Chaos is in the eye of the beholder: unravelling a quasi-criticism of the Serbian citation index
Abstract
The article is a response to criticism published by Rajko Bukvić in Ekonomski vidici in the paper ‘On quality and visibility of social and economic sciences of Serbia’, more precisely in the section entitled Scandals directed by CEON/CEES: Does chaos rule in our (economic) periodic publishing? In this section, the author directly accuses CEON/CEES for producing chaos in social sciences in Serbia by “excluding” many journals from its database called the Serbian Citation Index (SCIndeks). According to the author, CEON/CEES, after the termination of the financial support by the Serbian ministry responsible for science, blackmailed journal publishers by accepting for indexation only those willing to pay a fee for content maintenance. The author also claims that excluding three journals published by the Faculty of Organizational Sciences (FON), University of Belgrade, was illegal and scandalous. He adds to his allegations against SCIndeks several other unfounded, less important issues, supported by some serious unwarranted ethical accusations against its publisher. In this response, it is demonstrated that all accusations are fabricated and malicious. The alleged exclusion of formerly indexed journals was explained as a fully justified action of “non-inclusion” of journals unwilling to pay the necessary service fee after the forced transition of SCIndeks’s business model from a government-sponsored to the journals-sponsored (“diamond open access”, Ševkušić, Kosanović, & Šipka, 2020). Also, the suspension of the journals published by FON was a legitimate action aimed at protecting SCIndeks from a publisher who turned out to be untrustworthy, as demonstrated by the act of concealing the blatant plagiarism in the PhD thesis of the current Minister of Finance in the Serbian Government. The decision was reinforced by the discovery of a history of publishing in predatory journals by many members of the journals’ editorial boards, the Dean’s Collegium, and the Faculty Council. The author of the criticism is unmasked as lacking not only the basic knowledge on scientometrics, but also research and ethic integrity.
References
Bukvić R. (2019). Measuring the Science. Nova galaksija, 2, 20‒30. Available at https://ssrn.com/abstract=3467743 [in Serbian]
Bukvić R. (2020). On quality and visibility of social and economic sciences of Serbia. Ekonomski vidici, 25(1-2), 49–73. Available at https://bit.ly/3qUHOJ3 [in Serbian]
CEON. (2015a, July). SCIndeks changed its shape, scope, and funding model – CEON/CEES Announcement, Belgrad. Available at https://www.ceon.rs/images/pdf/saopstenje_CEON-a.pdf, 13.01.2021. [in Serbian]
CEON. (2015b, June), To the Ministry of Education, Science and Technological Development: Response to the request No. 92-06/15, Belgrade. Available at https://www.ceon.rs/images/pdf/odgovor_na_zahtev_MPNTR.pdf, 13.01.2021. [in Serbian]
CEON. (2015c, July). About the real reasons for cessation of SCIndeks funding: An informed testimonial prepared for the Association of the Institutes of Serbia, No. 114-07-02/15, Belgrade. Available at https://www.ceon.rs/images/pdf/Obavestenje_zajednici_instituta_Srbije.pdf, 13.01.2021. [in Serbian]
CEON. (2019, October). Plagiarism in the articles of the members of the Expert Commission for the evaluation of plagiarism in Siniša Mali’s PhD thesis, No. 41-10/19, Belgrade. Available at https://www.ceon.rs/images/pdf/Plagijarizam_clanova_strucne_komisije_za_ocenu_plagijarizma_u_doktoratu_Sinise_Malog.pdf, 13.01.2021. [in Serbian]
CEON. (n. d.). Journal Bibliometric Report, Help – Classification into research fields. Available at https://bic.ceon.rs/help/help.html, 13.01.2021. [in Serbian]
Jevremov, T., Pajić, D., & Šipka, P. (2007). Structure of personality psychology based on co-citation analysis of prominent authors. Psihologija, 40(2), 329–343. doi: 10.2298/PSI0702329J [In Serbian]
Kutlača Đ., Babić, D. Živković, L. & Štrbac, D. (2014). Analysis of quantitative and qualitative indicators of SEE countries scientific output. Scientometrics, 102, 247–265. doi:10.1007/s11192-014-1290-y
MPNTR (2015, April). Notice on the categorization of domestic scientific journals, Belgrade.
Ocić, Č. (2019, January, 17). Save us God of the plague and the Samaritans – racketeers. Danas. Available at https://www.danas.rs/dijalog/sacuvaj-nas-boze-kuge-i-samaricana-reketasa/, 13.01.2021. [In Serbian]
Ševkušić, M., Kosanović, B., & Šipka, P. (2020, April). Serbian Citation Index: The sustainability of a business model based on partnership between a non-profit web publisher and journal owners. In: ELPUB 2020 24rd edition of the International Conference on Electronic Publishing, Doha, Qatar, April 2020. Available at https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-02544845/document, 13.01.2021.
Šipka P. (1995). Citation analysis of Yugoslav psychological periodicals 1981-1990: The relations among indices of individual citedness. Psihologija, 28(1-2), 195–205. Available at https://scindeks.ceon.rs/article.aspx?artid=0048-57059502195S [In Serbian]
Šipka, P. (2012). Legitimacy of citations in predatory publishing: The case of proliferation of papers by Serbian authors in two Bosnian WoS‐indexed journals, CEES Occasional Paper Series, No. 2012‐12‐2. Available at http://www.ceon.rs/ops/12122, 13.01.2021.
Šipka, P. (2016). Ten years of growth of Serbian scientific production: But what about its quality? In: A. Kostić (Ed.), Nauka: stanje, strategija, perspektive, SASA, Belgrade, 33-62. Available at https://www.ceon.rs/images/pdf/deset_godina.pdf, 13.01.2021. [In Serbian]
Šipka, P. (2018). Incomplete, inaccurate and incompetent, but, in turn, expensive: Bibliometric analysis of MI SASA for 2016. CEON/CEES Occasional Paper Series, No. 2018-03-1. Available at https://www.ceon.rs/images/ops/18031.pdf, 13.01.2021. [In Serbian]
Šipka, P. (2019a, April, 3). All the colours of lies – Commentary on the response of academician Časlav Ocić “Save us God from the plague and Samaritans – racketeers. Danas. Available at https://www.danas.rs/dijalog/licni-stavovi/sve-boje-lazi/, 13.01.2021. [In Serbian]
Šipka, P. (2019b, May, 20). Journals published by the Faculty of Organizational Sciences of the University of Belgrade dropped out from SCIndeks – CEON/CEES announcement. Available at https://www.ceon.rs/images/pdf/Casopisi-FON-a.pdf, 13.01.2021. [In Serbian]
Šipka, P. (2021). Request for withdrawal of the paper of Rajko Bukvić “On the quality and visibility of social and economic sciences of Serbia” published in Ekonomski vidici, 25(1-2), 49–73. CEON, In media(res). Available at https://www.ceon.rs/images/pdf/Urednistvu_EV.pdf, 25.08.2021. [In Serbian]