REMEDYING THE DEFECTS IN INDIA’S CREDIT AND INSOLVENCY FRAMEWORKS WITH ADAPTED SOLUTIONS FROM THE ANGLO-AMERICAN LEGAL SCHOLARSHIPS
Sažetak
The law governing credit transactions in India is compartmentalized and concomitantly poses difficulties to contractual parties and access to credit: the overall effect of this is already being felt owing to the country’s low rank on the ‘getting credit’ indicator of the World Bank’s Ease of Doing Business Report 2020. The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code 2016 (Code), being almost a mirror-image of the English Insolvency Act 1986, has some inherent defects that are incompatible with the local conditions vis-à-vis access to credit and business rescue. Some of these defects arguably emanate from the Code’s unfair categorization of creditors into the ‘operational’ and ‘financial’ types, and the ensuing confusion as was witnessed in the Supreme Court’s Home Buyers’ case in 2019. Strangely, financial creditors enjoy some Code-given preferential treatments over operational creditors including the right to constitute committees of creditors in voting and confirming business rescue plans. The insolvency resolution process of the Code is incompatible with the fact that over 90% of the companies doing business in India are SMEs and family-owned. The crushing financial weight of insolvency resolution processes is foreseen to gradually cannibalize these SMEs and cause a sharp rise in the unemployment rate. The article diagnoses a number of defects in the credit and insolvency systems of India, and proposes transplantable solutions from the English system, the U.S. Chapter 11, and Article 9 of the Uniform Commercial Code.
Reference
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Ali, P., 2002, The Law of Secured Finance, Oxford, Oxford University Press.
Armour, J., Deakin, S., 2001, Norms in Private Insolvency: The “London Approach” to the Resolution of Financial Distress, Journal of Corporate Law Studies,Vol. 1, part 1.
Baird, D.G., 1983, Notice Filing and the Problem of Ostensible Ownership, Journal of Legal Studies, Vol. 12, no. 1.
Black’s Law Dictionary, 8th ed. 2004.
Buchheit, L., Pam, J., 2004, The Pari Passu Clause in Sovereign Debt Instruments, Emory Law Journal, Vol. 53.
Burkart, M., Ellingsen, T., 2004, In-kind Finance: A Theory of Trade Credit, The American Economic Review, Vol. 94.
Chiu-Iris, H-Y., 2006, The Legal Fabrication of Security Interests in the United Kingdom, North Carolina Journal of International Law and Commercial Regulation, Vol. 31, No. 3.
Clarke, A., 1997, Security Interests as Property: Relocating Security Interests within the Property Framework, in: Harris, J.W., (ed.), Property Problems from Genes to Pension Funds, London, Kluwer.
Cork, K., 1988, Cork on Cork: Sir Kenneth Cork Takes Stock, London, Macmillan.
Danielson, M. G., Scott, J.A., 2004, Bank Loan Availability and Trade Credit Demand, The Financial Review, Vol. 39.
Finch, V., 1994, Personal Accountability and Corporate Control: The Role of Directors’ and Officers’ Liability Insurance, Modern Law Review, Vol. 57.
Finch, V., 1997, The Measures of Insolvency Law, Oxford Journal of Legal Studies, Vol. 17, No. 2.
Finch, V., 2009, Corporate Insolvency Law – Perspectives and Principles, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
Flood, J., 2001, The Vultures Fly East: The Creation and Globalisation of the Distressed Debt Market, in: Nelken, D., Feest, J., (eds.) Adapting Legal Cultures, Oxford, Hart Publishing.
Gallagher, A., 2010, The Growth of Schemes of Arrangement as the Tool of Choice in Complex Restructurings, American Bankruptcy Institute Journal, Vol. 29, October issue.
Gikay, A., 2017, Rethinking Ethiopian Secured Transactions Law through Comparative Perspective: Lessons from the Uniform Commercial Code of the US, Mizan Law Review, Vol. 11, No. 1.
Gilmore, G., 1965, Security Interests in Personal Property, Boston, Little, Brown, Vol. 1.
Goode, R., 1988, Legal Problems of Credit and Security, London, Sweet & Maxwell.
Goodhart, W., 1986, Clough Mill Ltd v. Martin – a Comeback for Romalpa? Modern Law Review, Vol. 49.
Goodhart, W., Gareth, J., 1980, The Infiltration of Equitable Doctrine into English Commercial Law, Modern Law Review, Vol. 43.
Gudgeon, M.R., Joshi, S.A., The Restructuring and Workout Environment in Europe, in: Larkin, B., (ed.) 2013, Restructuring and Workout Strategies for Maximizing Value, 2nd ed. Globe, Law and Business.
Gullifer, L., 2008, The Reforms of the Enterprise Act 2002 and the Floating Charge as a Security Device, Canadian Business Law Journal, Vol. 46.
Gupta, S.K., 2014, Corporate Rescue in India: Trends and Prospects, International Company and Commercial Law Review, Vol. 11, Issue 3.
Harris, S.L., Mooney Jr. C.W., 1993, The Article 9 Study Committee Report: Strong Signals and Hard Choices, Idaho Law Review, Vol. 29.
Iheme, W.C., 2016, Towards Reforming the Legal Framework for Secured Transactions in Nigeria, Springer.
Iheme, W.C., Mba, S.U., 2017, Towards Reforming Nigeria’s Secured Transactions Law: The Central Bank of Nigeria’s Attempt through the Back Door, Journal of African Law, Vol. 61.
Keay, A., 2007, Company Directors’ Responsibilities to Creditors, London, Routledge-Cavendish.
Kraakman, R.H., 1984, Corporate Liability Strategies and the Cost of Legal Controls, Yale Law Journal, Vol. 93.
Li, K., Wang, W., 2016, Debtor-in-Possession Financing, Loan To-Loan, and Loan To Own, Journal of Corporate Finance, Vol. 39, Issue C. Part I and Schedule A1 of the Section 32, Registration Act, 1908.
Lipson, J.C., 2005, Secrets and Liens: The End of Notice in Commercial Finance Law, Emory Bankruptcy Development Law Journal, Vol. 21.
LoPucki, L.M., 1997, The Systems Approach to Law, Cornell Law Review, Vol. 82.
LoPucki, L.M., Abraham, A.I., Delahaye, B.P., 2013, Optimizing English and American Security Interests, Notre Dame Law Review, Vol. 88.
Macleod, H., 1876, Principles of Economical Philosophy, Longmans, Green, Reader & Dyer.
Mba, S., 2019, New Financing for Distressed Businesses in the Context of Business Restructuring Law, Springer.
McCormack, G., 1994, Priority of Charges and Registration, Journal of Business Law.
McCormack, G., 1995, Reservation of Title, 2nd ed., London, Sweet & Maxwell.
McCormack, G., 2002, The Nature of Security over Receivables, Company Lawyer, Vol. 23.
McCormack, G., 2003, The Floating Charge and the Law Commission Consultation Paper on Registration of Security Interests, Insolvency Lawyer, Vol. 3.
McCormack, G., 2011, American Private Law Writ Large? The UNCITAL Secured Transactions Guide, The International and Comparative Law Quarterly, Vol. 60, No. 3.
McCormack, G., Registration of Company Charges, 2009, 3rd ed., Jordans Publishing Limited.
Milman, D., 2002, The Administration Order Procedure, Company Law Newsletter, Vol. 17..
Mulligan, M., Tribe, J., 2003, The Remuneration of Office Holders in Corporate Insolvency – Liquidators, Administrators and Administrative Receivers: Part 1’ Insolvency Lawyer, Vol. 3.
Oditah, F., 2001, Fixed Charges over Book Debts after Brumark, Insolvency Intelligence, Vol. 14.
Oditah, F., 2004, Fixed Charges and Recycling of Proceeds of Receivables, Law Quarterly Review, Vol. 120.
Olivares-Caminal, R., 2009, To Rank Pari Passu or Not to Rank: That Is the Question in Sovereign Bonds after the Latest Episode of the Argentine Saga, Law & Business Review of the Americas, Vol. 15, No. 4.
Payne, J., 2014, Debt Restructuring in English Law: Lessons from the US and the Need for Reform, University of Oxford legal Research Paper Series.
Payne, J., 2014, Schemes of Arrangement: Theory, Structure and Operation, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
Pennington, R.R., 1960, The Genesis of the Floating Charge, The Modern Law Review, Vol. 23, No. 6.
Pierre, B., 1997, Classification of Property and Conceptions of Ownership in Civil and Common Law, Revue Générale de Droit, Vol. 28, No. 2.
Pilkington, C., 2013, Schemes of Arrangement in Corporate Restructuring, London, Sweet & Maxwell.
Spanogle, J.A., 2010, Secured Transactions Law in Eastern Europe: the Polish Experience as an Example, Thomas Jefferson Law Review, Vol. 31.
Sykes, E., Walker, S., 1993, The Law of Securities, Law Book Company.
Tajti, T., 2002, Comparative Secured Transactions Law, Budapest, Akadèmiai Kiadó.
Tajti, T., 2013, Testing The Equivalence of the New Comprehensive Australian Personal Properties Securities Act, Its Segmented European Equivalents and the Draft Common Frame of Reference, Bond Law Review, Vol. 24, Issue 1.
Varottil, U., 2017, The Scheme of Arrangement as a Debt Restructuring Tool in India: Problems and Prospects, European Company and Financial Law Review,Vol. 15, Issue 3.
Verrill, L., 2004, The R3 Regulation Survey, Recovery, Autumn issue.
Warren, E., Westbrook, J.L., 2009, The Success of Chapter 11: A Challenge to the Critics, Michigan Law Review, Vol. 107, Issue 4.
Weir, T., 1996, Taking for Granted: The Ramifications of Nemo Dat, Current Legal Problems, Vol. 49, No. 1.
Weston, K., 2013, Lifeblood, Liquidity, and Cash Transfusions: Beyond Metaphor in the Cultural Study of Finance, Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute, Vol. 19, No. 1.
Wood, P., 2003, Passu Clauses-What Do They Mean?, Butterworths Journal of International Banking & Financial Law, Vol. 18, No. 10.
Worthington, S., 1996, Proprietary Interests in Commercial Transactions, Oxford, Clarendon Press.
Ziegel, J.S., The Privately Appointed Receiver and the Enforcement of Security Interests: Anomaly or Superior Solution?, in: Ziegel, J.S., (ed.) 1994, Current Developments in International and Comparative Corporate Insolvency Law, Oxford, Clarendon Press.
Zwieten, K., 2015, Corporate Rescue in India: The Influence of the Courts, Journal of Corporate Law Studies, Vol. 15, Issue 1.
Zwieten, K., 2018, Director Liability in Insolvency and Its Vicinity, Oxford Journal of Legal Studies, Vol. 38, No. 2.
LEGISLATIVE SOURCES
Companies Act 2013, India.
Hire Purchase Act 1972, India.
Indian Contract Act, 1872.
Insolvency Act 1986, UK.
Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016, India.
Registration Act, 1908, India.
SARFAESI Act 2002, India.
The Report of the Review Committee on Insolvency Law and Practice (Cmnd 8558, 1982), UK.
Transfer of Property Act 1882, India.
Uniform Commercial Code, United States.
White Paper Insolvency: A Second Chance (Cmnd 5234, July 2001), UK.
CASE LAW
Agnew v. Commissioner of Inland Revenue [2001] 2 AC 710.
Benedict v. Ratner (1925) 268 US 354.
Browne-Wilkinson V-C in Re Paramount Airways Ltd 2 [1990] BCC 130.
Chow Yoong Hong v. Choong Fah Rubber Manufactory [1962] AC 209.
Edwards v. Flightline Ltd [2003] 1 WLR at 1200.
Illington v Houldsworth [1904] AC 355.
In Re BCCI (No. 8) [1998] AC 214.
Madura Coats Limited v. Modi Rubber Ltd (2016) Comp. Cas. 261 (SC).
Mirror Group Newspapers plc v. Maxwell [1998] BCC 324.
Pioneer Urban Land and Infrastructure Limited v. Union of India (2019), Writ Petition (Civil) No. 43/2019.
Re Brightlife Ltd [1987] Ch 200.
Re Coslett (Contractors) Ltd [1998] Ch 495.
Re Independent Insurance Co Ltd (No 2) [2003] EWHC 51 (Ch).
Re Independent Insurance Co Ltd [2002] 2 BCLC 709.
Re Spectrum Plus Ltd [2005] UKHL 41.
Re T& N Ltd and Others [2006] 3 All ER 697.
Re Yorkshire Woolcombers Association Ltd [1903] 2 Ch.
Salomon v. A. Salomon & Co. Ltd [1897] AC 22.
Siebe Gorman v. Barclays Bank [1979] 2 Lloyd’s Rep. 142.
Smith v. Bridgend County Borough Council [2002] 1 AC 336.
Solomons and Defty v. Cheal, Huggins and Coster [2011] EWHC 2543 (Ch).
Tata Motors Ltd. v. Pharmaceutical Products of India Ltd (2008) 114 Comp. Cas. 178 (SC).
Twyne’s Case [1601] 76 ER 809.
Zartman v. First National Bank (1907) 189 NY 267.
INTERNET SOURCES
Das, S., 2018, IBBI Looks to Rationalize Fees Structure, The Economic Times, (https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/markets/stocks/news/ibbi-looks-to-rationalise-fees-structure/articleshow/63584369.cms?from=mdr, 10. 7. 2020).
Dutt, I., 2019, IBC Resolutions Exceed New Time Limit of 330 Days Prescribed by Government, Business Standard, (https://www.business-standard.com/article/companies/ibc-resolutions-exceed-new-time-limit-of-330-days-prescribed-by-govt-119102800661_1.html, 12. 8. 2020).
Ministry of Finance, Government of India, Interim Report of the Bankruptcy Law Reform Committee, 2015, p. 77, (http://finmin.nic.in/reports/Interim_Report_BLRC.pdf, 12. 9. 2020).
Munerry, J., 2020, The Difference Between Secured and Unsecured Creditors, Begbies Traynor (https://www.begbies-traynorgroup.com/articles/director-advice/the-difference-between-secured-and-unsecured-creditors).
Press Trust of India, 2018, India has third highest number of family-owned businesses in the world, Business Standard. Available (https://www.business-standard.com/article/current-affairs/india-has-third-highest-number-of-family-owned-businesses-in-the-world-118091400409_1.html, 14. 9. 2020).
Review of the Corporate Insolvency Framework: A Consultation on Options for Reform, 2016, The Insolvency Service (https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/525523/A_Review_of_the_Corporate_Insolvency_Framework.pdf).
Sengupta, R., Sharma, A., and Thomas, S., 2016, Evolution of the Insolvency Framework For Non-Financial Firms in India (http://www.igidr.ac.in/pdf/publication/WP-2016-018.pdf, 10. 9. 2020).
SME Sector in India: Statistics, Trends and Reports. (https://evoma.com/business-centre/sme-sector-in-india-statistics-trends-reports/#:~:text=Number%20of%20SMEs%20in%20India,%2C%2040%25%20of%20India's%20workforce. 12. 9. 2020).
The Central Registry of Securitisation Asset Reconstruction and Security Interest of India (https://www.cersai.org.in/).
The World Bank Data, 2019, (https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.POP.TOTL?locations=IN, 12. 9. 2020).
US Courts, Chapter 11 – Bankruptcy Basics, (https://www.uscourts.gov/services-forms/bankruptcy/bankruptcy-basics/chapter-11-bankruptcy-basics, 12.0 6. 2020).
Vivek, K., 2020, A Few Hits & Some Misses, That’s The IBC Track Record, Mint, (https://www.livemint.com/news/india/a-few-hits-some-misses-that-s-the-ibc-track-record-11582474699506.html, 10.0 8. 2020).
World Bank Ease of Doing Business Report, 2020 (https://www.doingbusiness.org/en/rankings).