CONTROVERSIES IN THE LEGAL REGULATION OF SAME-SEX COUPLES IN THE REPUBLIC OF SERBIA IN LIGHT OF INTERNATIONAL LAW AND COMPARATIVE LAW
Abstract
Marriage and familiy are institutions which are continually evolving. Social reality points to the fact that the traditional concept of marriage does not have the capacity to recognize the full complexity of interpersonal relationships. Hence the aspiration for marriage to be equalized with common law marriages, including long term unions between individuals of the same sex. The European Court of Human Rights has greatly contributed to the improvement of the legal position of same-sex partners. To date, the European Court has not equalized same-sex unions with marriage, however it has foreseen that same-sex couples have to be legally recognized so that their relationship would be protected. Member states are not obliged to recognize same-sex marriages, however they have an obligation to institutionalize same-sex unions, for the purpose of protecting the rights and interests of those individuals who are part of them.
The intent is to legally regulate personal and the property rights of same-sex couples, in accordance with the obligations of the Republic of Serbia which emanate from the application of the European Convention on Human Rights. However, the overall impression is that the Draft Law on Same-Sex Unions does not contain consistent and well thought out solutions. Analyzed from the aspect of family law, there are significant criticisms with respect to the currently proposed draft law, particularly with regards to the exercising of parental rights. Although the Draft Law does not foresee the possibility of adopting children, the question is raised as to the basis on which a partner of the child’s parent obtains authorities vested by way of parental rights. A belief remains that due to the far-reaching consequences, the process of legally regulating same-sex unions must evolve with great care, especially as this remains an extremely controversial topic in Serbian society.
References
Bubić Suzana, „Uloga Evropskog suda za ljudska prava u priznavanju istopolnih zajednica“, u: Bubić Suzana (ur.), Odjeci prakse Evropskog sudaza ljudska prava u nacionalnim porodičnim pravima, Mostar 2017, 47-68.
Cvejić-Jančić Olga, „Zajednice života lica istog pola – trendovi u regulisanju porodično-pravnog statusa ovih zajednica u savremenom pravu“, Pravni život, 10/2019, 61-84.
Цвејић-Јанчић Олга, „Брак и развод између прошлости и будућности“, Зборник радова Правног факултета у Новом Саду, 2/2009, 63-88.
Digoix Marie, “Introduction – LGBT Questions and the Family“, in Digoix Marie (ed.), Same-Sex Families and Legal Recognition in Europe, Springer 2020, 1-9.
Durham W. Cole, Smith Robert, Duncan William, A Comparative Analysis of Laws Pertaining to Same-Sex Unions, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2409282 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2409282.
Džajić Ljiljana, Đorđević Aleksandra, Šenk Maja, Analiza pravno-političke situacije u Republici Srbiji u kontekstu zakonskog regulisanja istopolnih partnerstava, Labris – organizacija za lezbejska ljudska prava, Beograd 2021.
Gajin Saša, Model zakona o registrovanim istopolnim zajednicama, Centar za unapređenje pravnih studija, Beograd 2013.
Eskridge Jr. William, “Comparative Law and the Same-Sex Marriage Debate: A Step-by-Step Approach Toward State Recognition”, McGeorge Law Review, 31(3)/2000, 641-672.
Johnson Paul, Homosexuality and the European Court of Human Rights, Routledge, 2013.
Jovanović Marko, „Inostrane registrovane istopolne zajednice života pred kolizionim pravilima srpskog međunarodnog privatnog prava: crno-beli odraz slike duginih boja?“, Liber amicorum Gašo Knežević, Pravni fakultet Univerziteta u Beogradu, Beograd 2016, 167-190.
Hamilton Frances, “Strategies to achieve same-sex marriage and the method of incrementalist change”, Journal of Transnational Law and Policy, 25/2015-2016, 121-153.
Јанчић Меланија, Забрана дискриминације на основу сексуалне оријентације и родног идентитета – теорија и пракса, Нови Сад 2020.
Knežević Gašo, Pavić Vladimir, „Homoseksualni brakovi u međunarodnom privatnom pravu Srbije“, u: Knez Rajko, Kraljić Suzana, Stojanović Dušan (ur.), Evropski sodni prostor, Pravna fakulteta Univerze v Mariboru, Maribor 2005, 79-87.
Koppelman Andrew, “Judging the Case Against Same-Sex Marriage”, University of Illinois law review, 2/2014, 431-465.
Kovaček Stanić Gordana, Samardžić Sandra, „Marriage in Serbian Law and in Comparative Perspective”, Zbornik radova Pravnog fakulteta u Novom Sadu, 2/2020, 545-560.
Ковачек-Станић Гордана, Породично право, партнерско, дечје и старатељско, Правни факултет у Новом Саду, Нови Сад 2014.
Крстић Ивана, Забрана дискриминације у међународном и домаћем праву, Београд 2018.
Kumwenda Rosmery, Biti LGBTI u Istočnoj Evropi: Izveštaj za Srbiju, United Nations Development Programme, Beograd 2017.
Mršević Zorica, Ka demokratskom društvu – istopolne porodice, Institut društvenih nuka, Beograd 2009.
Petrašević Tunjica, Duić Dunja, Buljan Ena, „Prava istopolnih zajednica u Europskoj Uniji s posebnim osvrtom na Republiku Hrvatsku“, Strani pravni život, 3/2017, 145-169.
Pettinicchio David, “Current Explanations for the Variation in Same-Sex Marriage Policies in Western Countries”, Comparative Sociology, 11/2012, 526-557.
Поповић Драгољуб, Маринковић Танасије, Радојевић Мијодраг (ур.), Коментар Конвенције за заштиту људских права и основних слобода, Службени гласник, Београд 2017.
Saez Macarena, “Same-Sex Marriage, Same-Sex Cohabitation, and Same-Sex Families Around the World: Why ‘Same’ is so Different?”, American University Journal of Gender, Social Policy & the Law, 19(1)/2011, 1-54.
Самарџић Сандра, „Права истополних партнера у Европској Унији и Србији у области брачног права“, Зборник радова Правног факултета у Новом Саду, 3/2013, 429-446.
Симовић Дарко, Зекавица Радомир, Људска права, Београд 2020.
Shahid Masuma, “The Right to Same-Sex Marriage: Assessing the European Court of Human Rights’ Consensus-Based Analysis in Recent Judgments Concerning Equal Marriage Rights”, Erasmus Law Review, 3/2017, 184-198.
Scherpe Jens M., “The Legal Recognition of Same-Sex Couples in Europe and the Role of the European Court of Human Rights”, The Equal Rights Review, 10/2013, 83-96.
Врзић Никола, „Негативно мишљење“, Печат, 14. мај 2021, 6-7.
Waaldijk Kees, “What First, What Later? Patterns in the Legal Recognition of Same-Sex Partners in European Countries”, in Marie Digoix (ed.), Same-Sex Families and Legal Recognition in Europe, Springer 2020, 11-44.
Won Shin Jae, “Coming out of the Closet: A Comparative Analysis of Marriage Equality Between the East and West”, International Law and Politics, 49/2017, 1119-1156.