BEYOND GUILTY PLEAS: THE PROCEDURALIZATION OF NEGOTIATED JUSTICE IN INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL TRIBUNALS
Sažetak
Negotiated justice was first codified within the UN Ad Hoc Tribunals, where a consistent body of case law was developed. In contrast, plea-bargaining and guilty pleas were substantially denied in the earlier Nuremberg and Tokyo trials. The paper examines the theoretical and practical development of plea bargaining, tracing the proceduralization of negotiated justice in international criminal tribunals, which has ultimately resulted in the ICC’s abbreviated proceedings on an admission of guilt – a hybrid model incorporating features from civil law and common law systems, representing a compromise of Anglo-Saxon and European legal traditions. The paper also shows that at the ICC, the use of plea bargaining has reached an impasse, primarily due to two factors: its extremely limited application – reflected in only a single case to date – and unclear norms regarding the accused’s rights as well as the length of the proceedings.
Reference
Bibliography
Alschuler, A., 1979, Plea Bargaining and Its History, Columbia Law Review, Vol. 79, No. 1, pp. 1–43.
Beltzer, B. D., 1996, War Crimes: The Nuremberg Trial and the Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia, Valparaiso University Law Review, Vol. 30, No. 3, pp. 895–912.
Burrus, J. E., 2017, “So Far as War Allows”: Why the Al Mahdi Conviction Is Unlikely to Stem the Pace of Cultural Destruction Perpetrated by Non-State Actors, Washington International Law Journal, Vol. 27, No. 1, pp. 317–347.
Chiarini, G., 2021, Negotiated Justice in the ICC: Following the Al Mahdi case, a Proposal to Enforce the Rights of the Accused, PKI Global Justice Journal, Vol. 13, No. 5.
Chiarini, G., 2025, The Evolution of International Criminal Procedure: From Nuremberg and Tokyo to the International Criminal Court, Milton Park, Routledge.
Chifflet, P., Boas, G., 2012, Sentencing Coherence in International Criminal Law: The Cases of Biljana Plavsic and Miroslav Bralo, Criminal Law Forum, Vol. 23, No. 1, pp. 135–159.
Clark, J. N., 2009, Plea Bargaining at the ICTY: Guilty Pleas and Reconciliation, The European Journal of International Law, Vol. 20, No. 2, pp. 415–436.
Combs, N. A., 2002, Copping a Plea to Genocide: The Plea Bargaining of International Crimes, University of Pennsylvania Law Review, Vol. 151, No. 1, pp. 1–157.
Cook, J. A. III, 2005, Plea Bargaining at the Hague, Yale Journal of International Law, Vol. 30, pp. 473–506.
Damaška, M., 2004, Negotiated Justice in International Criminal Courts, Journal of International Criminal Justice, Vol. 2, No. 4, pp. 1018–1039.
Damaška, M., 1997, The Uncertain Fate of Evidentiary Transplants: Anglo-American and Continental Experiments, The American Journal of Comparative Law, Vol. 45, No. 4, pp. 839–852.
D’Ascoli, S., 2011, Sentencing in International Criminal Law: The UN Ad Hoc Tribunals and Future Perspectives for the ICC, Oxford, Hart Publishing.
Fisher, G., 2000, Plea Bargaining’s Triumph, The Yale Law Journal, Vol. 109, pp. 857–1086.
Gerstenblith, P., 2016, The Destruction of Cultural Heritage: A Crime Against Property or a Crime Against People?, J. Marshall Rev. Intell. Prop. L., Vol. 15, No. 3, pp. 336–393.
Haller, M. H., 1979, Plea Bargaining: The Nineteenth Century Context, Law and Society Review, Vol. 13, No. 2, pp. 273–279.
Henham, R., Drumbl, M., 2005, Plea Bargaining at the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia, Criminal Law Forum, Vol. 16, No. 1, pp. 49–87.
Henham, R., 2005, The Ethics of Plea Bargaining in International Criminal Trials, Liverpool Law Review, Vol. 26, No. 3, pp. 209–224.
Hola, B., 2012, Sentencing of International Crimes: Consistency of Sentencing Case Law, Amsterdam Law Forum, Vol. 4, pp. 3–24.
Howe, S. W., 2005, The Value of Plea Bargaining, Oklahoma Law Review, Vol. 58, No. 4, pp. 599–636.
Jørgensen, N., 2002, The Genocide Acquittal in the Sikirica Case Before the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia and the Coming of Age of the Guilty Plea, Leiden Journal of International Law, Vol. 15, No. 2, pp. 389– 407.
Kipnis, K., 1976, Criminal Justice and the Negotiated Plea, Ethics, Vol. 86, No. 2, pp. 93–106.
Kovarovic, K., 2011, Pleading for Justice: The Availability of Plea Bargaining as a Method of Alternative Resolution at the International Criminal Court, Journal of Dispute Resolution, Vol. 2011, No. 2, pp. 283–308.
Langbein, J. H., 1979, Understanding the Short History of Plea Bargaining, Law and Society Review, Vol. 13, No. 2, pp. 261–272.
Langer, M., 2004, From Legal Transplants to Legal Translations: The Globalization of Plea Bargaining and the Americanization Thesis in Criminal Procedure, Harvard International Law Journal, Vol. 45, pp. 1–64.
Ma, Y., 2002, Prosecutorial Discretion and Plea Bargaining in the United States, France, Germany, Italy: A Comparative Perspective, International Criminal Justice Review, Vol. 12, No. 1, pp. 22–52.
Rauxloh, R. E., 2010, Plea bargaining in international criminal justice – Can the International Criminal Court afford to avoid trials?, The Journal of Criminal Justice Research, Vol. 1, No. 2, pp. 1–25.
Sayers, S. M., 2003, Defence Perspectives on Sentencing Practice in the Interna- tional Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia, Leiden Journal of International Law, Vol. 16, No. 4, pp. 751–776.
Scharf, M. P., 1997, Balkan Justice: The Story Behind the First International War Crimes Trial Since Nuremberg, Durham, Carolina Academic Press.
Scharf, M. P., 2004, Trading Justice for Efficiency Plea-Bargaining and International Tribunals, Journal of International Criminal Justice, Vol. 2, No. 4, pp. 1070– 1081.
Sloane, R. D., 2007, Sentencing for the “Crime of Crimes”: The Evolving “Common Law” of Sentencing of the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda, Journal of International Criminal Justice, Vol. 5, pp. 713–734.
Tieger, A., Shin, M., 2005, Plea Agreements in the ICTY. Purpose, Effects and Propriety, Journal of International Criminal Justice, Vol. 3, No. 3, pp. 666–679.
Turner, J. I., 2017, Plea Bargaining and International Criminal Justice, The University of the Pacific Law Review, Vol. 48, pp. 219–246.
Turner, J. I., Plea Bargaining, in Carter, L., Pocar, F., (eds.), 2013, International Criminal Procedure: The Interface of Civil Law and Common Law Legal Systems, Cheltenham, Edward Elgar Publishing Limited, pp. 34–65.
Vasiliev, S., 2014, International criminal trials: A normative theory, PhD thesis, University of Amsterdam, 25 April 2014.
Vrdoljak, A. F., 2018, Prosecutor v. Ahmad Al Faqi Al Mahdi: Judgment and Sentence & Reparations Order (Int’l Crim. Ct.), International Legal Materials, Vol. 57, No. 1, pp. 17–79.
Legislative Sources
Agreement for the Prosecution and Punishment of the Major War Criminals of the European Axis (London Agreement), 8 August 1945, United Nations – Treaty Series, Vol. 82, No. 251, pp. 279–300.
Charter of the International Military Tribunal for the Far East (Tokyo Statute), 19 January 1946.
Instrument of Surrender of Japanese Forces, 2 September 1945.
Office of the Prosecutor, International Criminal Court, Guidelines for Agreements Regarding Admission of Guilt, 12 November 2020.
Regulations of the Office of the Prosecutor of the International Criminal Court (2002).
Regulations of the Registry of the International Criminal Court (2002).
Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court, UN Doc. A/CONF.183/9*, 17 July 1998, entered into force 1 July 2002.
Rules of Procedure and Evidence of the International Criminal Court, adopted by the Assembly of States Parties pursuant to the Rome Statute.
Rules of Procedure and Evidence of the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia (ICTY RPE).
Rules of Procedure and Evidence of the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda (ICTR RPE).
Statute of the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia, UNSC Res. 827, UN Doc. S/RES/827, 25 May 1993.
Statute of the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda, UNSC Res. 955, An- nex, UN Doc. S/RES/955, 8 November 1994.
Case Law
ICC, Prosecutor v. Ahmad Al Faqi Al Mahdi, ICC-01/12-01/15, Judgment and Sentence, 27 September 2016.
ICC, Prosecutor v. Ahmad Al Faqi Al Mahdi, ICC-01/12-01/15, Situation in the Republic of Mali ICC-PIDS-CIS-MAL-01-09/22_Eng, January 2022.
ICTY, Prosecutor v. Dražen Erdemović, IT-96-22-T, Joint Separate Opinion of Judge McDonald and Judge Vohrah, Appeals Chamber, 7 October 1997.
ICTY, Prosecutor v. Dražen Erdemović, IT-96-22-T, Sentencing Judgment, 29 November 1996.
ICTY, Prosecutor v. Dražen Erdemović, IT-96-22-T, Separate and Dissenting Opinion of Judge Cassese, Appeals Chamber, 7 October 1997.
ICTY, Prosecutor v. Miroslav Deronjić, IT-02-61-S, Judgment, 30 March 2004.
ICTY, Prosecutor v. Miroslav Deronjić, IT-02-61-S, Sentencing Judgement, Dissenting Opinion of Judge Schomburg, 30 March 2004.
ICTY, Prosecutor v. Erdemović, Sentencing Judgment (1996), 29 November 1996.
ICTY, Prosecutor v. Galić, IT-98-29-T, Separate and Partially Dissenting Opinion of Judge Meron, 30 November 2006.
ICTR, Prosecutor v. Jean Kambanda, ICTR-97-23-S, Judgment and Sentence, 4 September 1998.
ICTR, Prosecutor v. Jean Kambanda, ICTR-97-23-S, Sentencing Judgment, 4 Sep- tember 1998.
ICTR, Prosecutor v. Ntakirutimana, ICTR-96-17, Decision on the Prosecutor’s motion for Judicial Notice of Adjudicated Facts, 26 November 2001.
ICTY, Prosecutor v. Plavšić, IT-00-39&40/1, Sentencing Judgment, 27 February 2003.
ICTY, Prosecutor v. Ramush Haradinaj, Idriz Balaj and Lahi Brahimaj, IT-04-84, 20 November 2007.
ICTY, Prosecutor v. Shefqet Kabashi, IT-04-84-R77.1, Judgment, 16 September 2011.
ICTY, Prosecutor v. Sikirica et al., IT-95-8-T, Sentencing Judgment, 13 November 2001.
ICTY, Prosecutor v. Todorović, IT-95-9/1, Sentencing Judgment, 31 July 2001.
Other Sources
ICC, Decision on the review concerning reduction of sentence of Mr Ahmad Al Faqi Al Mahdi, Public Redacted Version, ICC-01/12-01/15-434-Red3, 25 November 2021.
ICC, Dépôt de l’Accord sur l’aveu de culpabilité de M. Ahmad Al Faqi Al Mahdi, ICC-01/12-01/15-78-Conf-Exp, 19 August 2006.
ICC, Repatriation order, ICC-01/12-01/15-236, 17 August 2017.
ICC, Situation in the Republic of Mali, Annex 1, Public Redacted Version, ICC- 01/12-01/15-78-Anx1-Red2, 19 August 2016.
ICC, Situation in the Republic of Mali, Public Redacted Version, ICC-01/12- 01/15-84-Red, 24 March 2016.
ICC, Transcript of hearing, ICC-01/12-01/15-T-4-Red-ENG, 22 August 2016.
International Law Commission, Report on the work of its forty-sixth session, 2 May – 22 July 1994, UN Doc. A/49/10, 1 September 1994.
International Military Tribunal, 1947, Trial of the Major War Criminals before the International Military Tribunal (1945), Vol. II. Proceedings: 11/14/1945– 11/30/1945, Nuremberg, IMT, 1947.
Morris, V., Scharf, M. P., 1995, An Insider’s Guide to the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia: A Documentary History and Analysis, London, Transnational Press, pp. 649–652.
UN GA, Preparatory Committee on the Establishment of an International Criminal Court. 12–30 August 1996, UN Doc. A/AC.249/L.6, 13 August 1996.
UN GA, Preparatory Committee on the Establishment of an International Crimi- nal Court. Decision taken by the Preparatory Committee at its Session held from 4 to 15 August 1997. A/AC.249/1997/L.8/Rev.1, 14 August 1997.
UN GA, Preparatory Committee on the Establishment of an International Criminal Court, Proposal submitted by Argentina and Canada for Articles 38, 38 bis, 41 and 43, 12–30 August 1996, UN Doc. A/AC.249/WP.16, 20 August 1996.
UN GA, Report of the Ad Hoc Committee on the Establishment of an International Criminal Court, UN Doc. A/50/22, 6 September 1995.
UN GA, Report of the Preparatory Committee on the Establishment of an International Criminal Court. Volume I, UN Doc. A/51/22, 13 September 1996.
UN Security Council, Resolution 827, UN Doc. S/RES/827, 25 May 1993.
UN Security Council, Resolution 955, UN Doc. S/RES/955, 8 November 1994.