REFORMS WITHOUT REFORMING: TRENDS IN LOCAL AND REGIONAL GOVERNANCE AND DECENTRALIZATION IN CROATIA
Sažetak
The paper presents, analyzes, and discusses changes in the Croatian local self-government system and assesses their drivers, whether these changes can be con- sidered real reforms, and why certain changes occur and others do not. The paper covers a 30-year time span of local self-government development – from the early 1990s, when Croatia introduced a modern local self-government, through the 2000s when Croatia transitioned to the system based on political decentralization, to recent reform activities. The paper shows that there have been several “real” reforms that have raised and addressed very important issues, while other “reforms” can mostly be described as partial changes that occur when there is significant political will for them or under strong external pressure. Political actors and their role of veto players, together with path dependency, remain crucial explanatory factors of local self-government development in the past three decades in Croatia.
Reference
Bibliography
Babić, Z., 2018, Decentralizacija socijalne skrbi i socijalne nejednakosti: slučaj Hrvatske (Decentralization of social care system and social inequalities: the case of Croatia), Revija za socijalnu politiku, Vol. 25, No. 1, pp. 25–48.
Blažević, R., Dobrić Jambrović, D., Menger, M., 2021, Lokalna samouprava (Local self-government), Rijeka, Pravni fakultet.
Buljan, A., Deskar-Škrbić, M., Švaljek, S., 2021, In Search of an Optimal Size for Local Government: An Assessment of Economies of Scale in Local Government in Croatia, Croatian National Bank Working Papers, No. W-62.
Dadasović, B., Načelo samostalnosti lokalnih jedinica pri određivanju vlastitog unutarnjeg ustrojstva (The principle of autonomy of local units in determining their own internal organization), in: Koprić, I., (ed.), 2018, Europeizacija hrvatske lokalne samouprave (Europeanization of Croatian local self-government), Zagreb, Institut za javnu upravu, pp. 521–548.
Đulabić, V., Regionalni razvoj i županije u Hrvatskoj (Regional development and counties in Croatia), in: Barbić, J., (ed.), 2015, Nova upravno-teritorijalna organ- izacija Hrvatske, Zagreb, Hrvatska akademija znanosti i umjetnosti, pp. 139–159.
Đulabić, V., Lokalna i regionalna samouprava i korištenje sredstava iz fondova Eu- ropske unije (Local and regional self-government and use of funds from European Union funds), in: Boban, M., Vukušić, I., (eds.), 2017, Zbornik radova Pametna lo- kalna samouprava, Novalja, Split, Zagreb, Udruga gradova i Grad Novalja.
Đulabić, V., 2018a, Lokalna samouprava i decentralizacija u Hrvatskoj (Lo- cal self-government and decentralization in Croatia), Zagreb, Friedrich Ebert Stiftung.
Đulabić, V., Harmonizacija regionalne samouprave u Europi i regionalno pitanje u Hrvatskoj (Harmonization of regional self-government in Europe and regional question in Croatia), in: Koprić, I., (ed.), 2018b, Europeizacija hrvatske lokalne samouprave (Europeanization of Croatian local self-government), Zagreb, Institut za javnu upravu, pp. 447–470.
Đulabić, V., Lokalna samouprava i lokalna demokracija u Hrvatskoj: koliko pros- tora za demokratske inovacije? (Local self-government and local democracy in Croatia: how much space for democratic innovations?), in: Čepo, D., (ed.), 2020, European values and the challenges of EU membership, Zagreb, Centar za demokraciju i pravo Miko Tripalo, pp. 143–170.
Đulabić, V., Teritorijalna samouprava i politika regionalnog razvoja u Hrvatskoj: Nužna kohabitacija ili poželjna sinergija? (Territorial self-government and re- gional development policy in Croatia: Necessary cohabitation or desirable syn- ergy), in: Jurlina Alibegović, D., Markić Boban, A., Fiesinger, K., (eds.), 2022, Prilika ili prijetnja? Reforma lokalne i regionalne samouprave u Hrvatskoj, Zagreb, Hanns-Seidel-Stiftung & Ekonomski institut, pp. 43–63.
Đulabić, V., 2021, Mogu li se nove izmjene propisa o lokalnoj i područnoj (re- gionalnoj) samoupravi smatrati reformom? (Can the new changes of the regula- tion on local and regional self-government be considered a reform?), Informator, No. 6662, pp. 1–5.
Đulabić, V., 2024, “Silent capture”: Undemocratic tendencies in Croatia, Zagreb, Friedrich Ebert Stiftung.
Đulabić, V., (ed.), 2024a, Regionalism and Regional Self-Government in South-East Europe, Cham, Springer.
Đulabić, V., Škarica, M., Lopižić, I., 2023, Analysis of centralization as a response to polycrises: evidence from local self-government in Croatia, paper presented at scientific conference “Steering European Union through Poly-Crises Storms: The Role of Public Administration”.
Džinić, J., Lopižić, I., Manojlović Toman, R., Reorganizacija sustava socijalne skrbi: priprema, provedba i perspektive (Reorganization of the Social Care Sys- tem: Preparation, Implementation and Perspectives), in: Barbić, J., (ed.), 2025, Priprema i provedba reformi u javnoj upravi i pravosuđu Republike Hrvatske (Preparation and implementation of reforms in the public administration and judiciary of the Republic of Croatia), Zagreb, Hrvatska akademija znanosti i um- jetnosti, pp. 65–87.
Halligan, J., Public Management Reform, in: Schedler, K., (ed.), 2022, Elgar Encyclo- pedia of Public Management, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing, pp. 283–287.
Jambrač, J., 2015, Funkcionalna decentralizacija u Hrvatskoj: petnaest godina poslije (Functional decentralization in Croatia: fifteen years later), Hrvatska i komparativna javna uprava, Vol. 17, No. 2, pp. 189–216.
Jurlina Alibegović, D., 2023, Interes općina i gradova za dobrovoljno spajanje (In- terest of municipalities and cities in voluntary merger), Informator, Nos. 6786– 6787, pp. 1–4.
Koprić, I., 2000, Proširenje lokalnog samoupravnog djelokruga i sužavanje nad- zora središnjih državnih organa (Expansion of the scope of competence of local self-government and narrowing of the supervision of central state authorities), Hrvatska javna uprava, Vol. 2, No. 3, pp. 391–437.
Koprić, I., 2001, Uloga županija u hrvatskom sustavu lokalne samouprave i up- rave 1990-ih i perspektive regionalizacije nakon promjena Ustava iz 2000. godine (The role of counties in the Croatian system of local self-government and admin- istration in the 1990s and the perspective of regionalization after the changes to the 2000 Constitution), Hrvatska javna uprava, Vol. 3, No. 1, pp. 63–87.
Koprić, I., Local Government Development in Croatia. Problems and Value Mix, in: Baldersheim, H., Illner, M., Wollmann, H., (eds.), 2003, Local Democracy in Post-Communist Europe, Wiesbaden, Springer Fachmedien, pp. 181–210.
Koprić, I., 2005, O neposrednom izboru gradonačelnika i općinskih načelnika (On the direct election of mayors), Informator, Vol. 53, No. 5399, p. 9.
Koprić, I., 2010, Prijedlozi za reformu lokalne i regionalne samouprave u Hrvat- skoj (Proposals for the reform of local and regional self-government in Croatia), Hrvatska javna uprava, Vol. 10, No. 4, pp. 941–959.
Koprić, I., Dvadeset godina lokalne i područne (regionalne) samouprave u Hr- vatskoj: razvoj, stanje i perspektive (Twenty years of local and regional self-gov- ernment in Croatia: development, status and perspectives), in: Đulabić, V., (ed.), 2013, Lokalna samouprava i lokalni izbori (Local self-government and local elec- tions), Zagreb, Institut za javnu upravu, pp. 6–63.
Koprić, I., 2017, Novela Zakona o lokalnoj i područnoj (regionalnoj) samoupravi iz 2017. (Amendment to the Act on Local and Regional Self-Government from 2017), Hrvatska i komparativna javna uprava, Vol. 17, No. 4 special issue, pp. 55–90.
Koprić, I., Suvremeni trendovi u razvoju lokalne samouprave i hrvatska lokalna i regionalna samouprava (Contemporary trends in the development of local self-government and Croatian local and regional self-government), in: Koprić, I., (ed.), 2018, Europeizacija hrvatske lokalne samouprave, Zagreb, Institut za javnu upravu, pp. 1–56.
Koprić, I., Crnković, M., Lopižić, I., Control of local governments in Croatia: Many components, still weak control, in: Max-Geis, E., Guérard, S., Volmerange, X., (eds.), 2018, A threat to autonomy? Control and supervision of local and re- gional government activities, Paris, Institut Universitaire Varenne, pp. 91–112.
Koprić, I., Škarica, M., Evaluacija neposrednog izbora načelnika i župana u Hr- vatskoj nakon dva mandata: korak naprijed, dva nazad (Evaluation of direct elec- tions of mayors and county prefects in Croatia after two terms: one step forward, two back), in: Gongeta, S., Smoljić, M., (eds.), 2017, Zbornik radova 7. međunar- odne konferencije Razvoj javne uprave, Vukovar, Veleučilište Lavoslav Ružička, pp. 156–172.
Koprić, I., Đulabić, V., Evaluation of the Decentralisation Programme in Croatia, in: Koprić, I., Wollmann, H., Marcou, G., (eds.), 2018, Evaluating Reforms of Lo- cal Public and Social Services in Europe, Cham, Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 243–260.
Koprić, I. et al., 2021, Upravna znanost: Javna uprava u suvremenom europskom kontekstu – 2. izmijenjeno i dopunjeno izdanje (Administrative science: public ad- ministration in the contemporary European context – 2nd revised edition), Za- greb, Pravni fakultet.
Kregar, J., Decentralizacija (Decentralization), in: Kregar, J. et al., (eds.), 2011, Decentralizacija, Zagreb, Centar za demokraciju i pravo Miko Tripalo, pp. 1–33.
Kuhlmann, S. et al., 2024, New Perspectives on Intergovernmental Relations – Cri- sis and Reform, Cham, Palgrave MacMillan.
Lindblom, C. E., 1979, Still muddling, not yet through, Public Administration Re- view, Vol. 39, No. 6, pp. 517–526.
Lopižić, I., Manojlović Toman, R., 2019, Prethodna evaluacija ukidanja ureda državne uprave u županijama (Preliminary evaluation of the abolition of state administration offices in counties), Zbornik Pravnog fakulteta u Zagrebu, Vol. 59, Nos. 5–6, pp. 835–870.
Lopižić, I., Manojlović Toman, R., 2023, Institutional and Performance Effects of Administrative Decentralization in Croatian Territorial Governance Setting, Studia Iuridica Lublinensia, Vol. 32, No. 5, pp. 195–216.
Marčetić, G., Lopižić, I., 2017, Utjecaj procesa decentralizacije na jačanje per- sonalnih kapaciteta hrvatske lokalne i područne (regionalne) samouprave (The influence of the decentralization process on personnel capacity strengthening in Croatian units of local and regional self-government), Hrvatska i komparativna javna uprava, Vol. 17, No. 3, pp. 407–435.
Peters, B. G., 2019, Institutional Theory in Political Science: The New institutional- ism, 4th edition, Cheltenham, Edward Elgar Publishing.
Škarica, M., Lokalni djelokrug u svjetlu novih funkcija i uloga lokalne samouprave (Local scope of competence in the light of new functions and roles of local self-government), in: Koprić, I., (ed.), 2013, Reforma lokalne i regionalne samouprave u Republici Hrvatskoj (Reform of local and regional self-government in the Republic of Croatia), Zagreb, Suvremena javna uprava, pp. 55–98.
Škarica, M., Funkcionalni odnos lokalne i područne (regionalne) samouprave u Hrvatskoj u svjetlu odredaba Europske povelje o lokalnoj samoupravi (The func- tional relationship between local and regional self-government in Croatia in light of the provisions of the European Charter on Local Self-Government), in: Ko- prić, I., (ed.), 2018, Europeizacija hrvatske lokalne samouprave (Europeanization of Croatian local self-government), Zagreb, Institut za javnu upravu, pp. 493–519.
Šimunović, I., 2017, Prostorne čarolije (Spatial magic), Split, Naklada Bošković.
Tsebelis, G., 2012, Veto Players: How Political Institutions Work, Princeton, Prince-
ton University Press.
Vries, M. S. de, Nemec, J., 2025, 35 Years of Public Sector Reform in Central Eu-
rope, Cham, Palgrave Macmillan.
Internet Sources
Congress of Local and Regional Authorities, 2024, Monitoring of the application of the European Charter of Local Self-Government in Croatia, co-rapporteurs: Gobnait NI MHUIMNEACAIN, Irland (L, ILDG) and Cecilia DALMAN EEK, Sweden (R, SOC/G/PD), CG(2024)46–18, 28 March, (https://search.coe.int/ cm?i=0900001680aecea2, 23. 4. 2025).
Jurlina Alibegović, D., 2025, Pružaju li sve općine zakonom zajamčene lokalne javne usluge svojim građanima? (Do all municipalities provide for the law guaran- teed local public services to their citizens?), EIZ commentary, 20 March, (https:// eizg.hr/pruzaju-li-sve-opcine-zakonom-zajamcene-lokalne-javne-usluge-svo- jim-gradjanima/7119, 26. 5. 2025).
Varošanec, S., Filipović Grčić, A. M., 2016, Javna uprava treba se vratiti pod skute županije, na to smo odmah spremni (Public administration should return to the control of counties, we are ready for that immediately), Poslovni.hr, 28 March, (https://www.poslovni.hr/poduzetnik/javna-uprava-treba-se-vratiti-pod-skute- zupanije-na-to-smo-odmah-spremni-310808, 29. 4. 2025).