Legal system of the World Trade Organization and electronic commerce
Abstract
The paper discusses several important issues related to the regulating of electronic commerce and their incorporation into the WTO legal system. First of all, the subject of the study is the relevance of the existing legal framework for this new area, with a special focus on the General Agreement on Trade in Services. Within that framework, the approach to the practice of dispute resolution in the given segment is considered. The paper also discusses the institutional efforts undertaken in the WTO with the aim of regulating electronic commerce. In particular, some of the possible courses of action are systematized and critically analyzed and suggestions are made for realistically feasible solutions to the problem of legal regulation in the given area.
The paper concludes that electronic trade has posed a complex legal challenge to the WTO, which must be answered urgently and as comprehensively as possible. However, the existing legal rules of this organization are only partially applicable to the given area. The attempts to extend the relevance of the given rules through the practice of dispute resolution in WTO have a limited scope. On the other hand, the activities on institutional improvement through negotiations in the WTO are blocked due to the different positions of the member countries. Therefore, we are of the opinion it necessary to create a realistic approach that would be widely acceptable, and which would combine the development of the most general rules, while simultaneously resolving practical issues related to electronic commerce.
References
Bashar, H. Malkwaj „E-Commerce in Light of International Trade Agreements: The WTO and the United States-Jordan Free Trade Agreement“, 15 INT'l J.L. & INFO. TECH. 153, 2007
Celli, Umberto Jr. „Technologies and the Trade in Goods and Services in the WTO“, 17 BRAZ. J. INT'l L. 391, 2020
Fefer, Rachel F. „Internet regimes and WTO E-commerce negotiations“, Congressional Research Service, 62, 2020
Ismail, Yasmin „E-commerce in the World Trade Organization“, International Institute for Systainaable Development and CUTS International, 1-2., 2020
Janow, M. E.; Mavroidis,
P. C. „Digital trade, e-commerce, the WTO and regional frameworks“, World Trade Review, 18(S1), S1-S7, 2019
Kelly, J. Patrick „Judicial activism at the World Trade Organization: Developing principles of self-restraint“, Nw. J. Int'l L. & Bus., 22, 353., 2001
Mai, Stefan International co-ordination of e-commerce (No. 2002/3). IWP Discussion Paper, 2002
Marengo, Federico „Regulating Data Transfers through the International Trade Regime“, 17 Manchester J. INT'l ECON. L. 266, 2020
Mattoo, Aaditya; Schuknecht Ludger “Trade Policies for Electronic Commerce 10”, (World Bank Policy Research Working Papers, Paper No. 2380, 2000).
McRae, Donald M. „The WTO in International Law: Tradition Continued or New Frontier?“, 3 J. INT'L. ECON. L. 27,
Messerlin, Patrick A. „Three Variations on 'the Future of the WTO'“, 8 J. INT'l ECON. L. 299, 2005
Mickutė, Karolina „The Role of the WTO DSB in Modernizing WTO Law on E-Commerce“, International Comparative Jurispru-dence, 5(2), 119-126, 2019
Mitchell, D. Andrew „Towards Compatibility: The Future of Electronic Commerce Within the Global Trading System“, 4 J. INT’L ECON. L. 683, 2001
Mitchell, D. Andrew; Mishra, Neha „Data at the Docks: Modernizing International Trade Law for the Digital Economy“, 20 VAND. J. ENT. & TECH. L. 1073, 2018
Mulopulos, Sam „Digital Trade Zones: Answering Impediments to International Trade in Information“, 21 CHAP. L. REV. 443, 2018
Neeraj, Rajan Sabitha „Trade Rules for the Digital Economy: Charting New Waters at the WTO“, 18 WORLD TRADE REV. S121, 2019
Peng, Shin-yi „Regulating new services through litigation? Electronic commerce as a case study on the evaluation of ‘judicial activism’ in the WTO“, Journal of World Trade, 2014
Staiger, Robert W. „Does Digital Trade Change the Purpose oF a Trade Agreement?(Very Preliminary).“, 2021
Trachtman, Joel „The Domain of WTO Dispute Resolution“, 40 HARV. INT'L L. J. 333, n.41, 1999
Weber, Rolf H. „International E-Trade“, 41 INT'l LAW. 845, 2007
Winn, Јane K. „Introduction: Borderless Electronic Commerce Symposium“, 35 INT'l L. 1, 2001
Zhao, Yun „Liberalization of Electronic Commerce in Mainland China and Hong Kong under the WTO-CEPA Regime“, 19 INT'l REV. L. Computers & TECH. 183, 2005
Zheng, Wentong „The Digital Challenge to International Trade Law“, 52 N.Y.U. J. INT'l L. & POL. 539, 2020