JUDICIAL SELF-GOVERNANCE IN SERBIA: CHALLENGES TO AND RESULTS OF A QUANTITATIVE APPROACH
Sažetak
Serbia has been continuously changing its judicial regulation landscape since 2000, in an effort to assert judicial independence and judicial self-governance, under strong EU external conditionality. The authors utilize the Judicial Self-Governance Index developed by Šipulová et al. as the main methodological tool aimed to determine whether the achieved level of judicial self-governance in Serbia is consistent with the demands of external conditionality. The research shows that judges control over 50% of relevant competencies, with a gradual increase in judicial self-governance in Serbia during the 2003–2023 period. This is consistent with the external conditionality demands and with the de iure implementation of the judicial council model. The research also points to some limitations of the applied methodology and highlights the need for a comprehensive examination of de facto judicial self-governance, while giving due regard to all integral parts of the complex rule of law principle.
Reference
Bibliography
Aarli, R., Sanders, A., 2023, Judicial Councils Everywhere? Judicial Administra- tion in Europe, with a Focus on the Nordic Countries, International Journal for Court Administration, Vol. 14, No. 2, pp. 1–34.
Akutsu, L., Aquino Guimarães, T. de, 2015, Governança Judicial: Proposta De Modelo Teórico-Metodológico, Revista de Administração Pública, Vol. 49, No. 4, pp. 937–958.
Bingham, T., 2010, The Rule of Law, London, Penguin Books.
Bobek, M., Kosař, D., 2014, Global Solutions, Local Damages: A Critical Study in Judicial Councils in Central and Eastern Europe, German Law Journal, Vol. 15, No. 7, pp. 1257–1292.
Bunjevac, T., 2020, The Rise of Judicial Self-Governance in the New Millennium: An Institutional and Policy Framework, Singapore, Springer.
Castillo-Ortiz, P., 2019, The politics of implementation of the judicial council model in Europe, European Political Science Review, Vol. 11, No. 4, pp. 503–520.
Dallara, C., Piana, D., 2015, Networking the Rule of Law: How Change Agents Re-shape Judicial Governance in the EU, London–New York, Routledge.
Devlin, R., Dodek, A., Regulating Judges: Challenges, Controversies and Choices, in: Devlin, R., Dodek, A., (eds.), 2016, Regulating Judges Beyond Independence and Accountability, Cheltenham, Edward Elgar, pp. 1–30.
Feld, L. P., Voigt, S., 2003. Economic growth and judicial independence: cross-country evidence using a new set of indicators, European Journal of Political Economy, Vol. 19, No. 3, pp. 497–527.
Garoupa, N., Ginsburg, T., 2009, Guarding the Guardians: Judicial Councils and Judicial Independence, American Journal of Comparative Law, Vol. 57, No. 1, pp. 103–134.
Grubač, M., 2000, Problems of Judiciary in Serbia – A Restitution of Integrity, Glasnik of the Bar Association of Vojvodina, Vol. 60, No. 12, pp. 453–462.
Hayo, B., Voigt, S., 2014, Mapping constitutionally safeguarded judicial independence – A global survey, Journal of Empirical Legal Studies, Vol. 11, No. 1, pp. 159–195.
Igwe, I. O. C., 2021, Rule of Law and Constitutionalism in Nigerian Democracy: A Critical Relativism Discuss in the Context of International Law, Athens Journal of Law, Vol. 7, No. 3, pp. 317–334.
Jordana, J., Sancho, D., Regulatory Designs, Institutional Constellations and the Study of the Regulatory State, in: Jordana, J., Levi-Faur, D., (eds.), The Politics of Regulation: Institutions and Regulatory Reforms for the Age of Governance, Cheltenham, Edward Elgar Publishing, pp. 296–320.
Knežević Bojović, A., 2011, Harmonizacija kompanijskog prava sa pravom Evropske unije i pravila o slobodi osnivanja privrednih društava u Sporazumu o stabilizaciji i pridruživanju, Strani pravni život, Vol. 55, No. 1, pp. 129–140.
Knežević Bojović, A., Free Access to Information of Public Importance, in: Rabrenović, A., (ed.), 2013, Legal Mechanisms for Prevention of Corruption in Southeast Europe with Special Focus on the Defence Sector, Belgrade, Institute of Comparative Law, pp. 131–152.
Knežević Bojović, A., 2024, Etička i finansijska dimenzija sudske samouprave – prikaz tendencija u Srbiji, Pravni život, Vol. 619, No. 1, pp. 75–94.
Knežević Bojović, A., Ćorić, V., 2023, Challenges of Rule of Law Conditionality in EU Accession, Bratislava Law Review, Vol. 7, No. 1, pp. 41–62.
Knežević Bojović, A., Ćorić, V., 2024, Educational Dimension of Judicial Self-Governance in the Exercise of the Judicial Independence Principle: The Case of Serbia in the European Integration Process, Sociological Review, Vol. 58, Nо. 1, pp. 179–205.
Knežević Bojović, A., Ćorić, V., Matijević, M. V., 2023, Individual judge at the heart of the rule of law – judicial ethics and integrity in the laws of Serbia and Montenegro, pp. 241–276, Bratislava legal forum 2023: State as a protector and violator of individual rights, September 11–12.
Knežević Bojović, A., Misailović, J., 2022, Judges’ Associations and Trade Unions – International Standards and Selected National Practices, Foreign Legal Life, Vol. 66, No. 4, pp. 387–410.
Knežević Bojović, A., Reljanović, M., 2022, Free Access to Information, Belgrade, Institute of Comparative Law.
Kosař, D., 2016, Perils of Judicial Self-Government in Transitional Societies, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
Kosař, D., 2018, Beyond Judicial Councils: Forms, Rationales and Impact of Judicial Self-Governance in Europe, German Law Journal, Vol. 19, No. 7, pp. 1567–1612.
Kosař, D., Šipulová, K., Politics of judicial governance, in: Tushnet, M., Kochenov, D., (eds.), 2023, Research Handbook on the Politics of Constitutional Law, Chelten- ham, Edward Elgar Publishing, pp. 262–285.
Kosař, D., Šipulová, K., Kadlec, O., 2024, The Case for Judicial Councils as Fourth-Branch Institutions, European Constitutional Law Review, Vol. 20, No. 1, p. 83.
Kosař, D., Vincze, A., 2023, European Standards of Judicial Governance: From Soft Law Standards to Hard Law, Journal für Rechtspolitik, Vol. 30, No. 4, pp. 491–501.
Mathieu, E., Verhoest, K., Matthys, J., 2016, Measuring Multi-Level Regulatory Governance: Organizational Proliferation, Coordination and Concentration of Influence, Regulation & Governance, Vol. 11, No. 3, pp. 252–268.
Pech, L., 2022, The Rule of Law as a Well Established and Well-Defined Principle of EU Law, Hague Journal on the Rule of Law, Vol. 14, Nos. 2–3, pp. 107–138.
Pérez, A. T., 2018, Judicial Self-Government and Judicial Independence: The Political Capture of the General Council of the Judiciary in Spain, German Law Journal, Vol. 19, No. 7, pp. 1769–1800.
Rakić Vodinelić, V., Knežević Bojović, A., Reljanović, M., 2013, Judicial Reform in Serbia 2008–2012, Belgrade, Centar za unapređivanje pravnih studija.
Simović, D., 2023, Constitutionalization of the Judicial Council in North Mace- donia and Serbia – Can We Learn from Each Other?, Foreign Legal Life, Vol. 67, No. 4, pp. 623–642.
Smithey, S., Ishiyama, J., 2000, Judicious Choices: Designing Courts in Post-Communist Politics. Communist and Post-Communist Studies, Vol. 33, No. 2, pp. 163–182.
Spáč, S., Šipulová, K., Urbániková, M., 2018, Capturing the Judiciary from Inside: The Story of Judicial Self-Governance in Slovakia, German Law Journal, Vol. 19, No. 7, pp. 1741–1768.
Spajić, B., Đorđević, M., 2024, Who Works More, and Who Works Smarter? Comparing Judicial Performance in Europe, Pravni zapisi, Vol. 15, No. 1, pp. 121–150.
Stanić, M., 2022, Sudski saveti: sastav i nadležnosti širom Evrope, Belgrade, Institut za uporedno pravo.
Stein, R., 2009, Rule of Law: What Does It Mean? Minnesota Journal of International Law, Vol. 18, No. 2 pp. 293–303.
Šipulová, K. et al., 2023, Judicial Self-Governance Index: Towards better understanding of the role of judges in governing the judiciary. Regulation & Governance, Vol. 17, No. 1, pp. 22–42.
Urbániková M., Šipulová K., 2018, Failed Expectations: Does the Establishment of Judicial Councils Enhance Confidence in Courts?, German Law Journal, Vol. 19, No. 7, pp. 2105–2136.
Legislative Sources
Action Plan for Chapter 23, adopted by the Government of Serbia on 27 April 2016.
Amendments to the Law on Organizations of the Courts Official Gazette of the RS, Nos. 13/2016, 08/2016, 113/2017, and 87/2018.
CCJE, Opinion No. 1 (2001) of the CCJE for the Attention of the Committee of Min- isters of the CoE on Standards Concerning the Independence of the Judiciary and the Irremovability of Judges, CCJE (2001) OP No. 1, 23 November 2001.
CCJE, Opinion No. 24 (2021) on the evolution of the Councils for the Judiciary and their role in independent and impartial judicial systems, CCJE (2021) 11, 5 November 2021.
Court Rules of Procedure, Official Gazette of the RS, Nos. 110/2009, 70/2011, 19/2012, 89/2013, 96/2015, 104/2015, 113/2015, 39/2016, 56/2016, 77/2016, 16/2018, 78/2018, 43/2019, 93/2019, and 18/2022.
Law on the Organization of Courts, Official Gazette of the RS, Nos. 116/2008, 104/2009, 101/2010, 31/2011, 78/2011, 101/2011, and 101/2013.
Constitution of the Republic of Serbia, Official Gazette of the RS, Nos. 98/2006 and 115/2021.
Decision on Establishment of the Sectorial Council for Information-Communication Technologies, Official Gazette of the RS, No. 33/2016.
Government Rules of Procedure, Official Gazette of the RS, Nos. 6/2002, 12/2002, 41/2002, 99/2003 and 113/2004.
Government Rules of Procedure, Official Gazette of the RS, Nos. 61/2006, 69/2008, 88/2009, 33/2010, 69/2010, 20/2011, 37/2011, 30/2013, 76/2014, and 8/2019.
Law on the High Council of the Judiciary, Official Gazette of the RS, Nos. 63/2001, 42/2002, 39/2003, and 41/2003.
Law on Judges, Official Gazette of the RS, No. 10/2023.
Law on the Organization of Courts, Official Gazette of the RS, No. 10/2023.
Rulebook on Criteria, Measures, Procedures and Bodies for Evaluating the Work of Judges and Court Presidents, Official Gazette of the RS, Nos. 81/2014–54, 142/2014–240, 41/2015–185, and 7/2016–23.
Strategy for the Development of ICT in the Judiciary for the 2022–2027.
Strategy of Human Resources in the Judiciary for the 2022–2026 Period, Official Gazette of the RS, No. 133/ 2021.
Law on Training of Judges, Public Prosecutors, Public Prosecutor Deputies, and Judicial and Prosecutorial Assistants, Official Gazette of the RS, No. 46/2006.
Law on the High Judicial Council, Official Gazette of the RS, No. 10/2023.
Case Law
CJEU, Joined Cases C-585/18, C-624/18 and C-625/18 A. K. and Others v. Sąd Najwyższy, CP v. Sąd Najwyższy, and DO v. Sąd Najwyższy, Judgment of 19 No- vember 2019, ECLI:EU:C:2019:982.
Constitutional Court, IUZ-497/2011, Decision of 20 March 2014. Official Gazette of the RS, No. 32/14.
Constitutional Court, IUZ 34/2016, Decision of 15 November 2018, Official Ga- zette of the RS, No, 88/2018.
ECtHR, Guðmundur Andri Ástráðsson v. Iceland, No. 26374/18, Judgment of 1 December 2020 [GC].
Internet Sources
Bjelogrlić, S., Boljević, D., 2022, Odstupanja radne verzije Zakona o Visokom savetu sudstva od predloga Radne grupe – komentari, (https://www.mpravde.gov. rs/files/2022%2009%2015%20Zakon%20o%20VSS%20Dragana%20Boljević%20 i%20Snežana%20Bjelogrlić.pdf, 12. 10. 2024).
Boljević, D., 2020, Osporavanje legitimiteta sudske vlasti u procesu ustavnog uređenja nezavisnosti sudstva na primeru Srbije, Sarajevo, Fondacija Centar za javno pravo, (https://www.ceeol.com/search/gray-literature-detail?id=1072499, 10. 10. 2024).
Brooks, J., An Analysis of Magistrates Training in Serbia: Findings and recommen- dations, UNDP, (https://www.undp.org/sites/g/files/zskgke326/files/migration/ rs/UNDP_SRB_An_Analysis_of_Magistrates_Training_in_Serbia_-_Findings_ and_Recommendations.pdf, 10. 10. 2024).
Castillo-Ortiz, P., 2023, Judicial Governance and Democracy in Europe, Cham: Springer, (https://link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978–3–031–20190–5, 14. 11. 2024).
CCJE, CCJE Opinions and Magna Carta, (https://www.coe.int/en/web/ccje/ccje- opinions-and-magna-carta, 10. 10. 2024).
CoE, 2019, Supreme Court of Slovenia wins Crystal Scales of Justice Prize, 25 October, (https://go.coe.int/6sVRr, 12. 10. 2024).
ECtHR Press Unit, 2023, Independence of the justice system, (https://www.echr. coe.int/documents/d/echr/FS_Independence_justice_ENG, 4. 10. 2024).
Judges’ Association of Serbia, 2024, Neprimerena brzina šteti kvalitetu zakona o Pravosudnoj akademiji, (https://www.sudije.rs/Item/Details/1020, 30. 9. 2024).
Knežević Bojović, A., 2020, Disciplinska odgovornost EU za Srbiju – Ažurirani pregled pravnog okvira i prakse, Belgrade, Support to The High Judicial Council of the Republika of Srbija–GIZ, (https://support-to-high-judicial-council.euza- tebe.rs/rs/preuzimanje/145, 12. 10. 2024).
Manko, R. 2023, European Parliament Briefing ECJ case law on judicial independ- ence: A chronological overview, (https://www.europarl.europa.eu/RegData/etudes/ BRIE/2023/753955/EPRS_BRI(2023)753955_EN.pdf, 11. 10. 2024).
Marinković, T., 2022, Judicial Self-governance and Judicial Culture in Serbia, Skop- je, Institute for Democracy “Societas Civilis”, (https://idscs.org.mk/wp-content/ uploads/2022/05/B5_JUDICIAL-SELF-GOVERNANCE-AND-JUDICIAL-CUL- TURE-IN-SERBIA.pdf, 12. 10. 2024).
Multi Donor Trust Fund for Justice Sector Support in Serbia, 2014, Serbia Judicial Functional Review, (https://www.mdtfjss.org.rs/en/serbia-judical-functional-re- view, 14. 10. 2024).
Papić, T., 2016, Pravo i praksa disciplinske odgovornosti sudija u Srbiji, Belgrade, OSCE Mission to Serbia, (https://www.osce.org/files/f/documents/2/1/263896. pdf, 12. 10. 2024).
Preshova, D., Damjanovski, I., Nechev, Z., 2017, The Effectiveness of the ‘Europe- an Model’ of Judicial Independence in the Western Balkans: Judicial Councils as a Solution or a New Cause of Concern for Judicial Reforms, The Hague, Centre for the Law of EU External Relations, (https://www.asser.nl/media/3475/cleer17–1_ web.pdf, 2. 10. 2024).
Presidents of the Appellate Courts, 2017, Instruction on the Operation of the Court Practice Department in Appellate Court, (http://www.kg.ap.sud.rs/assets/ files/2017/Uputstvo%20o%20radu%20odeljenja%20sudske%20prakse.pdf, 12. 10. 2024).
Supreme Court of the Republic of Serbia, 2014, Activity Plan for the Harmoni- zation of Jurisprudence, (https://www.vrh.sud.rs/sites/default/files/attachments/ PlanAktivnostiVrhovnogKasacionogSuda%20radi%20ujednačavanja%20sud- ske%20prakse.pdf, 12. 10. 2024).