ANONYMOUS BIRTH VERSUS CHILD’S RIGHT TO IDENTITY
Abstract
The right to identity of the child, internationally recognized by the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child, is one of the most important in the corpus of child rights. Its structure is complex since it includes several narrower rights. Nevertheless, the situations where it comes to restriction of the right to identity are not negligible. One of them is the right to anonymous birth, the possibility acknowledged by legislators in a certain number of European countries. Conflicting interests between a mother and a child are inevitable consequence of the anonymous birth.
The aim of this article is to compare the right to identity of a child and the mother’s right to anonymous birth as insurmountable barrier in determining biological origin. Special attention is paid to the possibility of establishing an adequate balance between their interests, by comparing the importance that national legal system offers to each of them, with appropriate arguments, several different models of motherhood regulations are presented and can be found in European legislations. The analysis also includes the stances of international bodies, especially the European Court of Human Rights.
References
Blauwhoff, R., 2008, Tracing down the historical development of the legal concept of the right to know one’s origins: Has ‘to know or not to know’ ever been the legal question?, Utrecht Law Review, Igitur, Vol. 4, No. 2.
Colcelli, V., 2012, Anonymous Birth, Birth Registration and the Child’s Right to Know Their Origins in the Italian Legal System: A Short Comment, Civil & Legal Sciences, 1, No. 2.
Dally, A., 1982, Inventing Motherhood: The Consequences of and Ideal, London, Burnett Books.
D’alton-Harrison, R., 2014, Mater semper incertus est: Who’s Your Mummy?, Medical Law Review, Vol. 22, No. 3.
Draškić, M., 2007, Porodično pravo i prava deteta, Beograd, Pravni fakultet Univerziteta u Beogradu.
Draškić, M., 2016, Komentar Porodičnog zakona, Praksa Evropskog suda za ljudska prava, praksa Ustavnog suda, praksa redovnih sudova prema stanju zakonodavstva od decembra 2015. godine, Beograd, Službeni glasnik.
Freeman, M., Margaria, A., 2012, Who and What Is a Mother? Maternity, Responsibility and Liberty, Theoretical Inquiries in Law, Vol. 13, No. 153.
Grylli, C., Brockington, I., Fiala, C., Huscsava, M., Waldhoer, T., Klier, C., 2015, Anonymous birth law saves babies - optimization, sustainability and public awareness, Archives of Women’s Mental Health, Vol. 19, No. 2.
Hadžimanović, N., 2018, Confidental and Anonymous Birth in National Laws – Useful and Compatible with the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child?, Comparazione e Diritto Civile.
Hlača, N., 2007, Pravo majke na anonimnost poroda – „L’accouchement sous X – porod pod X“, Gynaecol Perinatol, Vol. 16, No. 3.
Jumakova, A., 2020, Content of the child’s right to identity within the scope of the Convention on the rights of the child and the Latvian national framework, Miscellanea Historico-Iuridica, Vol. 19, No. 1.
Kovaček-Stanić, G., 2011, Autonomija versus materijalna istina u komparativnom pravu o porodičnom statusu deteta, Zbornik radova Pravnog fakulteta u Novom Sadu, 3.
Lafaucheur, N., 2004, The French ‘Tradition’ of Anonymous Birth: The Lines of Argument, International Journal of Law, Policy and the Family, Oxford University Press, Vol. 18, No. 3.
Mallet-Bricout, B., 2002, Reforme de l’accouchement sous X: quel equilibre entre les droits de l`enfant et les droits de la mere biologique?, La Semaine Juridique Edition Generale, Vol. 11, No. 9.
Margaria, A., 2014, Anonymous Birth: Expanding the Terms of Debate, Journal of Children’s Rights, Vol. 22, No. 3.
Marshall, J., 2018, Secrecy in births, identity rights, care and belonging, Child and Family Law Quarterly, Vol. 30, No. 2.
Milovanović, S., 2019, Nemogućnost utvrđivanja porekla deteta kod anonimnog porođaja, master rad, Pravni fakultet Univerziteta u Beogradu.
Pastore, A., 2019, El parto anonimo o secreto y el parto confidencial o discreto como sistemas legales estrategicos alternatives al aborto, Academia Nacional de Ciencias Morales y Politicas.
Ponjavić, Z., Palačković, D., 2017, Pravo na anonimni porođaj, Stanovništvo, Vol. 55, No. 1.
Ponjavić, Z., Vlašković, V., 2019, Porodično pravo, Beograd, Službeni glasnik.
Simmonds, C., 2013, An Unbalanced Scale: Anonymous Birth and the European Court of Human Rights, The Cambridge Law Journal, Vol. 72, No. 2.
Tobin, J., 2019, The UN Convention on the Rights of the Child: A Commentary, Oxford University Press.
Troiano, S., 2013, Understanding and Redefining the Rationale of State Policies Allowing Anonymous Birth: A Difficult Balance between Conflicting Interests, International Journal of the Jurisprudence of the Family, Vol. 4.
Vlašković, V., 2014, Načelo najboljeg interesa deteta u porodičnom pravu, doktorska disertacija, Pravni fakultet Univerziteta u Kragujevcu.
PROPISI
Evropska konvencija o ljudskim pravima – European Convention on Human Rights of 04 November 1950.
Konvencije UN o pravima deteta – Convetion on the Rights of the Child 44/25 of 20 November 1989.
Committee on the rights of the child, Consideration of reports submitted by states partis under article 44 of the convention, France, UN doc. CRC/C/15/Add. 20, (25 April 1994).
Porodični zakon Srbije, glasnik RS, br. 18/05, 72/11 i 6/15.
Zakona o ratifikaciji Konvencije Ujedinjenih Nacija o pravima deteta, list SFRJ – Međunarodni ugovori, br. 15/90 i Sl. list SRJ – Međunarodni ugovori, br. 4/96 i 2/97.
Zakon o matičnim knjigama, Sl. glasnik RS, br. 20/09, 145/14 i 47/18.
SUDSKA PRAKSA
EctHR, Gaskin v. U.K., no. 10454/83, Judgement of 7 July 1989.
EctHR, Bensaid v.K., no. 44599/98, Judgement of 6 February 2001.
EctHR, Odièvre v. France, no. 42326/98, Judgement of 13 February 2003 [GC].
EctHR, Jaggi v. Switzerland, no. 58757/00, Judgement of 13 July
EctHR, Godelli v. Italy, 33783/09, Judgement of 25 September 2012.
IZVORI SA INTERNETA
Bartsch, M., Schröder, C., Windmann, A., 2012, Abandoning Newborns: Do Baby Hatches Really Save Lives? (https://www.spiegel.de/international/germany/controversy-over-baby-hatches-in-germany-a-844134.html, 13.09.2021).
Godechot, J., 2021, Napoleon I: Biography, Achievements & Facts, (https://www.britannica.com/biography/Napoleon-I,09.2021).
Overmyer, M., 2019, The Bell That Saved Abandoned Babies in the Middle Ages, (https://religionunplugged.com/, 09.2021).
Rajneesh Osho on motherhood, (https://www.wisesayings.com/authors/rajneesh-quotes/, 12.09.2021).