Empirijsko istraživanje uloge međunarodnog prava u radu Saveta bezbednosti UN
Sažetak
Empirijsko istraživanje međunarodnog prava predstavlja predmet sve većeg interesovanja u naučnim krugovima u svetu. U ovom radu je predstavljen primer jednog takvog istraživanja. Empirijskim istraživanjen podataka o pozicijama koje su iznete povodom upotrebe sile protiv SR Jugoslavije 1999. testirana je hipoteza o operativnoj ulozi međunarodnog prava u radu Saveta bezbednosti UN: da li je ono korišćeno u formiranju pozicija, u oceni situacije i u predlaganju njenog rešenja. U uvodnom delu rada predstavljene su osnovne odlike i razvoj empirijskog istraživanja međunarodnog prava. Potom je usledio osvrt na osnovna teorijska polazišta o ulozi međunarodnog prava. U narednimm delovima rada autor je izložio hipotetički okvir, metode i rezultate istraživanja. Na kraju, izvedeni su zaključci o rezultatim istraživanja, ali je i ukazano da je neophodno raditi na širenju i razvoju znanja koja su neophodna za sprovođene empirijskog istraživanja međunarodnog prava i otvoriti raspravu o njegovim mogćnostima i dometima u naci međunarondog prava.
Reference
Allot Philip, “True Function of Law in International Community”, Indiana Journal of Global Legal Studies, 5/1998, 391-413.
Baylis Elena, “The Transformative Potential of Rigorous Empirical Research”, ASIL Proceedings 2010, 31-33.
Bryman Alan, Social Research Methods, Oxford University Press, New York 2012.
Dajović Goran, „Proučavanje prava – pravna nauka, teorija i filozofija“, Pravni zapisi 2/2017,222-248.
Deplano Rosanna, “The Use of International Law by the United Nations Security Council: An Empirical Framework for Analysis”, Emory International Law Review 2015, 2085-2112.
Deplano Rosanna, The Strategic Use of International Law by the United Nations Security Council: An Empirical Study, Springer, Heidelberg-New York 2015.
Eisenberg Theodore, “The Origins, Nature, and Promise of Empirical Legal Studies and a Response to Concerns”, University of Illinois Law Review 5/2011, 1713-1738.
Franck Susan D., “Empiricism and International Law: Insights for Investment Treaty Dispute Resolution”, Virginia Journal of International Law, 4/2008.
Gangrade K.D., “Empirical Methods as Tools of Research”, Journal of the Indian Law Institute 24/1982, 635-654.
Holtermann Jakob v.H., Madsen Mikael Rask, “Toleration, Synthesis or Replacement? The ‘Empirical Turn’ and its Consequences for the Science of International Law”, Leiden Journal of International Law 2016, 1001-1019.
Holtermann Jakob v. H., Kjær Anne Lise, “What 'If'? The Emerging Epistemic Community of International Criminal Justice”, European Journal of Legal Studies Special Issue 2019, 49-90.
Hurd Ian, “The UN Security Council and the International Rule of Law”, Chinese Journal of International Politics 3/2014, 361-379.
Knežević-Predić Vesna, Hrnjaz Miloš, „Čemu služi međunarodno pravo: pogled iz Srbije“, Zbornik radova sa međunarodne naučne konferencije Politika: nauka i profesija (ur. Milan Podunavac, Žarko Paunović), maj-jun 2013, Beograd, 251-264.
Kritzer Herbert M., “The (Nearly) Forgotten Early Empirical Legal Research”, The Oxford Handbook of Empirical Legal Research (eds. Peter Cane, Herbert M. Kritzer), New York 2010, 875-900.
Kumar Shashank P., Rose Cecily, “A Study of Lawyers Appearing before the International Court of Justice, 1999–2012”, European Journal of International Law 3/2014, 893–917.
Ma Xuechan, Guo Shuai, "An Empirical Study of the Voting Pattern of Judges of the International Court of Justice (2005-2016)", Erasmus Law Review 3/2017, 163-174.
Milić Tatjana, „Empirijsko istraživanje prava: revolucija ili nemoguća misija?, Anali Pravnog fakulteta u Beogradu 3/2019, 95-123.
Onderco Michal, Hola Barbora, Ruiter Stijn, “Testing Detachment of International Criminal Tribunals: Empirical Evidence from the ICTY”, Transnational Legal Theory 4/2013, 396-418.
Pečujlić Miroslav, Milić Vladimir, Metodologija društvenih nauka, Grafika, Beograd 1995.
Pound Roscoe, Social Control through Law, Yale University Press, New Haven 1942.
Sadl Urska, Panagis Yannis, “What is a Leading Case in EU law? An empirical analysis”, European Law Review 1/2015, 15-34.
Scalia Damien, Devresse Marie-Sophie, “Empirical analysis of international criminal law: perception and experience of tried people”, The Oxford Handbook of International Criminal Law (eds. J. K. Heller et al.), Oxford 2019.
Shaffer Gregory, Ginsburg Tom, “The Empirical Turn in International Legal Scholarship”, American Journal of International Law, 106/2012, 1-46.
Shany Yuval, Assessing the Effectiveness of International Courts, Oxford University Press, Oxford 2014.
Simmons Beth A., Mobilizing for Human Rights: International Law in Domestic Politics, Cambridge University Press, New York 2009.
van Dijck Gijs, Sverdlov Shahar, Buck Gabriela, “Empirical Legal Research in Europe: Prevalence, Obstacles and Interventions”, Erasmus Law Review 2/2018, 105-119.
Yasuaki Onuma,” International Law in and with International Politics: The Functions of International Law in International Society”, European Journal of International Law 1/2003, 105-139.
Ђајић Сања, Практикум за међународно јавно право - општи део, Универзитет у Новом Саду - Правни факултет, Нови Сад 2007.
ASIL 104th Annual Meeting, International Law in Times of Change, Empirical Approaches to International Law, 2010, https://www.asil.org/sites/default/files/ASIL_ANNUAL_MEETING_Program_2010.pdf 09.08.2019.
Burniske Jessica S., Modirzadeh Naz K., Pilot Empirical Survey Study on the Impact of Counterterrorism Measures on Humanitarian Action, HLS PILAC, CHE Project, March 2017, http://blogs.harvard.edu/pilac/files/2017/03/Pilot-Empirical-Survey-Study-2017.pdf, 16.08.2019.
Harvard Law School, Empirical Approaches to International Law, https://hls.harvard.edu/academics/curriculum/catalog/default.aspx?o=70516, 15.08.2019.
The Neglected Methodologies of International Law: Empirical, Socio-legal and Comparative, University of Leicester, 31 January 2018, https://www2.le.ac.uk/departments/law/research/celi/files/neglected-methodologies-of-international-law-programme, 15.08.2019.
СБУН https://www.un.org/securitycouncil/.
S/PRST/1999/12 14. мај 1999.
S/PV.3988 24. март 1999.
S/PV.3989 26. март 1999.
S/PV.4000 8. мај 1999.
S/PV.4003 14. мај 1999.