PARLIAMENTARY REPRESENTATION OF NATIONAL MINORITIES IN SERBIA AND HUNGARY: MECHANISM FOR EFFECTIVE PARTICIPATION OF MINORITIES, OR TOOL FOR POLITICAL MANIPULATION?
Sažetak
In multiethnic states, in which numerically large national, ethnic or linguistic minorities exist with a strong distinct identity, the principle of democracy requires that these groups have representatives in parliaments. However, in many multiethnic states the national-ethnic majority makes efforts to exclude or minimize the representation of minority national-ethnic groups in legislative bodies. Serbia and Hungary are nation states with relatively high percentage of citizens belonging to national-ethnic minorities, and with developed systems of the protection of minority rights. Both states enacted electoral laws facilitating the representation of national minorities in highest elected state bodies. This article describes, critically analyzes and compares the electoral rules and their practical implementation in both states, in order to answer the question whether these rules make it efficiently possible for national minorities to acquire proper representation in parliament. In order to answer this question, the results and experiences of the latest parliamentary elections – organized in 2022 in both states – will be elaborated as well.
Reference
BIBLIOGRAPHY
1. Burazer, N., 2016, Reforma sistema reprezentacije nacionalnih manjina u Narodnoj skupštini Republike Srbije [The reform of national minority representation in the national assembly of the Republic of Serbia], Belgrade, Konrad Adenauer Stiftung.
2. Canon, T. D., 1999, Electoral Systems and the Representation of Minority Interests in Legislatures, Legislative Studies Quarterly, Vol. 24, No. 3.
3. Dobos, B., 2021, A nemzetiségi részvétel jellemzői az országgyűlési választáson (2014–2019) [The characteristics of the participation of national minorities in parliamentary elections (2014-2019)], Parlamenti Szemle, Vol. 6, No. 2.
4. Horváth, L., 2020, A parlamenti választási rendszerek nemzeti kisebbségi vonatkozásai a Nyugat-Balkánon – harminc éve a demokrácia árnyékában? [The parliamentary electoral systems in the Western Balkans and national minorities – Thirty years in the shadow of democracy], Kisebbségi Szemle, Vol. 2020, No. 2
5. Korhecz, T., Ustavno načelo podele vlasti – zakonodavna vlast, izvršna vlast i položaj političkih stranaka u Republici Srbiji [The constitutional principle of separation of powers – legislative power, executive power and position of political parties in the Republic of Serbia], in: Simović, D., Šarčević, E., (eds.), 2018, Parlamentarizam u Srbiji, Sarajevo, CJP Fondacija za javno pravo.
6. Korhecz, T., 2019, Evolving Legal Framework and History of National Minority Councils in Serbia, International Journal of Public Law and Policy, Vol. 6, No. 2.
7. Korhecz, T., Constitutional Rights without Protected Substance: Critical Analysis of the Jurisprudence of the Constitutional Courts of Serbia in Protecting Rights of National Minorities, in: Tribl, N., (ed.), 2021, Minority and Identity in Constitutional Justice: Case Studies from Central and East Europe, Szeged, International and Regional Studies Institute.
8. Korhecz, T., National Minorities – Constitutional Status, Rights and Protection, in: Csink, L., Trócsányi, L., (eds.), 2022, Comparative Constitutionalism in Central Europe, Miskolc, CEA Publishing.
9. Kukorelli, I., 2018, A nemzetiségek jogállása a rendszerváltozás éveiben – kísérletek országgyűlési képviseletük szabályozására [The legal standing of nationalities in years of transition – attempts to regulate their parliamentary representation], Parlamenti Szemle, Vol. 3, No. 1.
10. Kurunczi, G., Electoral Systems, in: Csink, L., Trócsányi, L., (eds.), 2022, Comparative Constitutionalism in Central Europe, Miskolc, CEA Publishing.
11. Liphart, A., 1977, Democracy in Plural Societies, New Haven, Yale University Press.
12. Lijphart, A., 2004, Constitutional Design for Divided Societies, Journal of Democracy, Vol. 15, No. 2.
13. Móré, S., 2015, A nemzetiségek országgyűlési képviseletének egyes kérdései Magyarországon [Some questions about the representation of nationalities in the national assembly], Magyar Jog, Vol. 62, No. 10.
14. Moser G. R., 2008, Electoral Systems and the Representation of Ethnic Minorities: Evidence from Russia, Comparative Politics, Vol. 40, No. 3.
15. Nagy, N., 2022, Szemérmes alkotmánybíráskodás A nemzetiségek védelme az Alkotmánybíróság gyakorlatában [Shameful constitutional adjudication, the protection of nationalities in the practice of the Constitutional Court], Budapest, NKI (forthcoming).
16. Nohlen, D., Választási rendszerek és választási reform: Bevezetés [Electoral systems and electoral reform: introduction], in: 1996, Választási rendszer, választójog és választás Kelet-Közép Európában, Budapest, MTA JTI.
17. Pajvančić, M., 2007, Izborni sistem i pravo nacionalnih manjina na reprezentovanje [The electoral system and the representation of national minorities],
Glasnik advokatske komore Vojvodine, Vol. 80, No. 3–4.
18. Pajvančić, M., 2008, Izborno pravo, Novi Sad, Pravni fakultet Univerziteta u Novom Sadu.
19. Pap, A., Recognition, Representation and Reproach: New Institutional Arrangements in the Hungarian Multiculturalist Model, in: Vizi, B., Tóth, N., Dobos, E., (eds.), 2017, Beyond International Conditionality. Local Variations of Minority Representation in Central and South-Eastern Europe, Baden-Baden, Nomos.
20. Sartori, G., Political Development and Political Engineering, in: Montgomery, J. D., Hirschman, A. O., Public Policy, 1968, New York, Cambridge University Press.
21. Suksi, M., Effective Participation of Minorities in Public Affairs and Public Life – European Norms and Praxis Evaluated in Light of the Lund Recommendations, in: Vizi, B., Tóth, N., Dobos, E., (eds.), 2017, Beyond International Conditionality. Local Variations of Minority Representation in Central and South-Eastern Europe, Baden-Baden, Nomos.
22. Statistical Office of the Republic of Serbia, 2012, Population, Ethnicity, Data by Municipalities and Cities – 2011 Census of Population, Households and Dwellings in the Republic of Serbia, Belgrade, Statistical Office of the Republic of Serbia.
23. Wheatley, S., 2003, Deliberative Democracy and Minorities, European Journal of International Law, Vol. 14, No. 3.
24. Zuber, C. I., Muś, J. J., 2013, Representative Claims and Expected Gains, Minority Council Elections and Intra-Ethnic Competition in Serbia, East European Politics, Vol. 29, No. 1.
LEGISLATIVE SOURCES
1. Constitution of the Republic of Serbia [Ustav Republike Srbije], Official Gazette of the RS, Nos. 98/06 and 115/21.
2. Law on the Protection of Rights and Freedoms of National Minorities [Zakon o zaštiti prava i sloboda nacionalnih manjina], Official Gazette of the FRY, No. 11/2002, Official Gazette of the RS, Nos. 72/09 and 47/18
3. Law on Political Parties [Zakon o političkim strankama], Official Gazette of the RS, Nos. 36/09 and 61/15.
4. Law on the Election of National Deputies [Zakon o izboru narodnih poslanika], Official Gazette of the RS, No. 14/22.
5. Act No. 20. from 1949 on the Constitution of the Republic of Hungary [1949. évi XX. törvény a Magyar Köztársaság Alkotmánya]
6. Fundamental Law of Hungary [Magyarország Alaptörvénye], enacted on 25 April 2011.
7. Act No. 77 from 1993 on the Rights of National and Ethnic Minorities [1993 évi LXXVII. törvény a nemzeti és etnikai kisebbségek védelméről], Article 20, para 1.
8. Act No. 203 from 2011 on the Election of Parliamentary Deputies] [2011 évi CCIII. törvény az országgyűlési képviselők választásáról].
9. Act No. 179 from 2011 on the Rights of Nationalities [2011 évi CLXXIX. Törvény a Nemzetiségek jogairól]
10. Act No. 36 on the National Assembly [2012 évi XXXVI. törvény az Országgyűlésről].
11. Act No. 36 from 2013 on the Electoral Process [2013 évi XXXVI. törvény a választási eljárásról].
CASE LAW
1. Permanent Court of International Justice, Minority Schools in Albania, Advisory Opinion, 1935, Series A/B, No. 64.
2. US Supreme Court, Shelby County v. Holder, 570 U. S. 529 (2013).
3. Constitutional Court of Serbia, Order IU 110/2004 of 15 July 2004.
4. Constitutional Court of Serbia, Order IU 334/2004 of 2 December 2004.
5. Constitutional Court of Serbia, Order IU-97/2008 of 18 December 2008.
6. Constitutional Court of Serbia, Decision IUz-52/2008 of 21 April 2010.
7. Constitutional Court of Serbia, Decision IUp-42/2008, of 14 April 2011.
8. Administrative Court of Serbia, Decision Už 138/16 of 13 April 2016.
9. Administrative Court of Serbia, Decision Už 111/16 of 12 April 2016.
10. Administrative Court of Serbia, Decision Už 107/20 of 19 June 2020.
11. Administrative Court of Serbia, Decision Už 29/22 of 20 March 2022.
12. Administrative Court of Serbia, Decision Už 31/22 of 21 March 2022.
13. Constitutional Court of Hungary, Decision No. 1040/B/1999 of 17 December 2001.
14. Constitutional Court of Hungary Desicion No. 3002/2022 of 13 January 2022.
INTERNET SOURCES
1. Ministarstvo državne uprave i lokalne samouprave, Izvod iz registra političkih stranaka [Ministry of State Administration and Local Self-Government, Excerpt from the register of political parties], (http://mduls.gov.rs/wp-content/uploads/Izvod-iz-Registra-politickih-stranaka-22.07.2022.pdf, 11. 11. 2022).
2. Report on the Complete Results of the Election for Peoples Deputies in the National Assembly [Izveštaj o ukupnim rezultatima izbora za narodne poslanike Narodne skupštine], RIK, 5 July 2020. (https://www.rik.parlament.gov.rs/extfile/sr/9392/Izvestaj%20o%20ukupnim%20rezultatima%20izbora%202020l.doc, 11. 11. 2022).