Dealing with Demography. Immigration Restrictions in the United States c. 1880-1930 and the Literature of Exclusion
Abstract
The article investigates immigration restrictions in the United States circa 1880 to 1930. The emphasis is on the rhetoric and arguments utilized by supporters of limiting the intake. In the time period, immigrants from southern and eastern Europe grew as a proportion of the total. The anticipated resulting demographic change was worrying to traditionalist Americans and to the labour movement. Yet their country had always progressed through arrivals from overseas. How could they formulate mechanisms of exclusion which distinguished between people who were similar to themselves and those who brought something new? The racist conservationist Madison Grant drew upon anthropology and history for his contention that Americans were a great fusion of pioneers from northern Europe. The historian and journalist Lothrop Stoddard continued this line of reasoning. Both were organized supporters of eugenics, a doctrine used to ‘fine-tune’ racist discourses. However, eugenics was only a factor in the last two decades of the period. The labour movement and others had been clamouring for immigration restrictions long before that, roused to action especially by the arrival of Chinese workers. The pamphlet Meat vs. Rice by American Federation of Labor leader Samuel Gompers and Herman Gutstadt, originally published in 1902, applied crude racism to limit competition from such entrants in the job market. A dividing line was drawn between those who could become American and those who could not, buttressed by the Naturalization Law of 1870 and the Chinese Exclusion Acts of 1882 and 1902. The negative contentions against immigrants from less familiar places had significant influence on the Immigration Act of 1924. The article argues that Yankee intellectuals often had a conception of America as a British republic, in which related peoples were assimilable and valuable too.
References
Morgan K. English and American attitudes towards convict transportation 1718-1775. History. 1987;72(236):416-431.
Berlin I. Many thousands gone. The first two centuries of slavery in North America. Cambridge MA: The Belknap Press; 2003.
Department of the Interior, Census Office. Statistics of the population of the United States at the Tenth census (June 1, 1880). Washington: Government Printing Office; 1883.
Department of the Interior, Census Office. Report on population of the United States at the Eleventh census: 1890. Washington DC: Government Printing Office; 1895.
Department of Commerce, Bureau of the Census. Washington abstract of the Fourteenth census of the United States 1920. Washington: Government Printing Office; 1923.
Ludmerer KM. Genetics and American society. A historical appraisal. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press; 1972.
Galton F. Hereditary genius. An inquiry into its laws and consequences. London: Macmillan; 1869.
Ross A. The rest is noise. Listening to the twentieth century. London: Fourth Estate; 2008.
Hillstrom K. The dream of America: immigration 1870-1920. Detroit: Omnigraphics; 2009.
Engels F. The condition of the working class in England in 1844. London: Swan Sonnenschein; 1892.
Gompers S, Gutstadt H. Meat vs. Rice. American manhood against Asiatic cooleism. Which shall survive? San Francisco: Asiatic Exclusion League; 1908.
Roberts WK. The Mongolian problem in America. A discussion of the possibilities of the yellow peril, with notes upon American diplomacy in its relation to the boycott. San Francisco: Organized Labor Print; 1906.
Livesay HC. Samuel Gompers and organized labor in America. Boston: Little Brown and Company; 1978. See Gutstadt’s obituary in Jewish News of Northern California. January 19, 1917:4.
Black E. War against the weak. Eugenics and America’s campaign to create a master race. New York: Four Walls Eight Windows; 2003.
Ripley WZ. The races of Europe. A sociological study (Lowell Institute Lectures) (New York: D. Appleton and Company, 1910), p. 55.
Alexander CC. Prophet of American racism: Madison Grant and the Nordic myth. Phylon. 1962;23(1):73-90.
Grant M. The passing of the great race or the racial basis of European history. New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons; 1916.
Laughlin HH. The second international exhibition of eugenics. Baltimore: Williams & Wilkins Company; 1923.
Stoddard L. The rising tide of color against white world supremacy. New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons; 1923.
Stoddard L. The Japanese question in California. The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science. 1921;93(1):42-47.
Stoddard L. Pan-Turanism. The American Political Science Review. 1917;11(1):12-23.
Schmidt R. Red scare. FBI and the origins of anticommunism in the United States, 1919-1943. Copenhagen: Museum Tusculanum Press; 2004.
Stoddard L. The revolt against civilization. The menace of the under man. New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons; 1922.
Turda M, Quine MS. Historicizing Race. London: Bloomsbury Academic; 2018.
Hollingworth LS. Gifted children. Their nature and nurture. New York: Macmillan; 1927.
Selden S. Inheriting shame. The story of eugenics and racism in America. New York: Teachers College Press; 1999.
Kevles DJ. In the name of eugenics. Genetics and the uses of human heredity. Berkeley: University of California Press; 1986.
Hagedorn H, editor. The Americanism of Theodore Roosevelt. Selections from his writing and speeches. Boston: Houghton Mifflin; 1923.
Barkan E. The retreat of scientific racism. Changing concepts of race in Britain and the United States between the World Wars. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 1992.
Hansen R, Desmond King D. Sterilized by the state. Eugenics, race, and the population scare in twentieth-century North America. New York: Cambridge University Press; 2013.
Brigham CC. A study of American intelligence. Princeton: Princeton University Press; 1923.
Gould SJ. The mismeasure of man. London: Penguin; 1992.
Redvaldsen D. A history of British eugenics since 1865. From Francis Galton to designer babies. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan; 2024.
McDougall W. Is America safe for democracy? Six lectures given at the Lowell Institute of Boston. New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons; 1921.
Hasian MA. The rhetoric of eugenics in Anglo-American thought. Athens GA: University of Georgia Press; 1996.
