WHAT NEW IS BROUGHT BY THE AMENDMENTS TO THE LAW ON THE HIGH JUDICIAL AND PROSECUTORIAL COUNCIL OF BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA?
Abstract
Independence of the judiciary is one of the key preconditions of the Rule of Law. However, fostering the “culture“ of judicial independence has to be accompanied by constant efforts to develop the mechanisms and “culture“ of judicial accountability and integrity. This need is particularly highlighted in post-authoritarian societies where the independence of the judiciary rests on the unstable foundations of an authoritarian past characterized by the systematic undermining of judicial independence.
In recent decades, the means for strengthening judicial independence has been recognized in establishing judicial councils. Judicial councils, independent bodies whose majority of members come from the judiciary, have been “designed to insulate the functions of appointment, promotion and discipline of judges from the partisan political process while ensuring some level of accountability“ (Garoupa, Ginsberg). In recent years, however, an increasing number of authors have begun to acknowledge that the establishment of judicial councils may lead to the emergence of new channels of politicization of the judiciary, which brings to the fore the issue of the accountability of the aforementioned bodies.
The paper analyzes provisions of the Law on Amendments to the Law on the High Judicial and Prosecutorial Council of Bosnia and Herzegovina (HJSC BiH), adopted in 2023, which regulate the disciplinary responsibility of judges and the Council members, as well as the procedure of dismissal of the members of the HJSC BiH. The paper will also analyze other provisions of this law, which aim to suppress corruption in the judiciary and strengthen the integrity of the judicial officeholders.
References
Књиге и чланци
Bell, Ј. (2006). Judiciaries within Europe: A comparative review, Cambridge - New York: Cambridge University Press.
Bobek, M., Kosař, D. (2014). „Global solutions, local damages: a critical study in judicial councils in Central and Eastern Europe“, German Law Journal 15(7)
Cappelletti, M. (1983). “Who Watches the Watchmen - A Comparative Study on Judicial Responsibility”, American Journal of Comparative Law Vol. 31(1)
Galiot,M., Čović, S., Juras, D. (2013). „Kaznena i stegovna (disciplinska) odgovornost sudaca“, Zbornik Pravnog fakulteta Sveučilišta u Rijeci 34(2)
Garoupa, N., Ginsburg, T (2009). “Guarding the guardians: Judicial councils and judicial independence”, The American Journal of Comparative Law 57(1)
Garoupa, N., Ginsburg, T. (2009). „The comparative law and economics of judicial councils“, Berkeley Journal of International Law 27(1)
Kosař, D. (2018). “Beyond Judicial Councils: Forms, Rationales and Impact of Judicial Self-Governance in Europe”, German Law Journal 19(7)
Kosař, D. (2016). Perils of Judicial Self-Government in Transitional Societies, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Mastracci, M. (2020). “Judiciary Saga in Poland: An Affair Torn between European Standards and ECtHR Criteria”, Polish Review of International & European Law 9.
Милинковић, И. (2021). Огледи из правне етике I: Судијска етика, Бања Лука: Правни факултет Универзитета у Бањој Луци.
Pérez, A.T. (2018). “Judicial self-government and judicial independence: The political capture of the general council of the judiciary in Spain”, German Law Journal 19(7)
Chavez, R.B. (2008). “The Rule of Law and Courts in Democratizing Regimes”, in The Oxford Handbook of Law and Politics, edited by Whittington, K.E., Kelemen, R.D., Caldeira, G.A., Oxford University Press.
Прописи, судска пракса и пракса других органа
Venice Commission, Opinion no. 648/2011 on Legal Certainty and the Independence of the Judiciary in Bosnia and Herzegovina (paragraph 93) (2012); доступно на: https://www.venice.coe.int/webforms/documents/?pdf=CDL-AD(2012)014-e); преузето: 28.10.2023. године;
Venice Commission, Opinion no. 712/2013 on the draft Law on the High Judicial and Prosecutorial Council of Bosnia and Herzegovina (2014); доступно на: https://www.venice.coe.int/webforms/documents/default.aspx?pdffile=CDL-AD(2014)008-e); преузето: 28.10.2023. године;
GRECO – Group of States against Corruption, Evaluation Report: Bosnia and Herzegovina, 2016
Закон о Високом судском и тужилачком савјету БиХ, Службени гласник БиХ, бр. 25/2004, 93/2005, 48/2007, 15/08 и 68/23.
Закон о измјенама и допунама Закона о Високом судском и тужилачком савјету БиХ, Службени гласник БиХ, бр. 68/23.
Judiciary System Act of the Republic of Bulgaria; доступно на: https://vss.justice.bg/en/page/view/2073 (преузето: 27.11.2023. године);
Network of Councils for the Judiciary (ENCJ ), Councils for the Judiciary Report 2010-2011, Rome (2011); доступно на: https://www.encj.eu/images/stories/pdf/workinggroups/ report_project_team_councils_for_the_judiciary_2010_2011.pdf; преузето: 01.10.2023. године;
Одлука Уставног суда БиХ, бр. АП 633/04, Службени гласник БиХ, бр. 73/05.
Препорука Европске комисије заснована на стручној анализи дисциплинских поступака у БиХ; доступно на: https://pravosudje.ba/vstvfo/Sc/10001/kategorije-vijesti/10144/115100 (преузето 23.11.2023. године)
Пословник ВСТС БиХ – пречишћен текст; доступно на: https://vstv.pravosudje.ba/ vstvfo/Sc/141/kategorije-vijesti/1172/1180/4570; преузето: 12.12.2023. године;
Рјешење Агенцује за заштиту личних података у БиХ од 05.03.2019. године;
доступно на: http://www.azlp.ba/rjesenja/Archive.aspx?langTag=sr-SP-Cyrl&template_id=149&pageIndex=4 (преузето: 24.11.2023. године);
The Court of Justice of the European Union, Judgment in Joined Cases C-585/18, C-624/18 and C-625/18 (A.K. v Krajowa Rada Sądownictwa, and CP and DO v Sąd Najwyższy) (2019); доступно на: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri= CELEX:62018CA0585; преузето: 10.10.2023. године)
Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe, Recommendation CM/Rec(2010)12: “Judges: independence, efficiency and responsibilities”; доступно на: https://rm.coe.int/cmrec-2010-12-on-independence-efficiency-responsibilites-of-judges/16809f007d; преузето: 21.11.2023. године;
Consultative Council of European Judges, Opinion no. 21 (2018) on preventing corruption among judges; доступно на: https://www.coe.int/en/web/ccje/ccje-opinions-and-magna-carta; преузето 23.11.2023. године;
Autori koji objavljuju u ovom časopisu pristaju na sledeće uslove:
- Autori zadržavaju autorska prava i pružaju časopisu pravo prvog objavljivanja rada i licenciraju ga "Creative Commons Attribution licencom" koja omogućava drugima da dele rad, uz uslov navođenja autorstva i izvornog objavljivanja u ovom časopisu.
- Autori mogu izraditi zasebne, ugovorne aranžmane za neekskluzivnu distribuciju članka objavljenog u časopisu (npr. postavljanje u institucionalni repozitorijum ili objavljivanje u knjizi), uz navođenje da je članak izvorno objavljen u ovom časopisu.
- Autorima je dozvoljeno da postave objavljeni članak onlajn (npr. u institucionalni repozitorijum ili na svoju internet stranicu) pre ili tokom postupka prijave rukopisa, s obzirom da takav postupak može voditi produktivnoj razmeni ideja i ranijoj i većoj citiranosti objavljenog članka.