LIABILITY OF THE REPUBLIC OF CROATIA FOR ANY DAMAGE SUFFERED THROUGH COMPROMISING THE REAL PROPERTY REGISTRATION AND CADASTRE JOINT INFORMATION SYSTEM

  • Davorin Pichler Pravni fakultet u Osijeku
Keywords: damage, land registry, cadastre, information system, digitization

Abstract


Until their digitation, land registries in the Republic of Croatia had been kept manually (paper-based registration). The Land Registry Act stipulates that land registries in the Republic of Croatia are kept electronically by means of a Real Property Registration and Cadastre Joint Information System (hereinafter: JIS) containing harmonized real property and cadastral data. A real property and land database is created through the electronic entry of paper-based data. i.e. integration of real property and cadastral data into a single database. Hence, the protection of real property transfers is enhanced since the legal status of the land and all accompanying restrictions (concessions, public property status etc.) can be obtained in one place. The real property land database enables registration of every change to the real property without the need to inform both the land registration court and cadastre thereabout. The Real Property Registration and Cadastre Joint Information System is jointly coordinated and managed by the Ministry of Justice and Administration of the Republic of Croatia and the State Geodetic Administration. The Land Registry Act sets forth that the Republic of Croatia is strictly liable for any damage arising from flaws in keeping land registries. Such damage can occur if it comes to errors or malfunctions in the respective joint information system. This paper investigates the appropriateness of the measures for protection of the Real Property Registration and Cadastre Joint Information System and the general rules for security and control of the access to the said system, and analyse the risk of compromising it. Regarding the liability of the Republic of Croatia for any damage pertaining to flaws in the land records management, the paper depicts the model of defining the liability for any damage suffered by the holders of ownership rights due to unauthorized access to the said joint information system. The paper also sheds light on the advantages and disadvantages of the model for defining fault and strict liability in the above case and examines some pending issues relating to the applicable model for defining such damage liability de lege lata as well as possible legal solutions and the potential need for intervention by the legislator de lege ferenda.

References

 


Books and articles


Antonić, Lj. (2005). Uspostava baze zemljišnoknjižnih podataka. Treći hrvatski kongres o katastru s međunarodnim sudjelovanjem. Zagreb: 2005. 73-80.


Antonić, Lj. (2006). Projekt sređivanja i digitalizacije zemljišnih knjiga. Zagreb: Arhivski vjesnik, Vol. 49 No. 1. 77-90.


Bracanović, T. (2021). Umjetna inteligencija, medicina i autonomija. Zagreb: Nova prisutnost, Vol. XIX No. 1. 63-75.


Ćepulić, E., Roksandić Vidlička, S., Babić, T. (2008). Skandinavski model osiguranja od medicinske greške – može li zaživjeti u okviru naših propisa. U: Barbić, J. (ur.) Građanskopravna odgovornost u medicini. Zagreb: Hrvatska akademija znanosti i umjetnosti, Znanstveno vijeće za državnu upravu, pravosuđe i vladavinu prava. 125-133.


Crnić, I. (2006). Zakon o obveznim odnosima Napomene, komentari, sudska praksa i prilozi. Zagreb: Organizator.


Death, D. (2017). Information Security Handbook. Packt Publishing


Dika, M. (2006). Zajednička načela registarskog postupovnog prava. U: Josipović, T. (ur.) Hrvatsko registarsko pravo. Zagreb: Narodne novine. 29-39.


Gavella, N., Josipović, T., Gliha, I., Belaj, V., Stipković, Z. (2007). Stvarno pravo. Zagreb: Narodne novine.


Josipović, T. (2001). Zemljišnoknjižno pravo. Zagreb: Informator.


Josipović, T. (2006). Zajednička načela registarskog materijalnog prava. U: Josipović, T. (ur.) Hrvatsko registarsko pravo. Zagreb: Narodne novine. 1-28.


Klarić, P., Vedriš, M. (2006). Građansko pravo. Zagreb: Narodne novine.


Pichler, D. (2018). Objective Liability For Damages in Medicine and Prevention of Violation of Healthcare Rules (Medical Errors). Niš: Zbornik radova Pravnog fakulteta u Nišu, br. 79. 241-252


Pichler, D. (2022). Novo zemljišnoknjižno uređenje. Osijek: Pravni fakultet.


Proso, M. (2009). Sustavi osiguranja od odštetne odgovornosti u zdravstvenoj djelatnosti. Split: Zbornik radova Pravnog fakulteta Sveučilišta u Splitu, god. 46, br. 2. 359-372.


Šimundić, S., Franjić, S. (2009). Računalni kriminalitet. Split: Pravni fakultet.


Triva, S. (1978). Građansko parnično procesno pravo. Zagreb: Narode novine.


Verwoerd, T. (1999). Active Network Security. University of Canterbury


Legal sources and technical standards


Act on State Survey and the Real Property Cadastre, Official Gazette no. 112/18, 39/22.


Act on the Ratification of the Loan Agreement (Real Property Registration and Cadastre Project) between the Republic of Croatia and International Bank for Reconstruction and Development, Official Gazette, International treaties no. 2/2003.


Agreement on the Operation and Servicing of the Computing- and Communication-Based e-Infrastructure for the Application System Real Property Registration and Cadastre Joint Information System (JIS) without a Disaster Recovery (DR) Site, Class: 150-30/22-01/73, File no: APIS IT-06-04-22-1 od 29. 12. 2022.


Civil Procedure Act, Official Gazette of the Socialist Federal Republic of Yugoslavia no. 4/77, 36/77, 6/80, 36/80, 43/82, 69/82, 58/84, 74/87, 57/89, 20/90, 27/90, 35/91 and Official Gazette of the Republic of Croatia no. 53/91, 91/92, 58/93, 112/99, 88/01, 117/03, 88/05, 02/07, 84/08, 96/08, 123/08, 57/11, 148/11, 25/13, 89/14, 70/19, 80/22, 114/22.


ISO/IEC 27001 – Information security management system.


ITU-T recommendation X.800, Security Architecture for OSI.


Land Registry Act, Official Gazette no. 63/19, 128/22.


Ordinance on e-Services for Users and Authorized Users of the JIS, Official Gazette no. 108/19.


Ordinance on the Content and Form of Cadastral Documentation, Official Gazette no. 142/08, 148/09.


Ordinance on the Organization and Operations of the Real Property Registration and Cadastre Joint Information System, Official Gazette no. 107/10.


Regulation on the Tariff of Court Fees, Official Gazette no. 53/19, 92/21.


RFC 5905 Network Time Protocol Version 4: Protocol and Algorithms Specification.


Rulebook of the Real Property Registration and Cadastre Joint Information System, Official Gazette no. 6/21.


Web sources


http://www.uredjenazemlja.hr/default.aspx?id=7 (accessed on 30 March 2023)


https://www.fina.hr/e-gradani (accessed on 25 March 2023)

Published
2023/10/19
Section
Original Scientific Paper