A CONTRIBUTION TO SLAVERY DEBATE: DOMESTIC LABOR OF MIGRANT CHILDREN IN FOCUS
Sažetak
Slavery and connected practices are ostensibly forgotten phenomenons, often considered they belong to the past. However, the migrant movements are placing focus on these forbidden practices and they are getting new features. The purpose of this paper is to (re)consider specific cases, those with European Court of Human Rights epilogue, where children were victims. Taking into account contemporary considerations on slavery and related practices we question the outcome analyzing key elements related to slavery notion. Emphasis is placed on insufficiently functional definitions in this area, the uncertainity of assessment criteria and comparison to judgments made by other courts. Considering that European Convention of Human Rights is described as the most powerful human rights protection mechanism with great impact on national (criminal) law systems, we search to see how the Convention ban is brought to life, analyze recent developments in this area, offering a different perspective to slavery notion.
Keywords: Slavery, Servitude, Children, European Convention of Human Rights, Domestic Labour.
Reference
Angelika Kartusch, Domestic Workers in Diplomats’ Households Rights Violations and Access to Justice in the Context of Diplomatic Immunity. Analysis of Practice in Six European Countries. German Institute for Human Rights (2011).
Ariela J. Gross and Chantal Thomas, ʻThe New Abolitionism, International Law and the Memory of Slaveryʼ 35 Law and History Review (2017) 99-118.
Barbara Herceg Pakšić and Miroslav Jukić, ʻPrimjena konvencijskog prava u području zabrane ropstva i prisilnog rada: Europski standardi i hrvatska postignućaʼ /ECHR Prohibition of Slavery and Forced Labour: European Standards and Croatian Accomplishments/23 Hrvatski ljetopis za kaznene znanosti i praksu, (2016).
David Keane, ʻAbolitionist At Heart but not in Action, Slavery, Servitude and the Status of Art. 4 ECHR in Irish Lawʼ 50 Irish Jurist (2013) 166-198.
David Tolbert and Laura A. Smith, 2016. ʻComplementarity and the Investigation and Prosecution of Slavery Crimesʼ14 Journal of International Criminal Justice (2016) 429–451.
David Weissbrodt, ‘Slavery’ Max Planck Encyclopedia of Public International Law (2015) available at opil.ouplaw.com/view/10.1093/law:epil/9780199231690/law-9780199231690-e874, accessed 02 April 2019
David Weissbrodt, and Cheryl Heilman, ʻDefining Torture and Cruel, Inhuman, and Degrading Treatmentʼ 29 Law & Inequality, (2011) 343-394
Harmen van der Wilt, ʻSlavery Prosecutions in International Criminal Jurisdictionʼ 14 Journal of International Criminal Justice (2016) 269–283
Helen Duffy, ʻLitigating Modern Day Slavery in Regional Courts: A Nascent Contributionʼ 14 Journal of International Criminal Justice (2016) 375–403.
Irina Kolodizner, ʻR v Tang: Developing an Australian Anti-Slavery Jurisprudenceʼ 31 Sydney Law Review (2009) 487-497, at pp. 491-495.
Jacqueline Bhabha and Wendy Young, ʻNot Adults in Miniature: Unaccompanied Child Asylum Seekers and the New US Guidelinesʼ11 International Journal of Refugee Law (1999) 84-125.
Jean Allain and Robin Hickey, ʻProperty and Definition of Slaveryʼ 61 International and Comparative Law Quarterly (2012) 915-938.
Jean Allain, ʻR v Tang, Clarifying the Definition of Slavery in International Lawʼ10 Melbourne Journal of International Law 10 (2009) pp. 246-255.
Jean Allain, ʻThe Definition of Slavery in International Lawʼ52 Howard Law Journal (2009) 239-275.
Jean Allan and Kevin Bales, ʻSlavery and its Definitionsʼ14 Global Dialogue 14 Research Paper No. 12-06, (2012) pp. 3-7, available at hydra.hull.ac.uk/assets/hull:9986/content, accessed 15 March 2019.
Lucas Knott, ʻUnocal Revisited: On the difference between Slavery and Forced Labor in International Lawʼ 28 Wisconsin International Law Journal (2010) 201-233.
M. Cherif Bassiouni, ʻInternational Crimes: Jus Cogens and Obligations Erga Omnesʼ 4 Law and Contemporary Problems (2013) pp. 63-74.
Maja Munivrana Vajda, Sudska praksa /Court practice, 24 Hrvatski ljetopis za kaznene znanosti i praksu/Croatian Annual for Criminal Law Sciences and Practice, (2017) pp. 723-728.
Manfred Nowak and Elizabeth McArthur, ʻThe distinction between torture and cruel, inhuman or degrading treatmentʼ 16 Torture (2006) 147-151.
Mary E. Crock, ʻOf Relative Rights and Putative Children: Rethinking the Critical Framework for the Protection of Refugee Children and Youthʼ 54 Australian International Law Journal (2013) 33-53
Orlando Patterson, Slavery and social death: A comparative study (Harvard University Press, 1982), pp. 1-14
Ramona Vijeyarasa and Jose Miguel Bello Villarino, ʻModern Day Slavery-a Judicial Catchall for Trafficking, Slavery and Labour Exploitation: A Critique of Tang and Rantsevʼ 38 Journal of International Law and International Relation (2013) 38-76.
Urmila Bhoola and Kari Panaccione ʻSlavery Crimes and the Mandate of the United Nations Special Rapporteur on Contemporary Forms of Slaveryʼ 14 Journal of International Criminal Justice (2016) 363–373, at 368.
Virginia Mantouvalou, ʻThe Many Faces of Slavery: the Example of Domestic Workʼ 2012,www.academia.edu/1522698/The_Many_Faces_of_Slavery_The_Example_of_Domestic_Work, accessed 10 April 2019
Vladislava Stoyanova, ʻArticle 4 of ECHR and the obligation of Criminalizing Slavery, Servitude, Forced labour and Human Traffickingʼ 3 Cambridge Journal of International and Comparative Law (2014) 407-443.
Vladislava Stoyanova, Human Trafficking and Slavery Reconsidered, Conceptual Limits and States´Positive Obligations, Cambridge University Press, 2017.
Wiliam A. Schabas, The European Convention of Human Rights, A Commentary, Oxford University Press, 2015.
7th General Report on GRETA Activities. March 2018. Available online at rm.coe.int/greta-2018-1-7gr-en/16807af20e
Bellagio-Harvard Guidelines on the Legal Parameters of Slavery. Ten guidelines aimed at clarifying the slavery determination based on Art. 1 of the 1296 Slavery Convention and Art. 7 (a) of the 1956 Supplementary Convention. www.law.qub.ac.uk/schools/SchoolofLaw/FileStore/Filetoupload,651854,en.pdf, accessed 10 April 2019.
Convention Concerning Forced or Compulsory Labour, 1930 (No.29).
Convention on the Rights of the Child, United Nations, 1989.
Convention to Suppress the Slave Trade and Slavery, 1926, 46 Stat. 2183, Treaty Series 778.
Council of Europe Recommendation 1523 (2001) on Domestic Slavery
Domestic Slavery Report, CoE Parliamentary Assembly, Committe on Equal Oportunities for Woman and Men, Rapporteur: Mr John Connor, Doc.9102, 17 May 2001, Summary, and Council of Europe Recommendation 1523 (2001) on Domestic Slavery
Domestic Slavery, au pairs and mail-order brides, Council of Europe (CoE) Parliamentary Assembly, Doc. 10144, Report of Committee on Equal Opportunities for Woman and Men, Rapporteur: Mr Giuseppe Gaburro, 19 April 2004, point 6.
European Convention on Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, Council of Europe 1950.
Guide on Article 4 of the Convention – Prohibition of slavery and forced labour, European Court of Human Rights, 31 December 2018, at 6.
ILO Convention (No. 182) concerning the Prohibition and Immediate Action for the Elimination of the Worst Forms of Child Labour, Geneva on 17 June 1999 ([2007] ATS 38).
Modern Slavery Act No. 153, 2018, C2018A00153.
Protocol on the Prevention, Suppression and Punishment of Trafficking in Persons, especially Women and Children, the Convention on the Abolition of Slavery Application No 67724/09, 11 October 2012.
Protocol to Prevent, Suppress and Punish Trafficking in Persons, Especially Women and Children, supplementing the United Nations Convention against Transnational Organized Crime, New York on 15 November 2000 ([2005] ATS 27)
Ready for future challenges-Reinforcing the Council of Europe, Report by the Secretary General for the Ministerial Session in Helsinki, 16-17 May 2019, April 2019.
Report of the Special Rapporteur on Contemporary Forms of Slavery, including its causes and consequences, Gulnara, United Nations, General Assembly, A/HRC/15/20/Add.2, 16 August 2010, pp 2-4. David Weissbrodt and Anti-Slavery International (Michael Dottridge). Abolishing Slavery and its Contemporary Forms, Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights. United Nations New York and Geneva HR/PUB/02/4 2002.
Rome statute of the International Criminal Court 1998
The Supplementary Convention on the Abolition of Slavery, The Slave Trade and Institutions and Practices similar to Slavery 1956, UNTS 266, I. Nos 3822-3833.
UN Human Rights Council (2017) Report of the Special Rapporteur on contemporary forms of slavery including its causes and consequences, A/HRC/36/43.
United Nations, Committee on Migrant Workers 2011: General Comment on Migrant Domestic Workers: CMW/C/GC/1, 23 February 2011.
Croatian County Court Sisak KMP-33/2011
Croatian Supreme Court VSRH, I Kž 274/13-7
European Court of Human Rights Application number, M. and others v Italy and Bulgaria, Application No 40020/03, 31 July 2012
European Court of Human Rights, C. N. and V. v France, Application No 67724/09, 11 October 2012.
European Court of Human Rights, Siliadin v France, Application No 73316/01, 26 July 2005.
International Court of Justice, Barcelona Traction, Light and Power Company, Limited, Belgium v. Spain, Second Phase, 05 February 1970. Available at www.icj-cij.org/files/case-related/50/050-19700205-JUD-01-00-EN.pdf 12 12 2017, p. 32, paras. 33-34, accessed 20 August 2019
International Tribunal for the Prosecution of Persons Responsible for Serious Violations of International Humanitarian Law Committed in the Territory of the Former Yugoslavia since 1991, IT-96-23& IT-96-23/1-A, 12 June 2002. Judgment of June 2002, Prosecutor v Dragoljub Kunarac, Radomir Kovač and Zoran Vuković, available at www.icty.org/x/cases/kunarac/acjug/en/kun-aj020612e.pdf, accessed 13 September 2019
The Queen v Tang, [2008] HCA 39, 28 August 2008, M5/2008. Available at www.austlii.edu.au/cgi-bin/sinodisp/au/cases/cth/HCA/2008/39.html?stem=0&synonyms=0&query=title(%222008%20HCA%2039%22, accessed 13 January 2019.
Ramachandra Komala, ʻAustralia Starts Tackling Modern Slavery. New South Wales Adds Penalties for Offenders Under State Lawʼ Human Rights Watch, available on www.hrw.org/news/2019/01/09/australia-starts-tackling-modern-slavery, accessed 25 September 2019.
www.crin.org/en/library/publications/forms-violence-slavery, accessed 17 July 2019.
www.crin.org/en/library/publications/france-exploitation-case-sees-slavery-criminalised-last, accessed 12 December 2018
www.crin.org/en/library/publications/united-kingdom-child-domestic-slavery-growing-phenomenon-uk, accessed 17 July 2019.
www.euronews.com/2017/04/28/hungary-completes-new-anti-migrant-border-fence-with-serbia, accessed 25 June 2019.
www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2015/30/contents/enacted, accessed 25 August 2019.
www.theguardian.com/world/2017/jun/21/trial-begins-over-deaths-of-71-migrants-in-refrigerated-lorry, accessed 17 July 2019.
David Weissbrodt and Anti-Slavery International (Michael Dottridge). Abolishing Slavery and its Contemporary Forms, Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights. United Nations New York and Geneva HR/PUB/02/4 2002.