Applicable Law for Construction Contracts under FIDIC General Conditions – the Role of Chosen Law
Abstract
In academic literature on construction contracts governed by the FIDIC General Conditions, extensive attention has been given to dispute resolution, particularly the various mechanisms established within these conditions. Nevertheless, the question of the applicable law governing the substantive aspects of disputes remains largely underexplored. The FIDIC General Conditions allow parties to select the law of a specific state or jurisdiction to govern their contractual relationship. This choice of law plays a crucial role in shaping the interpretation and application of FIDIC contracts. While FIDIC contracts are meticulously designed to provide a comprehensive legal and technical framework for international construction projects, they do not operate in a legal vacuum. Instead, they are subject to the constraints and requirements of the selected national law. This paper examines how the applicable law influences key aspects of FIDIC contracts, particularly by enforcing mandatory legal norms that override the default provisions of the FIDIC General Conditions and by shaping the interpretation of legal concepts and abstract contractual terms within these standard conditions. Furthermore, the paper explores whether the UNIDROIT Principles of International Commercial Contracts can be chosen as the governing legal framework for FIDIC contracts and assesses their role in international construction disputes. The analysis underscores that the selection of applicable law is far more than a formality, it is a fundamental factor in the functioning of the FIDIC contractual system, with profound implications for dispute resolution, contract enforcement and legal certainty throughout the lifecycle of international construction projects.
References
Battrick, P., Duggan, P., The rainbow suite - The 1999 FIDIC suite, https://www.fidic.org/sites/default/files/FIDIC-rainbow-suite-2012.pdf, 7. март 2025.
Brozolo, L. G. R, „International Commercial Arbitration and Private International Law“, Cambridge Compendium of International Commercial and Investment Arbitration, (eds. Kröll, S., Bjorklund AK. & Ferrari F.), Cambridge University Press, 2023.
Варади, Т., Бордаш, Б., Кнежевић, Г., Павић, В, Међународно приватно право, Правни факултет Универзитета у Београду, Београд, 2020.
Вукадиновић, С. „Улога међународних организација и удружења у развоју стандардизованих модела уговора с посебним освртом на FIDIC-ове уговор“, Pravo i javne delatnosti: liber amicorum Jovica Trkulja, (ур. Вукадиновић, С,) Правни факултет Универзитета у Београду и Институт за упоредно право, Београд, 2024.
Дика, М., Кнежевић, Г., Стојановић, С, Коментар Закона о међународном приватном и процесном праву, Номос, Београд, 1991.
Ђорђевић, М., „Решавање спорова из уговора о грађењу“, Савремени проблеми правног система Србије – прилози пројекту 2022. Београд, 2023.
Ђорђевић, С., Мешкић, З., Међународно приватно право – општи део, Крагујевац, 2016.
Живановић Ф. М., „Специфичности осигурања у оквиру FIDIC-ове "Црвене књиге" - услови уговарања за грађевинске и остале техничке радове по пројекту наручиоца (издање из 1999. године)“, Страни правни живот 3/2023.
International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) - Dispute Resolution 2023 Statistics, 2024, https://iccwbo.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/3/2024/06/2023-Statistics_ICC_Dispute-Resolution_991.pdf, 7. март 2025.
Jakšić, A., Jovanović, S., „The FIDIC DAB: Legal Nature, Effects and Interaction with Arbitration Agreement“, Pravo i privreda 4/2024.
Јакшић, А., Међународно приватно право, Службени гласник, Београд, 2021.
Kromann Reumert, FIDIC White Book: What makes the choice of background law important?, https://kromannreumert.com/en/knowledge/articles/fidic-white-book-what-makes-the-choice-of-background-law-important, 5. март 2025.
Никчевић, Ј., „Претходни (пред-арбитражни) поступак за решавање спорова према FIDIC-овим општим условима уговора“, Право и привреда 7–9/2011.
Никчевић, Ј., „Разграничење уговора о делу и уговора о продаји“, Ревија Копаоничке школе природног права 1/2019.
Osman, A. M., Fidic contracts in the light of islamic laws, 2023, https://www.lextalk.world/post/fidic-contracts-in-the-light-of-islamic-laws, 18. март 2025.
Seppälä R. C., „The Arbitration Clause in the FIDIC Contract for Major Works“, Asian Dispute Review 2/2006.
Seppälä R. C., Legal Concerns, FIDIC Conditions of Contract and the Dispute Adjudication Procedure, London, 2003.
Seppälä R. C., „Chapter II: Applicable Law“, The FIDIC Red Book Contract: An International
Clause-by-Clause Commentary, Kluwer Law International, 2023.
Seppälä R. C., „Chapter III: Contract Interpretation“, The FIDIC Red Book Contract: An International Clause-by- Clause Commentary, Kluwer Law International, 2023.
Станивуковић, М., Живковић, М., Међународно приватно право – општи део, Службени гласник, 2010.
Stanivuković, M., „Choice of Court Convention (HCCC) and Arbitration. Anali Pravnog Fakulteta Univerziteta u Zenici“, Issue 18, 2016.
Stanivuković, M., „Adjudication as a preliminary step to arbitration: a case of first impression in Serbia“, Harmonizacija srpskog i mađarskog prava sa pravom Evropske unije, (ur. Ristivojević, B.), Pravni fakultet u Novom Sadu, Novi Sad, 2018.
Станивуковић, М., “Нови међународни привредни судови“, Право и привреда 2/2024.
Stojković, S., „FIDIC Force Majeure Clause from the Viewpoint of Serbian Law“, Anali Pravnog fakulteta u Beogradu 3/2023.
Sunna, E., Al Saadoon, O., FIDIC in the Middle-East, FIDIC, 2007, https://fidic.org/sites/default/files/FIDIC in the Middle-East.pdf, 18. март 2025.
Shahrour, A., FIDIC in Civil Law Jurisdictions: Justifiable or Challenging?, 2021, https://afitac.com/2021/03/14/fidic-in-civil-law-jurisdictions-justifiable-or-challenging/, 13. март 2025.
Schoups, M., de Buyzer G., van de Bos, P. „Demystifying construction disputes and FIDIC“, Liber Amicorum CEPANI (1969–2019): 50 Years of Solutions, (eds. De Meulemeester, D., Berlingin, M.), Wolters Kluwer, Alphen aan den Rijn, 2019.
Tsirigos, A., Georgiadi, E. & Kollas, T., FIDIC Construction Contracts and Arbitration: The Role of Dispute Adjudication Boards and the Importance of Governing Law, Kluwer Arbitration Blog, 2017, https://arbitrationblog.kluwerarbitration.com/2017/09/26/fidic-construction-contracts-arbitration-role-dispute-adjudication-boards-importance-governing-law/, 1. март 2025.
Услови уговора за грађење, Издање усклађено за мултилатералне развојне банке, Општи услови, 2010.
FIDIC, Услови уговора у изградњи - FIDIC Црвена књига 1999, (FIDIC, Conditions of Contract for Construction for Building and Engineering Works Designed by the Employer, First Edition – FIDIC Red Book (First Edition), 1999).
FIDIC, Conditions of Contract for Construction for Building and Engineering Works Designed by the Employer, Second Edition – FIDIC Red Book (Second Edition), 2017.
FIDIC, FIDIC White Book (Client/Consultant Model Services Agreement), Fifth Edition, 2017.
FIDIC, The FIDIC Golden Principles, First Edition. Geneva, 2019.
FIDIC, FIDIC Rainbow Suite, ed. 2017 Second edition of the Red, Yellow & Silver Books, 2017, https://fidic.org/sites/default/files/press release_rainbow suite_2018_03.pdf, 7. март 2025.
Cotovelea, C. A. M. A., Comparative View between FIDIC 1999/2017 Editions, Part 1 – Constitution. Romanian Arbitration Journal 1/2011.