Comparison of slot deformation in stainless steel and ceramic brackets during torque - A finite element analysis

Pandurangan Harikrishnan; Varadaraju Magesh; Devadhas Kingsly Jeba Singh

doi:10.5937/sejodr4-15203

Pandurangan Harikrishnan Teeth”N”Jaws Center, Chennai, India
Varadaraju Magesh SRM University, Department of Mechanical Engineering, Bio-Mechanics Laboratory, Chennai, India
Devadhas Kingsly Jeba Singh SRM University, Department of Mechanical Engineering, Bio-Mechanics Laboratory, Chennai, India

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5937/sejodr4-15203

Abstract

Introduction: Torque in orthodontics is vital in final positioning of the teeth during fixed appliance therapy. Torqueing of archwiresis a significant factor in transferring the applied forces to the bracket which might cause deformation of the slot. Any deformation in the bracket slot can vary the torque prescription and thus can affect the tooth position.

Aim: To evaluate and compare the deformation of stainless steel (SS) and ceramic bracket slots during torque, using finite element analysis.

Materials and methods: A maxillary right central incisor bracket (0.022 x 0.028 inch) dimensions were measured using a profile projector, and a finite element (FE) model was constructed. Bracket materials considered were stainless steel (SS) and ceramic. An SSrectangular archwire (0.019 x 0.025 inch) with angles of twist ranging from 5° to 40° was theoretically converted into torque. The bracket slot deformation was obtained at the top, middle and bottom locations using FE analysis.

Results: There is a uniform increase in deformation in the bracket slot walls from torque of 9.7 to 77.62 Nmm except that there isa 100 percent increase in deformation when the torque changed from 38.81 to 48.51 Nmm. The top location in the gingival slotwall showed maximum deformation compared with middle and bottom slot positions in both the materials. The deformation of SSbracket slot was more than the ceramic bracket slot.

Conclusion: This study showed that the bracket slot walls of both SS and ceramic brackets are subjected to deformation by application of torque and the maximum deformation was in the upper part of the bracket slot.

References

Archambault A, Lacoursiere R, Badawi H, Major PW, Carey J, Flores-Mir C. Torque expression in stainless steel orthodontic brackets. A systematic review. Angle Orthod. 2010;80(1):201-10.

Sebanc J, Brantley WA, Pincsak JJ, Conover JP. Variability of effective root torque as a function of edge bevel on orthodontic arch wires. Am J Orthod. 1984;86(1):43-51.

Badawi HM, Toogood RW, Carey JP, Heo G, Major PW. Torque expression of self-ligating brackets. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 2008;133(5):721-8.

Harzer W, Bourauel C, Gmyrek H. Torque capacity of metal and polycarbonate brackets with and without a metal slot. Eur J Orthod. 2004;26(4):435-41.

Hirai M, Nakajima A, Kawai N, Tanaka E, Igarashi Y, Sakaguchi M, Sameshima GT, Shimizu N. Measurements of the torque moment in various archwire-bracketligation combinations. Eur J Orthod. 2012;34(3):374-80.

Lacoursiere RA, Nobes DS, Homeniuk DL, Carey JP, Badawi HH, Major PW. Measurement of orthodontic bracket tie wing elastic and plastic deformation by arch wire torque expression utilizing an optical image correlation technique. J Dent Biomech. 2010;2010.

Major TW, Carey JP, Nobes DS, Heo G, Major PW. Measurement of plastic and elastic deformation due to third-order torque in self-ligated orthodontic brackets. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 2011;140(3):326-39.

Melenka GW, Nobes DS, Major PW, Carey JP. Three-dimensional deformation of orthodontic brackets. J Dent Biomech. 2013;4:1758736013492529.

Segerlind LJ. Applied finite element analysis. 2nd ed. USA: John Wiley & Sons.1984.

Jones ML, Hickman J, Middleton J, Knox J, Volp C. A validated finite element method study of orthodontic tooth movement in the human subject. J Orthod.2001;28(1):29-38.

Wakabayashi N, Ona M, Suzuki T, Igarashi Y. Nonlinear finite element analyses: advances and challenges in dental applications. J Dent. 2008;36(7):463-71.

Papageorgiou SN, Keilig L, Hasan I, Jager A, Bourauel C. Effect of material variation on the biomechanical behaviour of orthodontic fixed appliances: a finite element analysis. Eur J Orthod. 2016;38(3):300-7.

Hearn EJ. Mechanics of materials. 3rd ed. Elsevier. 2008.

Ghosh J, Nanda RS, Duncanson MG Jr, Currier GF. Ceramic bracket design: an analysis using the finite element method. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 1995;108(6):575-82.

Holt MH, Nanda RS, Duncanson MG Jr. Fracture resistance of ceramic brackets during arch wire torsion. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 1991;99(4):287-93.

Nishio C, Mendes Ade M, Almeida MA, Tanaka E, Tanne K, Elias CN. Evaluation of esthetic brackets’ resistance to torsional forces from the archwire. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 2009;135(1):42-8.

Matsui S, Umezaki E, Komazawa D, Otsuka Y, Suda N. Evaluation of mechanical properties of esthetic brackets. J Dent Biomech. 2015;26;6:1758736015574401.