-Hill Book Co., Statement on Lease Accounting.
del Luca, F. L., Reilly, T. M., Smith, E. E., Winship, P., 2011, Secured Transactions under the Uniform Commercial Code and International Commerce, 2nd ed., LexisNexis.
McCormack, G. & Bork, R., (eds.) 2017, Security Rights and the European Insolvency Regulation, Cambridge-Antwerp-Portland, Intersentia.
McCormack, G., Security Rights and Insolvency Law in the Common Law System, in: McCormack, G. & Bork, R., (eds.) 2017, Security Rights and the European Insolvency Regulation, Cambridge, Intersentia.
Messmann, S., Tajti, T., 2007, The Case Law of Central and Eastern Europe – Leasing, Piercing the Corporate Veil and the Liability of Managers & Controlling Shareholders, Privatization, Takeovers and the Problems with Collateral Law, Germany, Bochum, European University Press.
Messmann, S., Tajti, T., 2009, The Case Law of Central and Eastern Europe – Enforcement of Contracts, Germany, Bochum, European University Press.
Müller, M., 2014, Bankensanierung statt Bankinsolvenz: Sanierungsablauf am Beispiel der Hypo Alpe-Adria Bank AG, Hamburg, Diplomica Verlag.
Norton, J. J., Andenas, M., 1998, Emerging Financial Markets and Secured Transactions, UK, London, Kluwer.
Stănescu, C. G., 2015, Self-Help, Private Debt Collection and the Concomitant Risks, Springer.
Stefoff, R., 2006, The Telephone, New York, Marshall Cavendish.
Stummel, D., 2003, Standardvertragsmuster – zum Handels- und Gesellschaftsrecht (Deutsch-English), München, Beck.
Tajti, T., 2013, Systemic and Topic Mapping of the Relationship of the Draft Common Frame of Reference and Arbitration, Lithuanian, Vilnius, Kazimieras Simonavičius University.
Tajti, T., Security Rights and Insolvency Law in the Central and Eastern European Systems, in: McCormack, G. & Bork, R., (eds.) 2017, Security Rights and the European Insolvency Regulation, Cambridge-Antwerp-Portland, Intersentia.
UNCITRAL Legislative Guide on Secured Transactions (New York, 2010).
Vasiljević, M., 1995, Trgovinsko pravo, 4th ed., Belgrade, Savremena administracija.
Vékás, L., (ed.), 2013, Commentary of the Civil Code (“A Polgári Törvénykönyv magyarázatokkal”) 1st ed., Budapest, Complex.
Vilus, J., Carić, S., Šogorov, S., 1984, Međunarodno privredno pravo, Belgrade, Naučna knjiga.
White, J. J., Summers, S. R., 2010, Uniform Commercial Code, 6th ed., West.
Williams M., Lu H. and Ong C.A., Secured Finance Law in China and Hong Kong, Cambridge, 2010.
Ziegel, S. J., Geva, B., Cuming, R.C.C., 1995, Commercial and Consumer Transactions – Cases, Text and Materials, 3rd ed., Canada, Toronto, Emond Montgomery Publications.
LAW REVIEW ARTICLES
Beširević, V., 1989, Odgovornost za privredne prestupe i prekršaje prema odredbaman Zakona o preduzećima, Savremena praksa, ISSN 0036-5173, vol. 24, no. 1296.
Burdick, M. F., 1928, Codifying the Law of Conditional Sales, Columbia Law Rev., vol. 18, no. 2 (Febr.).
Burack, L. M., 1969, American Private Direct Investment in Eastern Europe: Intersection of Business Interests and Foreign Policy, 21 Stanford Law Review 877 (April).
Kalss, S., 2010, Measures by the Austrian Regulatory Authorities in Response to the Financial Market Crisis, European Business Organization Law Review 11.
Krygier, M., 2001, Transitional Questions about the Rule of Law: Why, What, and How?, East Central Europe, Special Issue, vol. 28, part 1.
Milošević, M., 2016, Prinudno izvršenje na osnovu javnobeležničke izvršne isprave, Pravni zapisi, vol. VII, no. 2.
Neth, S., 1972, Repossession of Goods: Due Process for the Consumer: What’s Due for the Creditor, Case Western Reserve Law Review, vol. 24, no. 1.
Stanford, M. J., 1987, Rapport explicatif sur le projet de convention sur le Credit-bail international, Uniform Law Review, vol. 15, no. 11.
Tajti, T., 2002, Viehweg’s Topics, Article 9 UCC, the “kautelarische Sicherheiten” and the Hungarian Secured Transactions Law Reform, Vindobona J. of Int’l Commercial Law and Arbitration, vol. 6, no. 1.
Tajti, T., 2011, Consignments and the Draft Common Frame of Reference, Pravni zapisi, vol. II, no. 2.
Tajti, T., 2015, Franchise and Contract Asymmetry: A Common Trans-Atlantic Agenda?, Loyola of Los Angeles Int’l & Comparative Law Review, vol. 37, no. 1.
Vodinelić, V. V., 2014, Čemu posesorni postupak? – O razlogu posesorne zaštite državine, Pravni zapisi, vol. V, no. 1.
WEEKLY AND DAILY NEWSPAPERS
Bryant, C., Finance Probes Stretch Limits of Justice System, Wall Street Journal, 22 Oct. 2010 issue, at 3 (special supplement on Austria).
Shotter, J., Austria Bad Bank Plan Risks Breaking Bloc’s Budget Limit, in: Financial Times, 11 March 2014 issue.
INTERNET-BASED SOURCES
Shields, M., Austria sells Hypo Balkans network to private equity firm Advent, Reuters (23 Dec. 2014),(http:// Austria sells Hypo Balkans network to private equity firm Advent Michael Shields).
Srdoc, N., Austria’s Hypo Group Alpe Adria: Collapse of the Rule of Law in Europe’s Largest Post-WWII Banking Scandal - Billions Missing, Culprits Still at Large, Huffington Post, 13 October 2017 issue, (https://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/hypo-group-alpe-adria-collapse-of-the-rule-of-law_us_59e06ab8e4b003f928d5e5c6).
INDUSTRY PUBLICATIONS:
EIB, Assessment of Financing Needs of SMEs in the Western Balkan Countries – Synthesis Report (August 2016), (http://vienna-initiative.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/09/EIB_assessment_of_financing_needs_of_smes_in_the_western_balkans_synthesis_en_compressed.pdf).
ELFA, 2017 Survey of Equipment Financing Activity of the US Equipment Leasing and Finance Association (ELFA), (https://www.leasefoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/2017sefaexecutivesummary.pdf).
HETA Asset Resolution AG, Annual Financial Report 2015.
STATUTORY AND REGULATORY LAW
Albania
Law No 9396 of 12 May 2005 on Financial Leasing
Bosnia and Herzegovina
Zakon o lizingu , Službene novine Federacije BiH, br. 85/08, 39/00, 65/13 i 104/16
Croatia
Zakon o leasingu (2013)
Hungary
Hungarian Civil Code of 2013 (Full title: Law No. V. of year 2013 on the Civil Code – in Hungarian: “A Polgári Törvénykönyvről szóló 2013. évi V. törvény”)
Poland
Civil Code, Book Three on Obligations, Title XVIII on Contract of Leasing
Serbia
Zakon o finansijskom lizingu (2003 as amended)
Ukraine
The Law of Ukraine “On Financial Leasing” (14 Jan. 1999 N 394-XIV as amended)
Former Yugoslavia
Zakon o preduzećima 1989 (Enterprise Act 1989)
Zakon o obligacionim odnosima 1978 [Act on Obligations 1978] (as amended by the various successor States of the former Yugoslavia)
COURT DECISIONS
Croatia
Visoki trgovački sud Republike Hrvatske, Pž-555/00 as of 26th of Febr. 2002
United States
In Re O.P.M. Leasing Services, United States Bankruptcy Court, Southern District of New York, 21 B.R. 993 (1982)
Fuentes v. Shevin (407 U.S. 67, 92 S. Ct. 1983, 32 L. Ed. 2d 556) [1972]
Mitchell v. Grant (416 U.S. 600, 94 S. Ct. 1895, 40 L. Ed. 2d 406) [1974]
SOFT LAW
European Union
EU Commission Press Release, State Aid: Commission Approves Plan to Orderly Wind Down Hypo Group Alpe Adria, 3 Sept. 2013
United States of America
Uniform Commercial Code (Revised Version 1999)