ELECTION OF CONSTITUTIONAL COURT JUDGES AS A GUARANTEE OF CONSTITUTIONAL COURT INDEPEDENCE
Abstract
In a system of government based on the principle of separation and balance of power, the constitutional court is considered to be an autonomous and independent constitutional authority. The independence of the constitutional court also implies the independence of its members from all other power holders and from the state bodies that participated in their election. The election of judges of the Constitutional Court is one of the most important guarantees of its independence. In addition, the selection of the Constitutional Court judges is a guarantee securing its legitimacy, preservation of its function as a politically neutral government, as well as the selection of persons with appropriate professional and personal qualities. The paper analyzes the legal requirements that judges must meet in order to qualify for this important judicial position, different election models, and the length of judicial mandates. After providing an overview of the comparative law solutions on this matter, the author focuses on the rules provided in the Constitution of the Republic of Serbia (2006). The aim of the research is to analyze the existing constitutional and legal provisions of other countries and compare them with the provisions in Serbia in order to address the following question: what is the key to the survival of this institution as an independent, impartial, politically neutral and professional authority.
References
Venice Commission. Draft law on the Constitutional court of the Republic of Serbia, comments by MS Hanna Suchocka, Opinion No. 445/2007. Преузето 30.03.2024. https://www.venice.coe.int/webforms/documents/default.aspx?pdffile=CDL(2007)067-e
Đurić, V. (2022). Izbor i imenovanje sudija Ustavnog suda u RS. Zbornik radova Kopaoničke škole Prirodnog prava – Slobodan Perović. Beograd: Kopaonička škola prirodnog prava – Slobodan Perović. (III). 607-624.
Закон о Уставном суду, ,,Сл. гласник РС“, 109/2007, 99/2011, 18/2013 - одлука УС, 103/2015, 40/2015 - др. закон, 10/2023 и 92/2023
Кутлешић, В. (2013). Услови за избор судија уставних судова – упоредна анализа 51 устава. Зборник радова Улога и значај уставног суда у очувању владавине права, округли сто. Београд: Уставни суд.
Marković, G. (2022). On the methods of selection of judges of constitutional courts. Collectio of Papers ,,Controversies od The contemporary Law“. E. Sarajevo. 371-395.
Марковић, (2007). Уставни суд у Уставу Републике Србије од 2006. године. Анали Правног факултета у Београду. 2 (LV). 19 – 56.
Nikolić, O. (2017). Položaj sudije ustavnog suda – uporednopravna analiza. Strani pravni život. Beograd: Institut za uporedno pravo.
Орловић, С. (2017). Правни положај и реалност Уставног суда Србије. Српска политичка мисао. Београд: Институт за политичке студије.
Петров, В. (2022). Уставно право. Београд: Правни факултет Универзитета у Београду.
Petrov, V. (2013). ,,Istaknuti pravnik'' – poseban uslov za izbor sudija Ustavnog suda ili prazna ustavna norma. NBP – Žurnal za kriminalistiku i pravo, Kriminalističko-policijska akademija. Beograd: Kriminalističko – policijska akademija. 41–52.
Симовић, Д. (2013). Проблем политизације и састав Уставног судства. Зборник радова Улога и значај уставног суда у очувању владавине права, округли сто. Београд: Уставни суд.
Стојановић, Д. (2018). Да ли и како реформисати Уставни сад? Зборник радова Правног факултета у Нишу. 78 (LVIII). 31-46.
Устав Републике Србије, „Службени гласник РС“, бр. 98/2006 и 115/2021
Џакић, Т. (2019). Гарантије независности уставних судова. Докторска дисертација. Београд. Правни факултет Универзитета у Београду.